This paper examines the traditional role of men in Japanese society and the family, tracing its roots in Confucian hierarchy and the expectation that men serve as aloof, authoritative breadwinners. It explores how the feminist movement of the 1970s, rising female workforce participation, and broader social modernization have disrupted these long-standing roles. Drawing on studies of gender-role development, counseling literature on Japanese fathers, and anthropological research on cross-cultural marriages, the paper argues that while Japanese men continue to exhibit traditional masculine traits, those traits no longer carry the social reinforcement they once did—leaving men caught between outdated ideals and the demands of modern family life.
The traditional role of men in Japanese society and in the Japanese family is one of the aloof breadwinner. This role comes directly from Japanese cultural history, rooted in Confucianism. The expectation under these social roles dictates that men work and remain distant from their families while maintaining a masculine authority over the household. Since the 1970s, these traditional roles have been threatened by social changes including modernity, technological advances, and the feminist movement in Japan. Women have sought work outside the home, often postponing marriage or expecting different male-female relationship dynamics. At the same time, Japanese society continues to expect the same masculine traits from Japanese men. Confusing gender roles, unfocused masculinity, and marital problems are the result. Through all of this, men in Japanese society continue to fulfill their role as aloof, masculine family authorities, but with results that are not as successful as they once were.
As an island nation, Japan developed while separated from other cultures. Ideals and social functions became ingrained over hundreds of years of habit and practice (Sugihara & Katsurada, 2002). Some roles are familiar to other nations and cultures. Like most nations, the role of mother dictated that women were responsible for much of the child and home care. However, Confucianism also played a great role in Japanese family structure with respect to hierarchy and power. Confucianism has had a significant effect on the development of male stereotypes, roles, and expectations in Japan. It dictates a hierarchy "which assumes subordinates' obedience to superiors and men's dominance over women and children" (Sugihara & Katsurada, 2002, p. 443). Naturally, social expectations set in motion long ago are now deeply ingrained in Japanese society and in the expectations of Japanese people. Confucianism has set the traditional stage for family life in Japan.
In the traditional Japanese family, men are "expected to be leaders, risk-takers, and decision makers" (Sugihara & Katsurada, 2000, p. 311). They provide for the family by going to work and often work long hours. As a result, they have limited contact with their wives and children. This allows the traditional Japanese husband and father to hold a significant amount of control over his family, maintained primarily through expectation and respect (Seto, Becker, & Akutsu, 2006). Children do not develop intimate relationships with their father and therefore do not behave normally when he is home, instead acting with formal respect. Fathers come to inspire a sense of awe and deference in both their children and their wives (Roberson, 2003).
"1970s feminism reshapes women's expectations and family dynamics"
"Men face tension between traditional ideals and modern women"
"Paternal aloofness creates family breakdown and counseling cases"
While Japanese men have retained their masculinity, they no longer have the power that masculinity formerly ensured. Although Japanese men appear to have maintained the traditional traits expected of them for hundreds of years, those traits no longer have the social structure to reinforce a man's hierarchy in the family. He may still be aloof and uninvolved with the direction of family home life, but that no longer guarantees him the respect and reverence that was once so readily assumed.
You’re 34% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.