Fra Filippo Lippi's Portrait of a Woman with a Man at a Casement

Introduction and Overview

Fra Filippo Lippi's Portrait of a Woman with a Man at a Casement is one of the most intriguing double portraits of the early Italian Renaissance. The following analysis begins with the painting's formal qualities — composition, color, line, texture, proportion, balance, contrast, and rhythm — before examining how the work fits within its broader stylistic category and reflects the social and cultural trends of the period in which it was created.

As one scholar has observed, "the paintings of Filippo Lippi are frequently characterised by two features: an interest in minimising the divide between world and image and the presence of humour, both bodily and representational. Although these two aspects of Lippi's art might initially seem unconnected, both can be associated with the use of scientific perspective. Lippi's spatial concerns can be understood as a reaction to the distancing of the iconic image that accompanied the invention of perspective" (Nygren, 2006).

The painting dates from around 1440–1444. It is executed in tempera on wood by the Florentine artist Fra Filippo Lippi and measures 64.1 × 41.9 cm. A particularly interesting detail is the inscription on the cuff of the woman, which reads the word lealtà — Italian for "loyalty." The painting is part of the Marquand Collection and is held at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where it was donated as a gift by Henry G. Marquand in 1889.

Formal Description of the Two Figures

The painting depicts two figures: a woman and a man. The dominant central figure is the woman. We see her in profile as she gazes to the left. Her hands are crossed in a graceful manner. She has blonde hair, and her figure is illuminated by what appears to be natural light; indeed, her face is the most luminous spot in the entire composition. She is dressed in red and wears an abundance of jewelry — rings, a brooch, a necklace, and a hat embroidered with pearls, typical of the aristocratic fashions of her time. Her sleeves are cut open to reveal a beautifully detailed underdress. Every element of her appearance signals great wealth and membership in a Florentine aristocratic family. Her gaze is entirely absorbed by something outside the viewer's field of vision, or she is engaged in a moment of powerful introspection.

In the second plane of the painting, we encounter the figure of a man. Only his face, hands, and a small portion of his chest are visible. He, too, is dressed in red, wearing a red hat and a ring on his finger. His figure faces the opposite direction from the woman, and, like her, he appears absorbed either by something beyond the frame or by his own thoughts.

The man's figure occupies roughly half the pictorial space of the woman's and is situated beneath hers. Both figures share prominent noses, delicate hands, and thin lips. She is positioned inside the house, dominating the composition, while he is outside, visible only through a window. A third framing element in the background reveals either a painting or an additional window, adding further depth to the scene. The shadow of the man's face cast on the wall reinforces the realism of the scene.

Historical Context and Identity of the Subjects

Judging by the coat of arms beneath the man's hands, the manner in which the figures are dressed, and the period in which the painting was created, "it is assumed that they are Ranieri Scolari and Angiola di Bernardo Sapiti, who married in 1436. The sumptuous manner in which the woman is dressed — the fur lining, the pearls, the loops of gold adorning her sleeves — and the word 'loyalty' spelled on the drapery at her wrist suggest that she is a bride. The man, accordingly, is the groom. The gardens and buildings visible in the background are presumably the possessions of the couple" (Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History).

The painting must also be understood within the broader context of early Renaissance portraiture. During this period, the portrait was beginning to establish itself as an independent genre. Previously, portraits had been embedded in larger religious compositions, and the figures depicted were almost invariably connected to religious or spiritual themes. The social and cultural transformations of the Renaissance allowed painters to portray individuals across a wider range of social contexts. People of various statuses had their likenesses immortalized by painters, and art was broadening its representational borders. Within this context, the painting under discussion is notably unusual and innovative.

One might ask why both figures are shown in profile. The answer lies in the prevailing convention of the early Italian Renaissance, which had inherited the use of the profile view from antiquity. This standard constrained the painter, limiting his ability to develop a character's personality or convey meaning through body language or varied facial expression. Lippi therefore had to work within restricted means to communicate the message he desired. Because body language and facial expression could not supply the viewer with interpretive clues, he was compelled to rely on all other available elements: dress, color, details, and spatial positioning. As Nygren (2006) notes, "while some of Lippi's contemporaries incorporated this distancing into their works, Lippi, for personal and devotional reasons, resisted this solution. Instead, using introductory steps and other compositional devices, he tried to de-emphasise the boundary marked by the physical picture plane."

In order to convey something of a person's personality and inner state, the painter had at his disposal a rich vocabulary of symbols and iconography. Nothing in such a painting is accidental; everything is carefully chosen. The woman's pale skin, for instance, may be read as a sign of purity and virtue. Her rich clothing signals her membership in a wealthy and powerful family and indicates that she is participating in a significant ceremony or event. The word "loyalty" confirms that this event is a marriage.

The woman's blonde hair and, although her face is only partially visible, her evident beauty are equally significant. In the early Renaissance, physical beauty was commonly associated with inner virtue. The beautiful woman dressed in red is thus understood to be a virtuous woman of great spiritual standing. The blonde hair, the pale complexion, and the high forehead — a recognized symbol of beauty and elegance at the time — all function as markers of virtue.

Such wedding portraits were becoming increasingly common during this period. They were typically commissioned by wealthy families in which marriages were arranged. The paintings served a pragmatic purpose as well: they allowed one prospective spouse to see the other before the wedding. The future spouses had often never met, and one family would commission a painter to portray the lady so that her future husband might know her appearance. The man's gaze directed toward the future can thus be explained: he has a vision of his future wife, having seen her portrait. She is presented as a virtuous woman with beautiful physical attributes, from a family of equal social standing.

Bibliography

Drogin, D., & Harris, B. Lippi's portrait of a man and woman at a casement. Smarthistory. http://www.smarthistory.org/lippis-portrait-of-a-man-and-woman-at-a-casement.html (accessed April 7, 2011).

Fra Filippo Lippi biography and works. http://www.frafilippolippi.org/biography.html (accessed April 9, 2011).

Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. Portrait of a woman with a man at a casement. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/89.15.19 (accessed April 8, 2011).

Gouwens, K. The Italian Renaissance: The Essential Sources (Blackwell Essential Readings in History). Wiley-Blackwell, 2003.

Ruda, J. Fra Filippo Lippi. Phaidon Press, 1999.

Holmes, M. Fra Filippo Lippi the Carmelite Painter. Yale University Press, 1999.

Borsook, E. "Fra Filippo Lippi and the murals for Prato Cathedral." Mitteilungen des Kunsthistorischen Institutes in Florenz, 19(1), 1975, pp. 1–148.

Burroughs, B. "Four saints by Fra Filippo Lippi." The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin, vol. 13, no. 11, November 1918, pp. 231–232.

Carmichael, M. "Fra Filippo Lippi's portrait." The Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs, vol. 21, no. 112, July 1912.

Nygren, B. "Una cosa che non-è: Perspective and humour in the paintings of Filippo Lippi." Oxford Art Journal, vol. 29, no. 3, 2006, pp. 319–339.

Shell, C. "The early style of Fra Filippo Lippi and the Prato master." The Art Bulletin, vol. 43, no. 3, September 1961.

Smith, R. "Eternal objects of desire: Art review — Art and love in Renaissance Italy." New York Times Art and Design, November 20, 2008.