This essay analyzes Susan Orlean's The Orchid Thief as a work that defies conventional genre boundaries by combining narrative and non-narrative exposition. The paper examines how Orlean uses fictional techniques — vivid character description, recorded dialogue, and psychological analysis — alongside the factual, reportorial tones of nonfiction to illuminate the unusual world of orchid collecting. Through close readings of key passages, the essay argues that Orlean's interweaving of personal narrative, objective reporting, character-driven drama, and historical context produces a portrait of protagonist John Laroche that is simultaneously believable and larger than life.
The paper demonstrates textual analysis through tonal categorization: rather than simply retelling the book's plot, the writer identifies and distinguishes four distinct narrative registers Orlean employs — personal descriptive narrative, objective reportorial narrative, psychological non-narrative analysis, and historical non-narrative editorializing — and shows how each contributes to the book's overall effect. This analytical framework gives the essay a clear organizational spine.
The essay opens by defining genre expectations for fiction and nonfiction before positioning The Orchid Thief as a hybrid that challenges those norms. It then introduces the book's protagonist and the significance of the orchid-obsession subject. Two central sections perform close readings of character portrayal and Orlean's authorial voice. The conclusion synthesizes the multiple tonal registers Orlean employs, closing with a quoted passage that encapsulates the book's thematic argument about collecting and "lovesickness." The single Works Cited entry follows MLA format.
According to conventional genre expectations, most readers assume that nonfiction provides factual information regarding historical events in a documentary and provable fashion, without recourse to constructed dramas in the form of dialogue or extended character descriptions. In contrast, the same reader might turn to a work of fiction — although fiction might not be technically accurate — to learn as well. Through the use of dialogue and flights of fancy in narration, fiction provides insight into human character.
The nonfiction work by Susan Orlean, entitled The Orchid Thief, however, provides ample examples of both non-narrative and narrative exposition. The work thus has both the expository quality of nonfiction combined with the character-driven psychological drama of fiction. Orlean is writing about an event that actually happened, so she writes in the tones of nonfiction, in an expository fashion. But this real-life obsession has its roots in the psychologically strange and inexplicable. Unless one understands the real-life protagonists' struggles, problems, and internal conflicts, the events and the obsessions seem inexplicable. Narrative and non-narrative sequences are therefore combined to provide the maximum amount of illumination upon the event.
The psychological obsession Orlean chronicles is that of pilfering rare flowers — namely orchids. Orlean begins her work of prose as she heads down to Florida to investigate the story of John Laroche, a plant purveyor who is politely termed "eccentric" by the author and those around him. He has been arrested, along with a crew of Seminole Indians, for poaching rare orchids out of a South Florida swamp. Laroche becomes the book's hero, or main protagonist, serving to highlight the larger phenomenon of humanity's obsession with this rare plant.
Without Orlean's larger background narrative regarding the history of orchid obsessions, this would simply be a hothouse flower of a tale — unusual, but with no larger horticultural or psychological significance. For instance, the main protagonist went through many collecting obsessions before settling upon flowers, including turtles, and when it comes to orchids, "Laroche went from wanting pictures of orchids to wanting orchids themselves," thus illustrating the nature of orchid collecting — and collecting in general — as something that exists deep within certain human characters. By counterposing the history of orchid collecting in a non-narrative fashion against the narrative history of Laroche, Orlean illuminates an unusual man and shows him to be an example of a larger psychological phenomenon that has the potential to exist within many human beings.
In a narrative fashion as well, Orlean becomes a protagonist in her own drama. As a result of her reporter's fascination with Laroche, she finds herself hiking through the swamps of South Florida. Her view of Laroche is sympathetic enough that she is able to make him human, yet distanced enough that she is able to render this real-life character with the fictional intensity and visual aplomb worthy of Dickens.
Even in some of the non-narrative or non-dramatic segments, Laroche appears as both caricature and fully realized character. When Orlean first meets him in one of the narrative sequences, he is described as "a tall guy, skinny as a stick, pale-eyed, slouch-shouldered, and sharply handsome, in spite of the fact that he is missing all his front teeth," with "the posture of al dente spaghetti and the nervous intensity of someone who plays a lot of video games." She notes that he is called by the Seminole Tribe of Florida a "Crazy White Man" and a "Troublemaker."
Perhaps the combination of finicky orchid obsession, self-pride, and foolish daring comes through most clearly when this character first appears before the court, accused of a crime. In this narrative, dialogue-driven sequence, "Laroche sauntered to the center of the courtroom. He jutted out his chin. He spoke in a rasping, draggy voice. He stuck his thumbs in his belt loops and said, 'I've been a professional horticulturist for approximately twelve years. I've owned a plant nursery of my own.... I have extensive experience with orchids, and the asexual micropropagation of orchids under aseptic cultures.' Then he grinned and said to the court, 'I'm probably the smartest person I know.'"
You’re 61% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.