This paper examines the role of madness in three of Edgar Allan Poe's most celebrated tales of terror: "The Tell-Tale Heart" (1843), "The Cask of Amontillado" (1846), and "The Fall of the House of Usher" (1839). Through analysis of the deranged narrators and protagonists in these works, the paper traces how Poe manifests psychological madness through fevered language, irrational actions, and the interior mental states of his characters. The paper demonstrates a consistent pattern across the three tales: protagonists trapped in hostile environments suffer from unexplained anxiety, respond with violence or cruelty toward innocent victims, and subsequently experience guilt or self-destruction. By examining the specific symptoms and manifestations of madness in each tale—from the protagonist's obsession with the "Evil Eye" to Montresor's obsessive revenge to Roderick Usher's inherited psychological decay—the paper argues that Poe's genius lies in his ability to portray the interior logic of madness with such precision that readers recognize their own subconscious fears reflected in his dark narratives.
As J. R. Hammond so acutely points out, many of the narrators in the short stories of Edgar Allan Poe reveal "their deranged minds by the fevered nervousness of their language and by the total irrationality" of the tale as it unfolds to the reader (1981, p. 82). This is the primary foundation for Poe's dark excursions into the human mind as expressed through his "tales of terror," which illustrate "the pressures of abnormal psychology (via) neurasthenia, hallucinations, neuroses and psychoses" (Buranelli, 1977, p. 73).
Poe's uncanny ability to transcend reality and inject the reader into the domains of madness is best represented by three celebrated tales: "The Tell-Tale Heart," published in the first issue of the Pioneer magazine in January 1843 with American poet James Russell Lowell as its editor; "The Cask of Amontillado," published in Godey's Lady's Book in November 1846, a masterly excursion into psychosis and retribution; and "The Fall of the House of Usher," which made its first appearance in Burton's Gentleman's Magazine in September 1839. Within the confines of these tales, a strange, unnerving familiarity with the characters and situations can be sensed, which allows the reader to subconsciously relate to the maddening experiences and insane thoughts of the main protagonists.
If the underlying substance of Poe's "tales of terror" lies within the deranged minds of the narrators, then a portrait of this psychosis can be understood by the following scenario: an individual perceives he is trapped in a hostile environment beyond his control, which produces great apprehension despite the lack of specific causes for his dread. On occasion, he suffers from real threats in his daily life and confronts these threats with ingenuity and courage, at times even overcoming his fears by retaliating against an innocent victim, either violently or through mental torture. Afterwards, he feels remorse for his actions and is emotionally moved to atone for his guilt through confession or by exposing himself to official punishment or self-inflicted agony.
In the three tales mentioned above, the narrators migrate through one or more segments of this scenario. In "The Tell-Tale Heart," the unidentified protagonist becomes the aggressor by attacking an innocent victim in his bed; he feels remorse for his act and then absolves his guilt by confession. In "The Cask of Amontillado," Montresor both suffers and retaliates against seen or imagined threats via his wine-maddened enemy. In "The Fall of the House of Usher," Roderick Usher, as a result of his irrational fears, falls victim to his own inherited madness by burying his sister alive.
Yet in reality, many individuals are frequently at the mercy of some unexplained anxiety brought about by circumstances which are difficult, if not impossible, to deal with in a logical manner. As seen with a quick reading of any of the tales mentioned, the origin of the madness is described graphically—the beating of a dead man's heart, the devious yet unexplained treachery of Fortunato, and the foreboding atmosphere of the decrepit House of Usher all serve as the catalysts for psychological breakdown.
In "The Tell-Tale Heart," perhaps the most famous of Poe's "tales of terror," the protagonist is beset by fears with no discernible foundation; his paranoia is unfounded, yet he suffers under these false delusions. As a result, he proceeds to vent these fears upon an innocent old man who had never wronged him and never given him insult. He then realizes his fears are directly related to the "Evil Eye" of the old man—described as resembling that of a vulture, "a pale, blue eye, with a film over it"—which prompts him to "take the life of the old man, and thus rid myself of the eye forever."
