NYC Vacant Space: Temporary Uses and Urban Solutions
This paper examines the problem of vacant and underutilized spaces in New York City — including empty retail storefronts, depots, rooftops, and parking lots — and explores how nonprofits, artists, city agencies, and entrepreneurs are finding creative temporary uses for them. Drawing on examples such as Brooklyn Bridge Park, Chashama, the Illy Push Button House, and the Boston Chinatown Storefront Library, the paper documents both the scale of the vacancy problem and the innovative responses it has inspired. The paper also surveys the commercial real estate climate following the 2008 economic downturn and proposes solutions, including a "Zip Lease" model to streamline nonprofits' access to short-term space.
- Introduction: Land scarcity and NYC's vacancy challenge
- Problem Statement: Scope of vacant retail and nonprofit demand
- Case Studies in Temporary Space Use: Four projects reusing NYC empty spaces
- Description of the Problem: Manhattan vacancy data and idle resource costs
- Literature Review: Commercial real estate crisis and expert analysis
- Solutions and Recommendations: Community awareness and Zip Lease model proposed
- Conclusion: Summary of findings and temporary-use value
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds abstract arguments in concrete, named examples — Chashama, Brooklyn Bridge Park, the Illy Push Button House, and the Chinatown Storefront Library — giving readers tangible anchors for each claim.
- Balances qualitative case studies with quantitative data (CoStar vacancy statistics, rental rate figures, acreage comparisons) to support its argument with both narrative and numerical evidence.
- Connects a local urban issue to broader economic forces, citing Federal Reserve testimony and national commercial mortgage data, which elevates the analysis beyond a simple survey of city projects.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of the problem–solution structure: it establishes the scope of the vacancy crisis with data, illustrates existing responses through case studies, and then proposes two forward-looking solutions (community awareness campaigns and a "Zip Lease" model). This approach shows students how to move from descriptive analysis to prescriptive recommendation within a single paper.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a historical framing of NYC's relationship with land scarcity, then states its research problem. A central case-study section profiles four distinct temporary-use projects. A data-driven problem description follows, supported by CoStar and Optimal Spaces figures. A literature review documents the broader commercial real estate crisis using expert testimony. The paper closes with two proposed solutions and a brief conclusion tying back to the opening thesis.
Introduction
According to the NYC Department of Parks & Recreation, Dutch traders established farming communities and villages east of Manhattan around 1652. One such village, Vlackebos, literally translated as the "wooded plain." This wooded area at the time consisted of virgin thick forests coupled with flat terrain, so it eventually came to be called Flatbush. The area remained in this overgrown natural state for nearly three centuries. "But in the 1920s, the new Interborough Rapid Transit linked Flatbush to the rest of the city, sparking new developments that began welcoming successive generations of immigrants. As with the Dutch traders, these newcomers built homes and roads, only more quickly and densely. Riding through East Flatbush today, there are still trees that line its quiet residential sidewalks. But the area's open space is virtually gone." (NYC Department of Parks & Recreation)
Today, New York City is home to over eight million people, and space is still as precious as it once was in Flatbush. The problem today is not open forests but retail spaces, depots, vacant lots, and underused properties. Although the city can claim the largest urban park system in the United States, the need for and use of space continues to be a growing concern for real estate developers, nonprofits, and the citizens of the metropolis. "Over the last five years, the City has added more than 300 acres of new parkland, much of it by reclaiming stretches of the waterfront that were abandoned by industry decades ago." Because space in NYC communities and the efficient use of those spaces is so vital to the city's quality of life, it is essential to understand how well — or how poorly — these spaces are being utilized. (NYC Department of Parks & Recreation)
In this highly economically motivated and highly technical globalized world, saving is rarely a priority. Our world is one where resources are wasted every few seconds, even though we all understand that this way of life is not sustainable. The obvious answer is that we must work together to capitalize on our natural resources as efficiently as possible. Most people, however, would only think of oil, electricity, or water when discussing natural resources. That is because historically, throughout the United States, there has been a virtual laissez-faire attitude toward other great natural resources such as land and space. The nation's farmers and other agricultural users do pay attention to land as a resource, but the vast majority of people remain blind to this issue because of the seemingly infinite abundance of land across the country. The prevailing purpose of land, therefore, has been simply to exploit it for economic gain.
New Yorkers, however — specifically the urbanites of the five boroughs — have long understood that land is not a limitless commodity. NYC's ever-increasing population, coupled with industrial expansion, has been the foundation of urban sprawl. The city has experienced, more than any other American city, how thousands of vacated retail spaces, depots, vacant lots, and rooftops go unused. This paper addresses what is happening in NYC with regard to vacated and available space. It examines existing projects and how they currently make use of temporary space around the city, and it aims to brainstorm new potential uses while exploring how the economic downturn has hurt this aspect of the real estate market.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.