This paper reviews literature on motivation's critical role in second and foreign language learning. It examines two primary motivation types—integrative and instrumental—and explores the three core elements of motivation: effort, desire, and emotional response. The paper analyzes Gardner's socio-educational model, which connects social-cultural factors, individual learner differences, learning context, and linguistic outcomes. It also discusses findings from cross-cultural studies and research on intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation in ESL classrooms, emphasizing that successful language acquisition depends on understanding and cultivating appropriate motivation types tailored to individual learners.
The purpose of this work is to present a review of literature on the role of motivation in second or foreign language learning. Motivation is a fundamental element in determining whether students acquire language proficiency and sustain engagement in their studies.
Motivation is comprised of three primary elements that work together to influence language learning success. Effort refers to the time invested in study of the language and the learner's overall drive to engage with material. Desire describes how much proficiency in the language is wanted by the learner—the extent of their personal goals. Effect encompasses the emotional response of the learner in relation to language study, including satisfaction, anxiety, or enthusiasm during the learning process (Norris-Holt, 2003).
The definition of motivation in the context of second language acquisition is stated to be "the learner's orientation with regard to the goal of learning a second language." Research on motivation in language learning has been greatly influenced by theoretical work spanning decades. The work of Gardner in relation to motivation was impacted greatly by earlier theorists such as Mowrer, who proposed that when a child is learning a first language successfully, this may be credited to the desire to gain identity within the family unit as well as the broader community.
Motivation is divided into two basic types that are essential to understanding how learners integrate into the target language community: integrative motivation and instrumental motivation.
Integrative motivation is possessed by successful learners who are those who "like the people that speak the language, admire the culture and have a desire to become familiar or even integrate into the society in which the language is spoken" (Falk, 1978, as cited by Norris-Holt, 2003). Learners with integrative motivation view the target language not merely as a communication tool but as a pathway to cultural understanding and community membership. This type of motivation is rooted in genuine interest in and respect for the culture associated with the language.
Research has consistently found that integrative motivation sustains long-term success when learning a second language. Multiple studies (Taylor, Meynard, and Rheault, 1977; Ellis, 1997; Crookes and Schmidt, 1991) demonstrate that learners driven by integrative motivation maintain their commitment over extended periods and achieve deeper language proficiency.
Instrumental motivation is characterized by the desire to obtain something practical or concrete from the second language. This type of motivation is utilitarian in nature. According to Hudson (2000, as cited by Norris-Holt, 2003), instrumental motivation reflects the individual's "desire to obtain something practical or concrete from the study of a second language." Examples include learning a language for career advancement, academic requirements, or economic opportunity. While different from integrative motivation in its orientation, instrumental motivation can also be effective in driving language acquisition, particularly in the early stages of learning or in specific, goal-focused contexts.
Because motivation is a critical factor in L2 achievement, identification of the type and combination of motivation that is key in the successful acquisition of a second language is essential. Researchers emphasize viewing motivation "as one of a number of variables in an intricate model of interrelated individual and situational factors which are unique to each language learner" (Norris-Holt, 2003).
One of the most influential frameworks in understanding motivation and second language learning is Gardner's socio-educational model, which explores the significance of motivation as a contributing factor in second language acquisition. The model recognizes that language learning does not occur in a vacuum but is embedded within social, cultural, and individual contexts.
Gardner's model focuses on second language acquisition in structured classroom settings and attempts to interrelate four key features:
In the second phase of Gardner's model, four variables emerge as influential in second language acquisition: (1) intelligence, (2) language aptitude, (3) motivation, and (4) situational anxiety (Giles and Coupland, 1991, as cited by Norris-Holt, 2003). These variables interact dynamically, with motivation playing a particularly central role in determining whether learners leverage their aptitude and intelligence effectively.
The third and final phase in Gardner's model makes identification of "linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes of the learning experience" (Norris-Holt, 2003). Linguistic outcomes refer to the actual language knowledge and language skills acquired. Non-linguistic outcomes refer to an individual's attitudes in relation to cultural values and beliefs, as well as their sense of belonging to the target language community.
A significant challenge in motivating language learners arises from cultural differences in expectations and values. A study conducted by David F. McCargar examined students of various cultures in relation to their role expectations for teachers and students. The research revealed important insights about heterogeneous ESL classrooms.
ESL classes are heterogeneous in terms of culture, which results in difficulty in the discovery and application of methods that align with students' expectations. McCargar's conclusions indicate that "cultural differences in role expectations are central to many second-language teaching contexts" (McCargar, 1993). The research recommends helping students change or adjust their expectations, but emphasizes that "teachers should realize that expectations may change slowly or very little" (McCargar, 1993, as cited by Knutson, 2001).
These insights provide important guidance for language teaching professionals seeking to assist students in learning languages in a more efficient manner. Cross-cultural understanding in ESL instruction is essential for creating classroom environments where diverse learners feel respected and motivated. According to Knutson (2001), effective ESL instruction must be "empowering through communication strategies that are effective" and should focus particularly on "cross-cultural communication and motivation."
"Complex motivation types beyond traditional integrative models"
Students who are motivated are students who are learning and who are challenged in that learning experience. This work has clearly shown the necessary structure of learning as well as the primary characteristics stated as necessary in relation to the learning of a second or foreign language.
You’re 72% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.