This paper examines behavioral change through the lens of the Red Bull energy drink controversy. Beginning with the debate over whether energy drinks foster caffeine addiction, the paper defines addiction using Howard Shaffer's three C's model and traces the neuroscience of addictive substances. It then outlines the five stages of change—precontemplation through maintenance—before discussing Post Acute Withdrawal Syndrome (PAWS), its symptoms, and stabilization strategies. The paper concludes with a detailed review of relapse warning signs, drawing on Gorski and Miller's process model of relapse. Together, these sections offer a structured overview of how addictive behavior develops, persists, and can be addressed.
In 2005, critics of energy drinks argued that soft drink companies were profiting from caffeine addiction. As one report noted, "energy drinks have as much sugar and roughly three times the caffeine of soda, and some experts peg their popularity to their addictiveness" (Shepherd). Dr. Roland Griffiths of Johns Hopkins University observed that energy drink skeptics "contend that much of the skyrocketing growth of energy drinks comes because consumers are getting physically addicted" (Shepherd).
During 2003, individuals consumed 213 million cans of Red Bull, Britain's best-selling energy drink at the time. Claims surrounding Red Bull — dubbed the "clubbers' drink" — contributed to this highly caffeinated, fizzy beverage earning the informal title of "the Porsche of soft drinks." Because it is frequently mixed with vodka, some consumers assert that "Red Bull gives you wings." Several deaths have, however, been linked to Red Bull, and a number of experts have criticized the beverage's high levels of stimulants, including caffeine.
Due to health concerns, Europe's highest court upheld a French ban on the energy drink in 2004 (Nordqvist). A spokeswoman for Red Bull — which reported sales of 1.6 billion cans worldwide that same year — insisted the product was safe, that no proof existed linking it to any unhealthy effects, and that it would continue to be marketed in 100 countries across the world (Nordqvist). Prior to his 2005 declaration relating Red Bull to addiction, Dr. Griffiths had, in 2004, hesitated to classify caffeine dependency as an addiction (Shepherd).
Along with conflicting ideas regarding what does or does not qualify as an unhealthy or addictive substance, a myriad of opinions surround not only addiction itself, but also withdrawal from addictive substances and the phenomenon of relapse. This paper explores these three factors as they relate to behavioral change.
To reduce inconsistency and avoid confusion in the field of addiction research, researchers and clinicians developed practical operational frameworks. One widely adopted model is the application of the three C's, which defines addiction through the following criteria:
According to Begley, addictive drugs alter the brain's pleasure circuits, causing an addicted individual's brain to differ physically and chemically from a non-addicted brain. Through repeated use or abuse of addictive substances, a decline in dopamine receptors occurs. As a result, experiences that previously brought pleasurable feelings to a person become far less effective at doing so.
For a variety of problem behaviors, researchers have conceptualized the following five stages of change:
Precontemplation: During this stage, many individuals are unaware or under-aware of the problems they are experiencing. They do not intend to change their behavior in the foreseeable future.
Contemplation: In this stage, individuals understand that a problem behavior exists and contemplate ways to overcome it, but have not yet committed to taking action.
Preparation: Individuals in this stage have unsuccessfully attempted to change in the past year. They unite intention with behavioral readiness and fully intend to take action within the next month.
Action: In this stage, individuals modify their behavior, environment, or experiences in order to overcome their problems. This stage involves overt behavioral changes and requires that a person invest and commit considerable time and energy to changing their behavior.
Maintenance: During this final stage, individuals deliberately work to prevent relapse and consolidate the gains achieved during the action stage. This stage varies in length and may last from six months to an indefinite period following the initial action (Stages).
"PAWS symptoms and the challenge of sobriety"
"Techniques and components for managing withdrawal"
"Relapse warning signs and recovery perspectives"
You’re 41% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.