This paper examines the myth of Santa Claus through multiple philosophical and sociological frameworks, arguing that the legend serves primarily as a mechanism of social control. Drawing on the ideas of Immanuel Kant, Ernst Cassirer, Roland Barthes, Theodor Adorno, Max Horkheimer, Alexis de Tocqueville, José Ortega y Gasset, and Alfred E. Taylor, the paper traces how adults perpetuate a childhood myth they no longer believe in order to regulate children's behavior. It further explores parallels between belief in Santa Claus and belief in God, and situates the myth within Marxist ideology as a tool wielded by those who possess the truth over those who do not.
One of the most pervasive myths in Christian American culture is the myth of Old Saint Nick. Santa Claus is a cherished childhood memory for millions of adults around the world. The story of the jolly old man who brings joy and happiness to good children every year has so thoroughly saturated the concept of Christmas that many children completely forget the religious importance of the holiday. This myth is one that becomes distorted as each individual ages. Santa Claus increasingly becomes a way for adults to control the behavior of their children as each person grows out of believing in the fantastical.
Christmas is the holiest Christian holiday of the year, representing the birth of Jesus Christ — the son of God according to Christian dogma. Yet one saint has morphed into a figure who has essentially stolen the show in the minds of most children. In contemporary society, Christmas is strongly associated with Santa Claus, who brings gifts to children who have behaved well throughout the year. According to the myth, Santa Claus can observe all children and their behavior at all times. Children who have been bad do not receive the lavish toys that well-behaved children do. He commands an entire army of elves who work endlessly all year to produce coveted toys for good children across the globe. Mainstream culture has thus transformed Christmas into a system for rewarding children for desired behavior.
As each child eventually learns the truth behind their parents' holiday deception, those new adults do not abandon Santa Claus — rather, they employ the myth with a Marxist twist of religious ideology. Parents everywhere deceive their children for years in order to influence their behavior and exert control over them. This dynamic can be illuminated through the application of various social and Marxist theories to the childhood dream of Santa Claus.
Plato's philosophies draw heavily on the words and teachings of his mentor Socrates. He frequently compares adults to children while describing Socratic philosophy — a comparison that would later be echoed by the philosopher Immanuel Kant, who believed that adults and children are parallel in remarkable and underappreciated ways. Plato's writings portray the father as a powerful influence in the lives of his sons (Plato, Symposium). Had Plato known the modern myth of Santa Claus, it would have served as yet another example of how a father's words can lead his son to believe even the most extraordinary stories. By tempting children with rewards, parents control their behavior in order to instill within them a sense of morality.
No child has ever seen Santa Claus, yet they believe in him wholeheartedly. According to Kant, no adult has ever seen God, yet they — like children — believe in him without reservation (McCormick, 2006). Despite the fact that we can never acquire direct knowledge of what lies beyond death, billions of people across the globe believe in a supernatural God. The myth of Santa Claus does for children what God does for adults. In Kant's framework, Santa Claus is parallel to God: children will never see or feel him, yet he is absolutely real to them. Even after individuals discover the truth, they continue to perpetuate the myth as a means of controlling their own children. Rather than behaving in life in order to earn entry into the afterlife, children behave in order to earn presents.
Ernst Cassirer would follow Kant's ideas in a complementary direction. He argues that human beings need symbols to create meaning and make sense of the world. According to Cassirer's framework, Santa Claus is a product of adult action designed to elicit the positive behavior they desire from children. In his work Mythologies, Roland Barthes explores the idea that myths are used to control behavior. The myth of Santa Claus is deployed by those who know the truth in order to benefit themselves. Children who display good behavior represent greater parental control — and the myth is the instrument through which that control is exercised.
"Adorno and Horkheimer frame Santa as ideological domination"
"Santa myth empowers parents across all classes and minorities"
The myth of Santa Claus ultimately transcends a simple childhood fantasy. Viewed through the lens of multiple philosophical traditions — from Plato and Kant to Cassirer, Barthes, Adorno, and Ortega y Gasset — it emerges as a sophisticated instrument of social and ideological control available to parents of every class and background. The myth endures not because adults have forgotten the truth, but precisely because they remember it.
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.