This paper examines Walmart's approach to financing both short-term and long-term capital projects, using two concrete examples: opening a new retail store and implementing a major IT infrastructure system. It evaluates the role of working capital, retained earnings, and debt in each scenario, taking into account Walmart's existing capital structure — approximately 62% liabilities and 38% equity. The paper argues that, given Walmart's high leverage and tight margins, equity financing is the more prudent choice for both project types, particularly for domestic U.S. initiatives where the core market is mature and additional debt would increase organizational risk.
Walmart regularly undertakes both short-term and long-term capital projects, each of which carries distinct financing considerations. The appropriate financing decision depends on the nature and duration of the project, the company's ideal capital structure, and the cost of capital — but it must also account for the realities of Walmart's existing balance sheet. Two illustrative examples — opening a new retail store and building a new IT system — help demonstrate how these factors interact in practice.
An example of a short-term project that Walmart undertakes is opening a new store. The company regularly opens new stores, and it typically takes several months from start to finish. New stores have a relatively indefinite operating life, making them capital projects, yet they are short-term in nature before they begin generating revenues of their own. The life span of the project suggests that equity financing may be more appropriate. For a short-term project, equity typically comes from working capital by way of retained earnings.
For short-term projects, Walmart should finance from cash. The financing decision should be based on the company's ideal capital structure and cost of capital, but it should also account for the company's existing balance sheet. Walmart holds approximately $7 billion in cash, which means the company can finance most operating expenses from its existing working capital without accessing external capital markets. One important principle in the financing decision is that the time frame of the financing should match the time frame of the project. This means that projects arising within the context of everyday operations should be financed through the company's operations.
An example of a long-term project at Walmart is building a new IT system to help route goods through the company's network of warehouses. The project is expected to have a usable life of twenty years. Because the cost of the project would run into the hundreds of millions of dollars, it qualifies as a long-term capital budgeting project. The new IT system is expected to result in direct cost savings for the company over its useful life.
Financing a long-term project is more challenging than financing a short-term one. The nature of the project matters, as some projects have finite lives while others have relatively indefinite lives. The firm's ideal capital structure also needs to be considered. Typically, debt financing is cheaper than equity financing. However, the cost of debt must be weighed against the fact that debt represents an obligation that must be met before earnings can be reinvested in the company or distributed to shareholders. As a result, debt increases the overall risk level of the organization.
It is worth noting that Walmart operates on tight margins, which means the firm retains a relatively low amount of free cash flow once expenses are paid. Walmart may hold a large cash balance, but it uses most of that cash in the course of its operations. Walmart's balance sheet reflects roughly 62% liabilities and 38% equity, indicating that the company is already a highly leveraged organization.
While Walmart is an expanding company globally, its core U.S. market is more or less mature. For any domestic project, equity financing should therefore be used where possible in order to limit further growth in Walmart's debt burden. Equity financing avoids the additional debt obligation and reduces the associated financial risk. It is also worth noting that Walmart has access to sufficient capital today to finance this type of project internally. If the company had to go to capital markets to raise the money, a different decision might be warranted given the complexity and cost of that process. For Walmart, however, even a project running into the hundreds of millions over a long time frame can be financed through existing equity rather than through external capital markets. This view aligns with broader corporate finance principles suggesting that internal financing is generally preferable when accessible and cost-effective.
"Final recommendation favoring equity over new debt"
You’re 83% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.