Setting and Atmosphere in The Lottery vs. The Rocking-Horse Winner
This essay compares and contrasts the settings and atmospheres of two celebrated short stories: Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" and D.H. Lawrence's "The Rocking-Horse Winner." Both stories explore the darker dimensions of human behavior — mob violence and unchecked greed, respectively — but employ markedly different settings to do so. Lawrence grounds his tale in recognizable post-WWI English locations and horse-racing venues, while Jackson uses a deliberately nameless village to suggest universality. The essay examines how each author's choice of time, place, and atmosphere shapes character response and reinforces thematic meaning, ultimately arguing that setting is central to both stories' critiques of human nature.
- Introduction: Two Dark Visions of Humanity: Framing both stories as explorations of human darkness
- Overview of the Two Stories: Plot summaries of Lawrence's and Jackson's stories
- Settings in The Rocking-Horse Winner and The Lottery: Contrasting specific versus anonymous geographic settings
- Temporal Setting and Seasonal Symbolism: How time of year shapes meaning in each story
- Atmosphere and Character Response: Enthusiasm and irony as contrasting story atmospheres
- Conclusion: Setting as a Lens for Comparison: Setting reveals shared and divergent themes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper maintains a clear comparative focus throughout, consistently returning to setting and atmosphere as the analytical lens rather than drifting into broad plot summary.
- It draws meaningful contrasts between the two stories — Lawrence's geographically specific England versus Jackson's deliberately anonymous village — and connects those contrasts to each story's thematic purpose.
- Direct quotations from both primary texts are used to anchor analytical claims, giving the argument textual grounding.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates a point-by-point comparative structure, addressing a shared element (setting, then temporality, then atmosphere) across both texts before moving to the next element. This organization keeps the comparison tight and prevents the essay from becoming two separate summaries stitched together.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with brief thematic framing of both stories, then provides a short plot overview of each. It proceeds to compare geographical settings, then temporal settings and seasonal symbolism, and finally the emotional atmosphere each story creates and how characters respond within it. A short conclusion synthesizes the similarities and differences uncovered through the setting-based analysis. The structure is straightforward and suits the comparative task well.
Introduction: Two Dark Visions of Humanity
"The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson and "The Rocking-Horse Winner" by D.H. Lawrence are two compelling short stories that both engage with the darker side of humanity. In "The Lottery," one of the fundamental themes is the viciousness and brutality characteristic of even the most civilized of societies. "The Rocking-Horse Winner" is a fable that highlights human greed and the dangers of avarice. Both stories analyze human behavior and its consequences, with the differences lying in the kind of behavior depicted and the consequences associated with it. The setting helps to focus attention on these similarities and differences, as well as on how the characters within each setting react to the world around them.
References
Cummings (2010). The Rocking-Horse Winner: A Study Guide. Retrieved from
Jackson, S. (2008). The lottery. Mankato, MN: Creative Education.
Lawrence, D.H., & Learning Corporation of America (1980). The rocking horse winner. Northbrook, IL: Learning Corp. of America.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.