Character Development in Tan's and Chekhov's Short Stories
This paper examines character development in two short stories drawn from Kennedy and Gioia's literary anthology: Amy Tan's "A Pair of Tickets" and Anton Chekhov's "The Lady with the Pet Dog." Through close reading, the paper traces the personal transformations of the central characters in each work. In Chekhov's story, Dmitrich Gurov evolves from a cynical womanizer into a man genuinely capable of love, while Anna Sergeyevna moves from pious restraint to emotional abandon. In Tan's story, Jing-Mei Woo undergoes a cultural and personal awakening as she travels to China and reconnects with her heritage and lost sisters. The paper compares the pace and nature of character change across both narratives.
- Introduction to the Literary Works: Introduces the anthology and two selected short stories
- Character Analysis in The Lady with the Pet Dog: Traces Gurov and Anna's transformation through illicit love
- Character Analysis in A Pair of Tickets: Examines Jing-Mei's cultural awakening and identity growth
- Conclusion: Contrasts pace and depth of change in both stories
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses direct textual quotations to ground its character observations in specific moments from each story, lending credibility to its claims about transformation.
- It maintains a comparative frame throughout, returning at the conclusion to contrast the pace and quality of character development across both works.
- The discussion of Jing-Mei's dual cultural identity is concrete and tied to plot events, making the abstract theme of heritage tangible for the reader.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative literary analysis by holding two distinct short stories up against each other using a single consistent lens — character development — rather than treating each work in complete isolation. This technique allows the conclusion to deliver a meaningful evaluative judgment about which narrative achieves smoother, more stable character growth.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing section introducing the anthology from which the stories are drawn. It then devotes a dedicated section to each story, analyzing the main characters in turn. A short conclusion synthesizes the comparison, contrasting the pacing and texture of character change in each work. The structure is clean and symmetrical, with the analytical body sections doing the primary argumentative work.
Introduction to the Literary Works
Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, and Drama by X. J. Kennedy and Dana Gioia is a wide-ranging literary anthology that includes student essays, brief author biographies, and reflections by authors on their own work, covering a broad range of ideas, topics, and literary forms and styles.
From this collection, this paper focuses on two short stories — A Pair of Tickets by Amy Tan and The Lady with the Pet Dog by Anton Chekhov — for thorough analysis. The following sections concentrate primarily on the character development and changes that occur in the principal characters of both works.
Character Analysis in The Lady with the Pet Dog
The Lady with the Pet Dog has two main characters around whom the entire plot is built. The character of Dmitrich Gurov highlights the fickle nature of a man deeply dissatisfied with his marriage who ends up pursuing a woman who is herself married. Through the illicit extra-marital affair shared by Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna, the author reveals the shortcomings of human beings and the temptations that life presents. Both characters develop side by side, with the male character introduced before the "lady with the pet dog." As the story unfolds, their personality transformations become unmistakable. The modest friendship that begins between the two gradually takes on a far more serious form. As the story reveals: "Then he looked at her intently, and suddenly embraced her and kissed her on the lips, and the moist fragrance of her flowers enveloped him at once; he looked round him anxiously, wondering if anyone had seen them" (196).
The attention-seeking behavior and frustrations that Anna Sergeyevna felt as a result of her unfulfilling married life led her to maintain contact with a man for whom the desire for female companionship transcended faith, religion, and rational understanding (Eclectic Literary Review). From mediocre and discontented individuals, the two characters are transformed into extraordinary lovers immersed in passionate affection.
Conclusion
In the former story, character development is not as fast-paced as in the latter. However, the main characters in The Lady with the Pet Dog develop more smoothly and with greater stability than the characters in A Pair of Tickets, in which the themes are conveyed more directly but the character changes are more abrupt. The character of Jing-Mei in A Pair of Tickets changes gradually once she immerses herself in the culture to which her roots belong and begins to see her surroundings in a new perspective (Themes). The character of Dmitrich Gurov changes gradually but clearly and smoothly. From a womanizer and a dissatisfied husband who is an insincere lover, he transforms into a deeply caring, passionate partner who comes to believe in the power of love and struggles to keep his emotions alive — even to the point of sustaining an illicit relationship.
Gurov's development is steady, and he transforms from a dishonest man into a compassionate soul. Similarly, Anna Sergeyevna changes from a pious, God-fearing woman into someone passionately consumed by love, who surrenders to her emotions and ultimately moves toward Gurov in order to satisfy her longing for affection. This is evident when, after being physically intimate with a man other than her husband for the first time, she says: "'God forgive me,' . . . 'It's terrible'" (Kennedy & Gioia, p. 196). At another point, the righteous side of her personality speaks through her words: "We are parting forever — it has to be, for we ought never have met" (Kennedy & Gioia, p. 198). Yet her transformation is confirmed when, at the story's end, she chooses to continue the relationship. As the text reads: "And Anna Sergeyevna began coming to see him in Moscow" (Kennedy & Gioia, p. 202).
Works Cited
Kennedy, X. J., and Dana Gioia. Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, and Drama. Longman, 2001.
Janet. Planet Papers Review. Retrieved April 5, 2003.
"Anton Chekhov's 'The Lady with the Pet Dog.'" Eclectic Literary Review, Fall/Winter 1998.
Themes. Monkey Notes from Pink Monkey Library. Retrieved April 5, 2003.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.