Children, Destruction, and Emotion in Greene and Lawrence
This essay compares and contrasts two short stories — Graham Greene's "The Destructors" and D.H. Lawrence's "The Rocking Horse Winner" — focusing on the emotional experiences of their characters. Both works feature children who are forced into premature maturity by adult circumstances, and both conclude with shocking acts of destruction. The essay examines how each story's children respond to the misery of the adults around them, how lovelessness and obsession replace healthy emotion, and how the destructive endings of each narrative can be compared and contrasted. The analysis reveals that in both stories, a lack of love gives way to destructive fixation, ultimately consuming the lives of those involved.
- Introduction: Framing the emotional comparison between both stories
- Children as Main Characters: Premature maturity of Trevor and Paul
- Adults in Misery: Adult unhappiness saturating each household
- The End: Destruction and Its Aftermath: Parallel destructions and the absence of love
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It establishes a clear comparative framework early, signaling exactly which dimensions — character emotion, adult misery, and destructive endings — will be analyzed.
- It balances comparison and contrast, noting both similarities (premature maturity in children, loveless households) and meaningful differences (death of a child vs. destruction of a home).
- It uses close reading of textual details — the whispering house, the laughing truck driver, Paul's rocking horse — to ground abstract claims about emotion in concrete narrative evidence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic comparative analysis: rather than summarizing each story separately, it groups both texts under shared conceptual headings (children, adults, endings) and moves fluidly between them within each section. This structure keeps the comparison active throughout rather than deferring it to a conclusion.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a brief introduction that frames the comparative task and previews the organizational plan. Two body sections follow — one focused on the child protagonists, one on the adult figures and their misery — each drawing on both texts. A final section addresses the endings, noting both parallel destructions and the key contrast between the death of a child and the ruin of an old man's life. The closing paragraph synthesizes the shared theme of lovelessness replaced by destructive obsession.
Introduction
On the surface, "The Destructors" by Graham Greene and "The Rocking Horse Winner" by D.H. Lawrence have little in common. However, when the emotional impact of each plot on the various characters is considered, it becomes clear that there are many points of comparison. This essay compares and contrasts the emotions experienced by selected characters in each story. Issues such as the roles of children and adults, and the emotions each group experiences, are considered first. This is followed by a discussion of the endings of the two works. Each story concludes in a destruction that can be both compared and contrasted with the other.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.