This paper examines the contrasting portrayals of religion in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and Yann Martel's Life of Pi. While Hawthorne uses his novel to critique Puritan religious authority as a tool of social oppression and patriarchal control, Martel presents religion as a subjective psychological resource that sustains individuals through crisis. Drawing on annotated secondary sources, the paper argues that these two works together illustrate how literary treatments of religion have shifted over time — from modern critiques of institutional hypocrisy to postmodern explorations of personal faith and spirituality as universal human impulses.
Religion features prominently as a theme in literature. Some of the earliest works of literature are rooted in their religious and cultural traditions, including the ancient literatures of the Middle East and Mesopotamia. As the role of religion in society changed, so too did the role of religion in literature.
Modern literature, including the work of Nathaniel Hawthorne, often offers scathing critiques of religion, whereas postmodern literature allows religion to play a more complex role in shaping individual identity. Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter heavily criticizes the role of religion in a patriarchal society, whereas Yann Martel's Life of Pi presents religion more as a subjective phenomenon — revealing an important cultural shift from institutional religion to personal spirituality.
In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter, the author shows how religion becomes a tool of social oppression and political control. Hawthorne demonstrates that religious authorities are hypocritical — and especially fundamentalists — as the Puritans in the novel do not practice what they preach (Mills). Hester Prynne emerges as the novel's heroine because she liberates herself from the patriarchal constraints of Puritanism (Gilligan).
In Yann Martel's Life of Pi, the author shows how religion serves as a psychological salve for people in times of stress. Pi Patel's faith in God allows him to maintain strength and courage even when faced with seemingly insurmountable obstacles. As one scholar observes, "Life of Pi attempts not to prove God's existence, but to justify belief in Him" (Stratton 6).
Religion, in Martel's treatment, requires the act of faith, which matters more than the doctrinal aspects of any given religion. As Cole argues, "Religion arises from a perceptual strategy by which we contrive to alleviate our perpetual uncertainty — or doubt, or disbelief" (Cole 33). Belief in God and prayer are presented as universal human impulses, which is why Pi holds that all faiths are equally valid.
Martel ultimately suggests that faith and a "journey toward enlightenment" can be secular activities (Stewart 41), reflecting the author's own secular background and his broader postmodern stance on the nature of truth and reality.
"Two novels illuminate different, complementary facets of religion"
"Evaluative notes on five secondary scholarly sources"
You’re 38% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.