This paper examines the role of the prenatal environment in shaping human personality and mental health. Drawing on a Time Magazine article by Annie Paul (2010) and supporting academic research, the paper reviews evidence linking maternal malnutrition, emotional stress, and hormonal states to behavioral and psychological outcomes in children. It traces the biological pathways through which nutritional deficiencies—particularly iron and zinc—affect neural development, and extends this logic to argue that the mother's emotional state and associated chemical environment in the womb may similarly influence the developing child's personality. The paper concludes that prenatal care should be expanded to include maternal mental and emotional health.
The paper demonstrates evidence scaffolding: it establishes a well-supported premise (nutrition affects neural development) and then uses that precedent to argue for a related but less-proven claim (maternal emotional chemistry affects infant personality). This technique — building from the known toward the speculative — is a standard move in scientific argument and review writing.
The paper opens with a broad framing of personality development, introduces the central Time Magazine article, and then moves into a literature review section organized thematically: genetics and predisposition, nutritional deficiencies, and finally maternal emotional state. A brief conclusion synthesizes the findings and gestures toward policy implications. The glossary and full reference list follow the conclusion.
Human personality development is one of the greatest mysteries in the field of psychology. Decoding the unique combination of traits that makes us who we are as individuals goes beyond genetics. Environmental factors, social learning, and biological factors combine to shape who we become. Our personality consists of our reactions and feelings when presented with stimuli from the world around us — it is those reactions that define us. A recent article in Time Magazine presents research indicating that more occurs in utero than was first thought, and that the time we spend in the womb can affect our personality throughout the rest of our lives. This paper explores how the first nine months of life shape the personality that develops later as we grow older.
According to the article in Time Magazine, genetics go beyond simple inheritance from our parents. Many things can happen that damage or alter the genetic code we inherit. When our genes are changed by environmental factors, disease can develop. We might inherit a certain tendency from our parents, but that is not the end of the story. Perhaps the most surprising finding was that poor nutrition during a mother's pregnancy was linked to obesity and the development of diabetes in the child (Paul, 2010). The finding that famine experienced by the mother could cause schizophrenia in the child suggests that many other mental illnesses might also have their origin in the prenatal environment (Paul, 2010). The article goes on to suggest that the mental health of the newborn should begin to be a priority before birth, through treatment of the mother. It proposes that the prenatal environment and the mental stress of the mother can affect the personality of the child. The sections below examine the current body of research regarding this claim.
Current academic research supports the premises put forward in the Time Magazine article. The study of the effects of maternal mood and stress on the child has become a popular topic in recent years. Braungart-Rieker, Hill-Soderlund, and Karrass (2010) found that the fear and anger response is present as early as two to three months in newborns. It appears when their world is uncertain or their expectations are not met. These fear and anger responses continue to be refined as the child grows. Children learn to intervene and manage what bothers them, but in some cases they may be set — before they are even born — to become anxious, depressed, or fearful adults.
It has long been established that mental illness results from a combination of genetic and environmental factors. Genetic research has revealed that certain gene combinations predispose a person toward conditions such as depression or schizophrenia (Schmidt, 2007). Evidence now also supports the role of environmental factors in the development of mental illness. For instance, a person who experiences loss or a sense of danger, and who is genetically predisposed to conditions such as depression, anxiety, or schizophrenia, may develop mental illness as a result of environmental stressors (Schmidt, 2007). The net result of these studies is that individuals with a genetic predisposition can potentially be identified through genetic screening. The research also suggests that by preventing or altering the conditions that could trigger the expression of those tendencies, the development of the associated mental illness might be prevented. If risks and risk factors are known, targeted interventions can be developed.
The suggestion that maternal malnutrition could be linked to schizophrenia in the child is supported by several models connecting maternal nutritional deficiency to child mental health. Wachs (2009) found that nutritional deficiencies during the prenatal period could be positively linked to mental health problems. When one considers the biological and nutritional basis for the chemical processes that govern brain development and the formation of the nervous system in the fetus, this connection appears logical. Lozoff, Beard, and Connor et al. (2006) found that iron deficiency in infancy was linked to long-term neural and behavioral effects.
The nutritional basis for behavioral consequences during infancy has been a widely studied area. Several mental health issues have been linked to poor nutrition during this period. For instance, zinc has been found to have an impact on both maternal and child mental health. In one study, a zinc supplement was given to mothers and children with mental health problems, and both groups showed improvement with continued dosages (DiGirolamo & Ramirez-Zea, 2009). A study by Corapci, Calatroni, and Kaciroti et al. (2010) found similar results in a longitudinal study spanning 19 years.
These post-natal studies, together with others, demonstrate the connection between nutrition and mental illness. Once this connection is established, it is not difficult to extend it to the relationship between maternal nutrition and mental health in both mother and child. If nutrition affects the infant soon after birth and can have far-reaching consequences through the developing years, it follows that the nutritional status of the mother carries implications for the neural and brain development of the child. Maternal malnutrition can therefore contribute to mental illness in the infant. However, the Time Magazine article goes further still. It suggests that the emotional state of the mother and the resulting chemical environment in the womb can affect the personality of the child.
Recent research into the connection between the emotional state of the mother and the development of emotions in the child reveals a biological synergy that could lead to new frontiers in the prevention of not only physical defects, but also mental illness. This may be politically sensitive ground, as it implies that regulating emotions in pregnant women carries consequences. However, society has already moved in this direction on the issues of drug use, smoking, and alcohol consumption during pregnancy. As research progresses, this will add another layer to the understanding that parental responsibility begins before a child is even born.
You’re 60% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.