This paper examines the nursing shortage in the United States, arguing that the crisis stems from a complex combination of interrelated factors rather than any single cause. Drawing on national surveys, government projections, and peer-reviewed studies, the paper documents the scale of the shortage—including projected vacancies surpassing 800,000 by 2020—and analyzes its primary drivers: low job satisfaction, poor working conditions, insufficient involvement in decision-making, and the expanded career opportunities available to women. The paper also considers how nursing's perceived lack of professional status contributes to recruitment difficulties. It concludes that effective solutions must address this full range of factors simultaneously.
The retention of nursing staff in hospital departments and health institutions has become a major issue in healthcare management. Many studies indicate that the shortage of nursing staff has become an international problem. There are numerous causes for this shortage. One of the most commonly cited reasons is decreased job satisfaction. Other issues that must also be considered include the changing status of women in modern society and the fact that women in developed countries now have more life and work choices than in the past. This is also related to the attraction of other opportunities and professions.
While many factors influence the loss and retention of nursing staff, one of the central causes cited in the literature is that the nursing shortage is largely due to increased pressure and poor working conditions. This is linked to other central causes, such as the appeal of other professions and the changed status of women in modern society. Coupled with this is the fact that the nursing shortage is a serious issue with profound implications for both the healthcare industry and the nursing profession. The central thesis of this paper is that the nursing shortage results from a combination of various factors that together create a complex and serious situation for modern nursing. The various causes and the ways in which they are related to one another are discussed in the sections that follow.
An article by a practicing healthcare professional clearly summarizes the extent of the nursing problem:
"The nursing shortage in the United States has turned into a full-blown crisis. Because fewer young people go into nursing, one-third of registered nurses in the United States are now over 50 years of age, and that proportion is expected to rise to 40 percent over the next decade. Nurses currently practicing report high rates of job dissatisfaction, with one in five seriously considering leaving the profession within the next five years. In Baltimore, where I practice medicine, hospitals routinely cancel or delay surgical cases because of a lack of nursing staff." (Dworkin)
This view is supported by numerous studies and official statistics. A number of national surveys, including one by the American Hospital Association, indicate that hospitals are averaging 11 to 14 percent vacancy rates in nursing positions, amounting to approximately 120,000 vacancies nationwide. Furthermore, the federal government has predicted that the number of vacancies will surpass 800,000 by 2020. As one report noted, "The projected shortage in 2020 results from a projected 40 percent increase in demand between 2000 and 2020, compared to a projected 6 percent growth in supply" ("Condition: Critical; Long Hours," 2002, p. A01).
Other reports indicate that this shortage has broadly impacted healthcare, with nurses and physicians stating that hospital nurse staffing levels are already inadequate for safe and effective care ("Condition: Critical; Long Hours," 2002, p. A01). A number of journal articles clearly identify the shortage of nursing expertise as a national crisis in healthcare and a threat to the future of the nursing profession: "The future of professional nursing is threatened today by the current and impending shortage of nurses. While the entire health care industry is affected, it is even more predominant in specialty areas such as urologic nursing. If unresolved, the crisis will be even more significant in the future." (Albaugh)
Numerous causes are cited in the research literature. One of the most common is low job satisfaction. A central contributing factor to this is that nurses often feel they lack adequate involvement in decision-making. For example, McFarland, Leonard, and Morris (1984) identified the following as central causative factors: "a lack of involvement in policy and decision making, problems with supervisors, poor working conditions, inadequate salary, and a lack of job security." (Albaugh)
Other aspects that affect job satisfaction include increased tension and growing responsibilities. According to a study by Leveck and Jones (1996), cited in Albaugh (2003), the main complaints of nurses were related to "overseeing unlicensed assistive personnel, greater diversity in patient diagnosis on inpatient units, increased severity of illness, lack of recognition and respect, lack of involvement in decision making, increased patient load, and a larger, more diverse physical environment." (Albaugh)
A study by Aiken et al. (2001) found that the job dissatisfaction experienced by nurses was due to staff shortages, which resulted in nurses being unable to provide effective, high-quality care. The study also reiterated that nurses often felt excluded from important policy decisions, which had a negative effect on their level of work satisfaction.
These findings are linked to other evidence showing that the shortage of nursing staff is closely related to the perception that working conditions do not permit the development of a high standard of excellence in the profession. As one survey indicated, "75 percent of nurses surveyed feel the quality of nursing care at the facility in which they work has declined over the past two years, while 56 percent of nurses surveyed believe that the time they have available for patient care has decreased." (Nurses Concerned Over Working Conditions, Decline in Quality of Care, ANA Survey Reveals)
The findings above are strongly connected to the changed situation and status of women in the modern world. Simply put, women now have greater freedom of choice and more work opportunities available to them than in the past. Previously, women could find employment only in certain occupations. This has changed significantly, and it has also meant that if a nurse finds her working conditions unacceptable, many other employment opportunities are available to her. This point is clearly summarized by Dworkin: "The new career opportunities open to women provide an explanation for the nursing shortage. When nursing was one of the few career paths available, it had a captive labor pool. Now that other, more lucrative opportunities beckon—for example, medical school—women are less likely to choose nursing." (Dworkin)
"Expanded career choices reduce nursing recruitment pool"
As Albaugh points out, the various causes of the nursing shortage are interrelated, and there is no single dominant cause for the situation: "Many factors contribute to nurse dissatisfaction and subsequent turnover and burnout. In light of the current nursing shortage, it is essential and cost-effective to retain nurses in their specific jobs and within the profession. There is no single, simple reason or solution for professional staff nurse turnover." (Albaugh)
You’re 83% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.