The victim is murdered in his sleep, and the dismembered body ends up beneath the floor of his bedroom. Yet the protagonist succumbs to his guilt and confesses his crime to the local police: "I admit the deed!—tear up the planks!—here, here!—it is the beating of his hideous heart!" This dramatic confession reveals the psychological torture that accompanies the murder; the protagonist cannot bear the sound of the dead man's heart, whether real or imagined, and must expose himself to punishment to ease his conscience.
The madness inherent in this tale revolves around "the beating of the old man's heart," which according to Elizabeth Phillips indicates criminal insanity as described by Dr. Benjamin West in his lectures of the late 1700s. West noted that "the symptoms of madness include acceleration of the pulse (with) complaints of pain in the head and ringing in the ears" (Phillips, 1979, p. 130). Poe thus grounds the protagonist's psychological breakdown in contemporary medical theory, lending credibility to the internal logic of his madness.
As a biographical reference, "The Tell-Tale Heart" illustrates Poe's lifelong interest in human psychology, a subject which he found to be of great importance to the overall psychological makeup of his manic characters. His use of the term "mania" in other tales "calls into question judgments of sanity in his narrators" and points to Poe's evident interest in medical theories and abnormal psychology (Phillips, 1979, p. 108). It has also been suggested that Poe consulted several prominent books on the diseases of the mind as early as 1835.
"The Cask of Amontillado" displays similar characteristics of mental insanity via Montresor's obsession with the unidentified transgressions of Fortunato. In this tale, Fortunato is led by his enemy Montresor to sample a cask of Amontillado sherry, which inevitably tempts him into a remote section of the family vaults where Montresor walls him up alive in a niche in the catacombs. The line "My heart grew sick; it was the dampness of the catacombs that made it so" demonstrates the allegorical undertones which correspond to Montresor's obvious madness—a madness which lies not in his heart but in his diseased brain.
Montresor's revenge is motivated by a vague and never-explained injury, suggesting that his obsession has festered in his mind far beyond any rational justification. Like the protagonist of "The Tell-Tale Heart," Montresor's psychological state has become so warped by resentment that he commits an act of unspeakable cruelty. His deliberate, methodical entombment of Fortunato alive suggests a mind consumed entirely by the desire for revenge, a madness that transforms a presumed insult into a capital crime.
Poe's most celebrated protagonist, Roderick Usher in "The Fall of the House of Usher," not only suffers as a victim of "the grim phantasm, Fear," but also inflicts his "morbid acuteness of the senses" upon his sister Madeline, who is slowly dying from the result of some unidentified "family evil." The unknown narrator in this tale attempts to comfort Usher by suggesting his fears are unfounded, but Usher is convinced that death is imminent. Madeline abruptly dies—"the lady Madeline was no more"—and Usher proceeds to inter her in the family crypt. Soon he imagines he has accidentally buried her alive.
His fears of premature burial, however, are realized, for he begins to hear odd movements in the house. Madeline then appears in Roderick's chamber, where she falls dead into his arms "a corpse, and a victim to the terrors anticipated." The narrator then quickly flees from the house as "the deep and dark tarn" swallows up "the fragments of the House of Usher." This catastrophic ending suggests that Usher's madness has literally destroyed not only himself but also his sister and his ancestral home.
The insidious presence of madness can easily be felt in "The Fall of the House of Usher," not so much in the somewhat detached narrator but in Usher himself, the tortured occupant of a house filled with absolute mania. Daniel Hoffman sees Usher as the penultimate Poe character who exudes "extreme psychological states" and serves as the model for Poesque "madmen who undergo some excruciating suffering of the soul" (1978, p. 206).
J. R. Hammond notes that "The Fall of the House of Usher" is "an incomparable study in atmospherics" (1981, p. 70), symbolized by such lines as "During the whole of a dull, dark, and soundless day in the autumn of the year, when the clouds hung oppressively low in the heavens" and "the precipitous brink of a black and lurid tarn." Both of these descriptions create in the mind of the reader the presence of some unidentifiable, threatening menace which gradually becomes more menacing as the narrative unfolds. In reality, these descriptions are allegories for Usher's tortured and unbalanced mind, imbued with irrational and melancholic madness.
"Recurring madness theme and Poe's precision in portraying mental illness"
You’re 82% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.