This paper examines the role of commercial contract law in shaping oil investment in Kuwait. It traces the constitutional and legislative framework governing Kuwait's oil sector, including the formation of the Kuwait Petroleum Corporation and its subsidiaries, and surveys Kuwait's efforts to attract foreign direct investment through legal reforms. The paper then provides a systematic analysis of general contract law principles — including offer, consideration, binding effect, terms, vitiating factors, breach, and remedies — applied to the specific context of the Kuwaiti oil industry. It concludes by assessing whether Kuwait's legal and regulatory environment is sufficiently flexible and attractive to increase foreign participation in its oil sector.
In the industries of natural resources and energy, the law of investment protection is of particularly great concern. According to statistics from July 2013, 25% of the cases registered with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) addressed issues concerning the gas, oil, and mining sectors. Moreover, another 12% of those cases were relevant to other energy sectors, including electric power.
Investments in the energy sector, including oil, are usually very capital-intensive and long-term in nature. They are also regulated at the highest levels and are of concern to the public, since valuable resources and essential services are involved. These are the main reasons why such investments are extremely vulnerable to national and governmental interference. The attributes of energy-sector investment increase the likelihood of conflicts arising from changing laws and regulatory policies over the duration of a project.
Given the nature of such investments, many activities in the energy sector will normally qualify for protection as part of applicable investment contracts. Disputes can surface in connection with grey areas that include hedging arrangements and pure services and sales contracts. In such circumstances, the outcome will depend on the specific nature of the activities in question and the specific definition of an eligible "investment" under the applicable investment agreement.
Oil has always been the most precious natural resource of the State of Kuwait. According to the Kuwaiti Constitution, the State owns and controls all oil resources. However, the State alone does not have the power to exploit, safeguard, and utilize those resources without legislative authority, as stated in Article 21 of the Kuwaiti Constitution and Law No. 1 of 1962. Accordingly, the right to monopolies or concessions for the exploitation of Kuwait's natural resources — including oil — can only be created by law, and only for a restricted period of time, as provided in Articles 152 and 153 of the Kuwaiti Constitution.
In 2012, Kuwait moved to amend its foreign direct investment law as the Persian Gulf oil producer launched a $111 billion plan to modernize the Kuwaiti economy. A senior official of the Kuwait Foreign Investment Bureau stated that foreign investors seeking important licenses face a very difficult and prolonged procedure, as well as challenges in obtaining the land required for their projects. The suggested amendments were intended to address these shortcomings.
The State of Kuwait expected private investors in oil to contribute nearly half of the four-year development program, which began in fiscal year 2010–2011, in order to diversify Kuwait's oil-reliant economy. Kuwait had passed a foreign direct investment law in 2001 to liberalize foreign ownership limits, and it was seeking investments in projects that included a $14 billion oil refinery. In 2007, the Kuwaiti parliament also passed a law reducing the tax burden on international companies for the first time in more than 50 years, cutting the corporate tax rate on foreign companies from 55% to 15%.
Despite these efforts, Kuwait was considered the lowest recipient of foreign direct investment among the six Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) states in 2010, even though it was the fourth-largest oil producer in the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries. Kuwait's stock of inward foreign direct investment was recorded at $6.5 billion according to data from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. By comparison, Saudi Arabia, the largest Arab economy, held $170.5 billion, and the United Arab Emirates held $76.2 billion.
When the Constitution was drafted, both the private sector and foreign oil companies held interests in Kuwait's oil resources pursuant to various concessions. In 1975, through a series of legislation and agreements, those rights reverted to the government of Kuwait and were subsequently represented by fully state-owned organizations, including the Kuwait Petroleum Corporation (KPC), the Petrochemicals Industries Company (PIC), the Kuwait National Petroleum Company (KNPC), and the Kuwait Oil Company (KOC).
There are many laws and regulations associated with direct investment in countries, including oil investment. This paper provides background on the situation of oil investment and its governing laws, both globally and in Kuwait specifically. When investment in any sector is contemplated, commercial and contract law plays a critical role. This paper explores contract and commercial law principles and considers them in relation to oil investment in Kuwait.
International commercial contracts are agreements for sale transactions made between parties in different countries. There are many methods by which companies can enter a foreign market, chosen after weighing risk, control, and transaction costs. These methods include direct export, the engagement of a foreign agent to distribute and sell, and the use of a foreign distributor to transact directly with customers. Companies can also manufacture products in a foreign country by establishing a local business or acquiring a foreign subsidiary. Other modes of market entry include licensing a local producer, entering a joint venture with a foreign entity, or deploying a franchise in the foreign country.
KPC was established in 1980 as a public corporation and is the primary actor in Kuwait's oil sector. Its objectives include engaging in all activities associated with the petroleum and hydrocarbon materials industries in all their stages, both in Kuwait and abroad, as permitted by Article 3 of Law No. 6 of 1980. Under Article 5 of the same law, KPC also has the right to engage in any activities that assist it in achieving its objectives, including forming partnerships with companies engaged in similar activities.
