This paper examines the two primary career paths available to accounting graduates: public accounting and private accounting. It begins by clarifying the distinction between the two—public accountants work for accounting firms serving diverse clients, while private accountants work within a single company's finance department. The paper then compares the skill sets, daily responsibilities, workload demands, and long-term career trajectories associated with each path. Drawing on these comparisons, the author reflects on personal career goals, ultimately concluding that private accounting aligns best with a desire for stability, structured daily duties, and upward mobility toward senior finance roles such as controller or Chief Financial Officer.
Accounting has become one of the most popular degree choices in recent years because it can lead to a wide range of careers that are often more exciting than they initially sound. A student who chooses to pursue an accounting degree may find, after taking a few classes, that they must decide between different types of jobs. Beyond the more specialized careers that tend to require a master's degree, there are two primary avenues available to an accounting major. The first is working as a public accountant with an international, national, or regional firm; the second is working as a private accountant within a single company. This paper examines both types of accounting, evaluates their differences and similarities, and concludes with a personal set of goals that will shape the course of my own accounting career.
The distinctions between the two paths are many, so it is best to begin with what they share. Both paths require that an individual hold an accounting degree or, at the very least, possess sufficient experience and education in the field to accomplish the tasks required. The work that each type of accountant performs is similar in nature, though carried out at different scales. A person who thrives as a public accountant may not be content as a private accountant because, though the roles are related, they do demand different skill sets.
Before discussing the skills required for each career path, it is necessary to clearly define how the two differ. The distinction is not simply that one works for the private sector (business) and the other for the public sector (government), although that division can sometimes come into play. Public accountants generally work for a large accounting firm and serve diverse clients, which requires them to perform a wide variety of work depending on the contract at hand. There are four major accounting firms in the United States — PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, Ernst & Young, and KPMG (Ryan, 2009) — which employ large numbers of public accountants. Regional firms, though smaller, perform the same types of services. A private accountant, by contrast, works for a company that is not an accounting firm. This individual works within an accounting or finance department and handles only the financial work of the specific organization that employs them. These are significant differences, and the two paths naturally appeal to different types of people.
Public accountants interact with a wide variety of people in their daily work, which may appeal to certain accounting graduates. According to Ryan (2009), public accounting is a sector where communication and excellent people skills are essential. This means that, in addition to holding an accounting degree, the individual must have developed — or be naturally gifted with — interpersonal skills that allow them to work successfully with a diverse range of clients. Of course, possessing strong people skills does not obligate someone to pursue public accounting, but those skills are particularly valuable on this career path.
The workload in public accounting can also be demanding. As Freedman (2010) notes, young accountants who work with publicly traded clients help those clients meet strict Securities and Exchange Commission deadlines, which can mean working more than 100 hours a week for short periods without any increase in vacation time, as well as working fewer than 40 hours a week during slower periods of the year. This intense but variable workload is typically rewarded with increased compensation during peak periods, but it may not suit every young accountant's preferred lifestyle. Despite the heavy initial demands, public accounting offers a significant advantage when transitioning to other roles: because public accountants perform a great diversity of work, the experience looks impressive on a résumé (Freedman, 2010).
"Stability, duties, and advancement in corporate accounting"
"Author's preference for private accounting and long-term goals"
You’re 61% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.