Israeli Cinema and the Sabra: From Heroism to Self-Critique
This paper examines how Israeli cinema has depicted the Sabra — the idealized native-born Israeli — and the legacy of the Holocaust across several decades of filmmaking. Beginning with the patriotic wartime portrait in Hill 24 Doesn't Answer (1955), the paper traces a shift through the irreverent humor of Charlie Ve'hetzi (1974) and into the morally complex territory of Walking on Water (2004). It argues that Israeli film progressively moved from projecting national strength and unity to interrogating the psychological and ethical costs of that strength, particularly in relation to Holocaust memory, collective identity, and the possibility of reconciliation with Germany.
- The Heroic Sabra in Early Israeli Cinema: Hill 24 depicts the Sabra as fearless national ideal
- Toward a More Critical National Cinema: Charlie Ve'hetzi introduces antiheroic self-critique
- Holocaust Memory and the Post-Zionist Turn: Post-1970s films reckon with Holocaust's lasting legacy
- Walking on Water: Complexity, Memory, and Reconciliation: Eyal embodies conflicted modern Israeli identity
- Conclusion: Moving Beyond the Old Conflicts: Israel's cinema urges reconciliation over obsession with past
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds every analytical claim in specific, concrete scenes from the films discussed, giving the argument an evidence-based foundation rather than relying on generalizations.
- It uses a clear chronological arc — from 1955 to 2004 — to demonstrate genuine historical development in Israeli cinematic culture, making the thesis about change over time persuasive.
- It integrates secondary scholarly sources (Avisar, Smith) naturally, using them to frame and support observations rather than substitute for original analysis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative textual analysis across multiple films, placing them in dialogue with one another to reveal ideological shifts. Rather than treating each film in isolation, the writer explicitly contrasts how the same cultural figure — the Sabra — is represented differently across decades, using each new film to revise and complicate the image established by its predecessor.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into two thematically parallel halves addressing two related questions: (1) the cinematic image of the Sabra across time, and (2) the evolving depiction of Holocaust memory. Each half opens with the early, heroic films, moves through a transitional example, and arrives at the nuanced moral landscape of Walking on Water. This parallel structure reinforces the paper's central argument that both national identity and Holocaust memory underwent the same fundamental shift — from affirmation to critical self-examination.
The Heroic Sabra in Early Israeli Cinema
The 1955 film Hill 24 Doesn't Answer is one of the first products of Israeli cinema. It is meant to be a stirring portrait of the new Jewish state, dramatizing the then-recent War of Independence. The film shows the war bringing together Jews of disparate backgrounds, all united by the need to defend Israel. As Ilan Avisar notes, "In Israeli culture, the figure of the Sabra" during the period when Hill 24 was made was considered a kind of ideal national type, exemplifying the new Jewish attitude that was free from fear and persecution (Avisar 132). The national ideal of a state that could triumph against all odds — strong both spiritually and militarily — is conveyed through the physical strength and determination of the soldiers.
In one pivotal scene, one of the soldiers confronts a Nazi who uses his status as a prisoner of war as his defense, hiding behind the claim that he was "just following orders." He begs for forgiveness in an attempt to preserve his life. The silent Israeli soldier demonstrates tremendous strength and composure, embodying how the new Israel can never again be beholden to anti-Semites. The group of soldiers fighting for Israel is remarkable for its diversity, and collectively they symbolize the multinational unity of the new Jewish state.
Works Cited
Avisar, Ilan. "The National and the Popular in Israeli Cinema." 2005. 24.1 (2005): 125.
Charlie Ve'hetzi. Directed by Boaz Davidson. 1974.
Hill 24 Doesn't Answer. Directed by T. Dickenson. 1955.
Smith, Anthony. "The Formation of National Identity." Identity. Oxford, 1995.
Walking on Water. Directed by Eytan Fox. 2004.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.