Historically, KOC, KNPC, and PIC were partially owned by the State in partnership with private investors. KNPC was established by government decree in 1960, with ownership split 60% State and 40% private sector. Its objectives were to participate in the oil industry inside and outside Kuwait, covering all stages of production including exploration, transportation, and refining. PIC was established in 1963 as a commercial company between the State and local private investors, with the purpose of creating a petrochemical industry for Kuwait. In 1974, the State entered into a Participation Agreement with Gulf Kuwait and BP Limited, resulting in the creation of KOC, whose objectives are to explore, exploit, refine, and produce oil for both the local market and for export. A series of legislative measures passed in the mid-1970s pursued the nationalization of the oil sector; as a result, KOC, KNPC, and PIC are now wholly owned by the State. By virtue of the 1980 law, KPC was established and all these companies were brought under its umbrella.
A contract is defined as an agreement that creates obligations enforceable by law. The fundamental elements of a contract are mutual assent, consideration, legality, and capacity. In some legal systems, consideration may be satisfied by a reasonably valid substitute. The potential remedies available when a contract is breached include general damages, consequential damages, reliance damages, and specific performance.
Contracts are, in essence, promises enforced by law. The law provides the parties to a contract with remedies in the event of breach, and assists them in recognizing their performance obligations. A contract comes into existence as a result of a duty or a promise exchanged by one or both parties. For a contract to be legally binding, a promise must be exchanged for sufficient consideration. Adequate consideration is understood as an advantage or detriment received by a party that reasonably and fairly induces the making of a promise or agreement. Promises that are purely gratuitous, for instance, are not enforceable contracts, since the personal satisfaction the promisor derives from making a gift does not constitute adequate consideration. However, some promises that do not technically qualify as contracts may in special circumstances be enforced through promissory estoppel, where one party has relied to their detriment on the assurances of the other.
In most cases, contracts are governed by common law (judge-made law), statutory law, and private law. Private law fundamentally comprises the terms and conditions upon which the parties have agreed. This private law has the potential to override many rules otherwise established by statute. Some contracts are required by statutory law to be in writing and executed with certain formalities, while in other cases parties may enter into a binding agreement without a formally signed written document.
The Ministry of Oil of Kuwait has made available to interested parties a complete document titled Kuwait Oil Company Policies and Regulations of Purchasing, published in 2008. This document contains all information that interested parties need to know about the law and legislation pertaining to oil investment in Kuwait, particularly with respect to contract law. The document is divided into various sections. Following an explanation of the document's purpose and standing instructions, Section 1 provides definitions; Section 2 explains material requests and the termination of contracts or agreements; Section 3 covers competitive procurement; Section 4 describes the blanket purchase order; Section 5 explains single-source procurement; Section 6 covers repair orders; Section 7 addresses emergency or major incident procurement; Section 8 covers vital procurement; Section 10 addresses cancellation of purchase orders; and Section 11 explains liquidated damages. Sections 12 and 13 address claims and invoices respectively. A section on regulatory provisions explains each article pertaining to oil investment rules and regulations in Kuwait.
According to commercial contract law more generally, a written business contract is also divided into several standard sections. The first section identifies the names of the parties. The second section sets out the details of the agreement. The third section provides the terms and conditions of the contract. The fourth section contains the signatures of both parties and the date of execution.
"Kuwait's three-tiered civil and Sharia court system"
"Terms, clauses, binding effect, and good faith duties"
"Breach types, mistake, duress, and available remedies"
As part of a national-level effort, Kuwait has created numerous public entities and organizations to devise policies monitoring the activities and performance of its oil sector. These include the Supreme Petroleum Council, established in 1974 by Emiri Decree. The Council's primary task is to set the general principles and policies for the oil sector within the framework of the national social and economic development plan. The process of sector governance continued with the establishment of the Ministry of Oil in 1986 as a separate ministry, distinct from the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. The Ministry exercises policies in association with the Supreme Petroleum Council and supervises all relevant public institutions.
As noted above, Kuwait is among the top oil producers in the Arab world, yet the revenue it receives from oil trade and exploitation relative to its peers remains comparatively low. This suggests that significant work remains to be done in the oil investment sector. Commercial and contract law, as well as the general laws of the State, play an important role in shaping the environment for oil investment. This paper has provided a general outline of business laws relevant to the oil and energy sector, and has explained the main principles of contract and commercial law as applied in Kuwait and internationally.
Under business law, when two parties enter into an agreement and promise each other specific performances and deliveries, they are legally bound to act in accordance with that agreement. In some cases, parties are required to set out the terms and conditions in writing so that clear evidence of the agreement exists. Penalties apply to any party that acts against the order of the court. Where a party breaches the contract, the remedies available under Kuwaiti law — damages, quantum meruit, specific performance, injunction, and repudiation — ensure that the innocent party can obtain redress.
It would not be an overstatement to say that Kuwait's legislation is relatively flexible and cooperative when it comes to inward investment. The country has been actively seeking to modernize its economy, which explains the significant liberalization seen in its investment, commercial, and contract laws in recent years. The availability of clear contractual remedies for breach is itself one factor that can attract foreign investors, since it provides certainty of redress. The overarching aim of these legislative reforms is to increase foreign direct investment in Kuwait, diversify the economy, and maximize returns from the country's most valuable natural resource.
You’re 53% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.