This paper offers a comparative analysis of Shakespeare's Richard III and Homer's The Odyssey, arguing that both works center on the struggle between good and evil. The paper examines Richard III as a psychopathic villain driven by self-serving ambition and devoid of remorse, contrasting him with Odysseus, a fundamentally virtuous hero whose flaws stem from vanity and human frailty rather than malice. It also explores the role of supernatural forces — the cursing ghosts in Richard III and the goddess Athena in The Odyssey — as catalysts that ultimately ensure the triumph of good over evil in both narratives.
The focus of both Shakespeare's Richard III and Homer's The Odyssey is the struggle between good and evil. Each work shows the consequences of following temptation and how, in the end, good triumphs over evil.
Richard is evil personified. Due to his complete lack of compassion or humanity, there is no other conclusion to draw except that Richard is psychopathic. He is essentially a serial killer with a self-promoting plan (Shakespeare 1996). His every intention is to be in complete control at any cost; nothing and no one will stand in his way. Although Richard might initially be taken as simply a jealous, physically deformed man seeking revenge against his older brother, by the end of the play he has become a monster — the epitome of evil — feeding on power and death in a mad frenzy to obtain his goal (Shakespeare 1996).
Like most psychopaths, Richard is able to mask his evil and present an innocent face to those around him. He manipulates others by gaining sympathy for his physical condition and convincing them that he is unloved because of his deformity (Shakespeare 1996). His strongest challenger is the Earl of Richmond, who finally gathers forces to battle Richard for the throne. Throughout the play, Richard shows no remorse for any of the murders he commits; however, the night before his battle with Richmond, all the people he has killed visit him in a dream. They curse him and tell him that he will die in battle the following day — and the next morning, Richard is indeed killed in combat (Shakespeare 1996). Richmond is crowned king, marries the young Elizabeth, and England is promised an era of peace. It is as though Richard believes himself justified in the murders, viewing himself as victimized and isolated because of his deformity by those who should love him; yet his madness progresses, pure evil takes total control, and he leaves a wake of death behind him (Shakespeare 1996).
Odysseus is fundamentally a good soul. He is heroic, courageous, confident, and fearless. He is also intelligent and articulate, with the ability to think on his feet in difficult situations (Homer 1998). However, he is human, and so is subject to human frailties and temptations. Odysseus is charming — so charming, in fact, that Athena has a soft spot for him and aids him throughout his journey home (Homer 1998). He wins the attention of many women during his travels, some of whom do not have his best interests at heart. Although Odysseus is skilled at manipulation — as when he wins Nausicaa's trust on the island of Scheria — he is also easily enticed into indulgence, such as his prolonged stay with Circe, with whom he enjoys a life of luxury, even while professing devotion to his wife Penelope (Homer 1998).
Odysseus's pride and love of glory are what entangle him with evil and expose him to its consequences. When he obeys Athena, all goes well for him; when he strays, he falls. To reclaim his wife and his rightful position, he disguises himself as a beggar, thereby humbling himself in a way that marks his moral growth (Homer 1998).
"Contrasting motivations and supernatural roles in each work"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.