Skip to main content
Literature Review Undergraduate 1,620 words

Inclusion Strategies and Student Performance in Elementary Schools

~9 min read 6 sections Education · Inclusive Education
Abstract

This paper reviews literature on the effects of inclusive education on student performance at the elementary school level. Drawing on multiple empirical studies, it examines four interconnected areas: social outcomes for both students with disabilities and their mainstream peers, effective teaching practices in inclusive environments, the role of teacher collaboration, and teacher attitudes toward inclusion. The review finds that while inclusive classrooms generally produce positive social outcomes and have theoretical advantages over traditional pull-out strategies, empirical evidence regarding academic performance remains inconclusive. The paper identifies key gaps in the literature and calls for further investigation with larger sample sizes, broader comparison groups, and greater focus on collaborative teaching models.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction to Inclusion in Education: Overview of inclusion debate and research gaps
  • Social Outcomes in Inclusive Classrooms: Effects of inclusion on peer socialization and behavior
  • Effective Teaching in the Inclusive Environment: Teacher qualifications and collaboration in inclusive settings
  • Collaborative Teaching Models and Reading Outcomes: Two-teacher models and mild disability reading results
  • High-Quality Instruction in Successful Inclusive Schools: Case study of school with strong inclusive practices
  • Teacher Attitudes Toward Inclusion: Teacher skepticism and workload concerns about inclusion
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper synthesizes multiple peer-reviewed sources into a coherent argument about gaps in the empirical literature, rather than simply summarizing individual studies in isolation.
  • It consistently connects each study's findings back to a central organizing theme — the need for further empirical investigation — giving the review a clear and purposeful direction.
  • The paper acknowledges limitations in the studies it reviews (e.g., small sample sizes, narrow disability categories), demonstrating critical engagement with sources rather than passive acceptance.

Key academic technique demonstrated

This paper demonstrates effective literature synthesis: the writer does not merely describe what each source says, but draws comparative connections across studies (for instance, linking Robbins's findings about highly qualified teachers to Lingo, Barton-Arwood, and Jolivette's argument for collaborative teaching). This technique allows the paper to build a cumulative argument rather than produce a disconnected list of summaries.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a framing introduction that identifies the research gap and the four focal areas of the review. It then proceeds thematically — first addressing social outcomes, then shifting to effective teaching strategies and collaborative models, then examining a successful case-study school, and finally turning to teacher attitudes. Each section builds on the previous one, with a consistent forward-looking emphasis on what future research should address.

Essay 1,620 words

Introduction to Inclusion in Education

The field of education has long grappled with the question of how to serve a divergent student body. Particularly challenging in this regard is the group of students that has become known as "special needs" students. In the past, these students were generally subject to "pull-out" strategies, in which they received targeted instruction outside of the regular classroom. More recently, however, inclusion strategies have been hypothesized as more effective — not only for promoting the self-esteem of these children, but also for their actual academic performance. According to Robbins (2010), empirical studies in this regard have been far from conclusive and are indeed contradictory. This suggests a need for further study regarding the academic performance of children who are educated inclusively as part of the mainstream classroom.

The literature reviewed here reveals the need for further empirical study, with specific focus on children in elementary school and on outcomes in terms of social environment, effective teaching, student performance, and teacher support.

While O'Brien, Kudlacek, and Howe (2009) focus their attention on inclusive physical education for European students, their framework can also be usefully applied to elementary school education more broadly. The authors identify four integrated areas for investigation: teacher (strategies), students (performance), interaction (social outcomes), and product — the educational outcomes that emerge from teacher-student interaction. These four elements can equally be applied to subject areas beyond physical education.

5 Sections Hidden · 1,270 words
Social Outcomes in Inclusive Classrooms320 words
Social outcomes in inclusive classrooms can be considered in terms of a reciprocal effect. Investigations may focus either on the effect of the presence of…
Effective Teaching in the Inclusive Environment310 words
Instruction by highly qualified teachers had a more positive effect on included children than instruction by less qualified teachers (Robbins, 2010). In their article, Lingo, Barton-Arwood, and Jolivette (2011, p. 6) emphasize…
Collaborative Teaching Models and Reading Outcomes280 words
Using a slightly different focus on the same theme, Potter (2011) considers the effectiveness of collaboration involving two certified teachers in a general education setting for special needs students, as opposed to a single special education teacher in a segregated setting. The specific aim was to determine outcomes for students with mild…
High-Quality Instruction in Successful Inclusive Schools270 words
Another productive approach to studying teaching effectiveness in inclusive environments is to examine schools that have already demonstrated favorable outcomes. McLesky, Waldron, and Redd (2012) recently conducted such a study. In…
Teacher Attitudes Toward Inclusion90 words
The issue of teacher attitudes toward students with disabilities is vital to the success of inclusive classrooms and, indeed, to the broader implementation of inclusion in schools where it has not yet been attempted. It is human nature to be skeptical, at first, of new…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Inclusive Education Pull-Out Strategy Special Needs Students Social Outcomes Collaborative Teaching Teacher Attitudes Student Performance Reading Instruction General Education Mild Disabilities
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Inclusion Strategies and Student Performance in Elementary Schools. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/inclusion-strategies-student-performance-elementary-75161

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.