This paper examines the role of mid-range theory in nursing as a practical alternative to grand theory, which has long been criticized for its abstract terminology and disconnect from clinical practice. Drawing on the work of Nolan and Grant, Peplau, Xu and Jezewski, and Flood, the paper argues that mid-range theory successfully bridges the theory-practice gap by incorporating the direct experiences of patients, families, and practitioners into the research process. Key applications discussed include patient advocacy, family inclusion in mental health nursing, and theoretical frameworks for caring for an aging population. The paper concludes that mid-range theory represents a more effective and humanistic foundation for nursing research, education, and practice.
Nursing theory, as Nolan and Grant (1992, p. 217) correctly state, cannot be separated from the practice of the profession. On the other hand, theories that have become known collectively as "grand theory" have grown so fraught with terminology discrepancies and idealistic representation that it has become impossible for practitioners to use them effectively. This has created what Nolan and Grant (1992, p. 217) refer to as the "theory-practice gap" — a lack of basic communication and collaboration between nursing theorists and practitioners in the field. To remedy this, a new approach to nursing theory and its relationship to practice arose, known as "mid-range theory." This approach was first suggested by Hildegard Peplau at the end of the 1960s (Peden, 1998). Recently, there has been a revisitation of the merits of mid-range theories as a more effective approach not only to the practice of nursing, but also to research in the field and to the education of both nurses and the families who make use of nursing care.
Mid-range theory has opened the field to better communication between nursing practitioners and their patients in terms of inclusive education. In the field of mental health nursing, for example, the current approach focuses on the inclusion of families in nursing education, especially where conditions such as schizophrenia or physical disability create a need for extensive family support. According to Goldenberg and Goldenberg (p. 381), mental health and other caregiving practitioners have increasingly recognized the importance of collaborative therapist-family relationships in order to provide optimal care to clients. This creates a network of care for disabled and mentally challenged individuals that is far more effective than placing the burden of care exclusively upon an already burdened nursing profession. Education therefore extends not only to the nursing profession itself, but also to families who face caregiving challenges on a daily basis.
In this context, communication is also of the greatest importance, as made evident in the work of Xu and Jezewski (2007). In focusing on the nurse's role in patient advocacy, the authors address the public demand for greater control over healthcare. Not only public education, but also collaborative communication is of the utmost importance in this regard. One might therefore argue that grand theory is no longer relevant in this domain, while the importance of mid-range theory has heightened. This is particularly significant in view of current technological and medical advances, which, without adequate communication and education, can leave healthcare clients with a sense of bewilderment and loss of control. Here, the role of the nursing practitioner is vital; he or she serves as the mediator between the client and the intricacies of the profession. The advocating role is therefore not only one of communication, but also of public education.
Another function of mid-range theory in nursing is to promote effective and practically applicable theories that address the current nursing needs of humanity. In other words, this type of theory observes the function and status of humanity in the world today and devises frameworks focused on improving outcomes. This includes addressing the aging population, which has become one of the defining nursing realities of our time. Flood (n.d., p. 35), for example, notes that 2011 would see the 65th birthday of the oldest members of the baby boom generation. The practical reality of this is that comprehensive care for older people has increased, especially as medical advances have resulted in people generally reaching a greater age. For this reason, nurses who work with older people have themselves entered the theoretical field in order to devise effective and consistent theories that can provide a basis for caring for this generation.
According to Flood (n.d., p. 35), what currently lacks in nursing theory relating to older persons is practical direction. This practicality is what nurses are currently pursuing by devising mid-range theories. One practical element missing from current theory is a comprehensive description of the human aging process. The author notes a notable discrepancy between the practical experiences of older people and the findings of researchers regarding aging. This indicates a need for research that includes the perspectives of those who are directly involved. The same is true of the families described above, who face the medical and care needs of mentally and physically disabled family members.
"Mid-range theory addresses aging care needs"
"Clients and practitioners co-create nursing theory"
"Empirical rigor and practical roots reinforce each other"
In conclusion, nursing is by definition a caring profession, where the practical relationship between nurse and client is as important as the theory that governs it. One might therefore conclude that the "grand theories" of nursing no longer hold the prominent position in the profession that they once did. Instead, there is a growing focus on practical applicability in the form of public education, communication, and nursing practice itself. Through mid-range theory, a balance has been achieved between theoretical and practical excellence in the nursing profession. Being responsive to the rigors of current public demand, this type of theoretical approach lends itself well to the advancement of nursing as a caring service to humanity.
You’re 61% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.