This paper examines several common business practices through the lens of the United Airlines case, in which competing locations bid for a firm's industrial base. It explores the economic and ethical dimensions of competitive incentive bidding, the broader phenomenon of outsourcing to low-cost labor markets such as China and India, and the limited influence ordinary citizens have over such decisions. The paper also analyzes why manufacturers tend to locate near their resources and retailers near their customers, and considers the drawbacks of each approach, ultimately arguing that a balanced, long-term strategy serves both businesses and communities better than purely profit-driven decisions.
The case provided in the article regarding United Airlines is just one of many examples of how firms react when they decide to either increase profits or avoid a loss. There are many points that can be raised in this scenario. The competition over which location will host the industrial base illustrates what different cities have to offer. Through this process, the firm can choose the best option available by assessing all bids — evaluating location, price, and quality of labor. Economically, the outcome can be beneficial for the firm and the winning bidder while remaining within legal boundaries; however, ethically, it may not be the best decision.
The United Airlines case serves as a useful lens for examining several broader business practices, including competitive incentive bidding, outsourcing, corporate location strategy, and the limited role of ordinary citizens in major economic decisions.
Consider a city that cannot offer a large financial incentive in the bidding process but has a significant pool of skilled labor and high unemployment. Such a city may be passed over simply because the firm prioritizes business advantage over social benefit. This is a very common phenomenon. Firms outsource their operations not only to avoid losses but also to secure substantial profits.
In the United States as a whole, this trend is causing widespread unemployment, as many companies choose to shift jobs to countries that offer cheap labor and stronger economic incentives. Countries such as China and India are top destinations for companies seeking to outsource their operations. In the case of United Airlines, state taxpayer money was involved; in other cases, private firms or individuals are implicated in financial incentives or payoffs.
In most cases, the only representation ordinary citizens receive comes through their respective government authorities — and many residents are unaware that these types of bidding processes are even taking place, let alone that they could participate in them. As a result, ordinary people have little or no influence over the major economic decisions being made on their behalf.
"Resource proximity gives manufacturers market advantages"
"Customer proximity drives retail competitiveness and feedback"
"Balance between proximity and broader market awareness needed"
You’re 44% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.