Verified Document

GAO Case Study Case In Point, File Case Study

GAO Case Study Case in point, File B-293049 and B-293049.2 dated January 23, 2004 is a decision between the United States General Accounting Office and Computer Information Specialists, hereby known as CIS. The document, however, has been subjected to a GAO Protective Order, and therefore only a sanitized version has been approved for public release.

Facts of the Case- Essentially, the case involves a protest by Computer Information Specialists who bid on a contract (RFP NLM-03-101/.SAN). CIS bid on the RFP, which was issued by the National Library of Medicine and the National Institutes of Health to acquire telecommunications support services at the Bethesda, Maryland campus. CIS alleges that the government awarded the contract to the Open Technology Group (OTG) based on misevaluated research and made an unreasonable source decision. CIS holds that they had the more appropriate proposal, much of which was ignored by the government evaluators.

Issues Involved in Case- The review of the decision by the NLM and NIH was made by the U.S. GAO's Comptroller General of the United States. Several relevant facts were uncovered during the investigation:

The agency received a number of proposals and established a range...

Each portion of the proposal was assigned a weight, with value being more important than price.
In the matrix, OTG received the highest score of the four, CIS the lowest. However, of five evaluations, four only prepared cursory narrative comments to even support their scoring of the CIS proposals. Any deficiencies brought to CIS's attention were immediately cured, according to the company.

Once these deficiencies were cured, the evaluators raised their scores but provided little or no justification, thus the entire decision on CIS was based on the 5th evaluator (20% of the scoring committee).

The conclusions reached by Evaluator 5 were found to be problematic, unreasonable and based more on subjective opinion and commentary on prose rather than factual data.

The evaluator's further language does not include a technical approach, nor an explanation of such an approach. It was found to be unprofessional and unsubstantiated in relation to decisions necessary.

Decisions (Holdings) -- The appeal of CIS was sustained by the GAO and recommendations ensued.

Decision Support -- The GAO was not in a position to re-evaluate the proposals, only to rule on whether…

Sources used in this document:
Government Accounting Office. (23 January 2004). Decision in the Matter of Computer

Information Specialists, Inc. B-293049; B-293049.2. Washington, DC: United States

Government Accounting Office.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Confonting the Amman-Zarqa Lrs Conceived
Words: 6876 Length: 25 Document Type: Case Study

Some type Government involvement and regulation, Nguyen (2009) asserts, proves critical to helping ensure the private sector r thrives. Many of world's leading economies concur that Governments must be involved to best manage their country's economy. Control, however, needs to extend beyond the control and regulation of the private sector per se. For the country's overall development, the better process includes the synergies of both private and public sectors being

Offshore Financial Centres and Their
Words: 22477 Length: 60 Document Type: Dissertation

Because the home country is not required to reimburse foreign depositors for losses, there is no corresponding financial penalty for lax supervision; there is, though, a benefit to the country with lenient regulatory policies because of increased revenues generated and the employment opportunities these services provide (Edwards 1999). Furthermore, banks seeking to conduct multinational business are attracted to countries where incorporation laws and the regulatory framework offer less regulatory oversight

Protest Centered on Alleged Misevaluation
Words: 878 Length: 3 Document Type: Article Review

Other protests presented by CIS included unfair evaluation of OTG - another presenting company. Complaints here included vague requirements; insufficient detail as to why they rejected proposal; apparent duplicity (as in the case of implying that three of its present employees were available for position); and ambiguous and vague language in its blanket statements. The decision was that the agency misevaluated the proposal of CIS as well as that of OTG,

Change Management & Organizational Transformation
Words: 5634 Length: 20 Document Type: Thesis

(GAO, 2008) These criteria are stated to "inform many other elements of the positions, including roles and responsibilities, job qualifications, reporting relationships, and decision-making structure and processes." (Dejewski, 2007) Three types of COO/CMO positions were identified as follows: (1) the existing deputy position could carry out the integration and business transformation role. This type of COO/CMO might be appropriate in a relatively stable or small organization; (2) a senior-level executive who reports to

Impact of Sarbanes Oxley Act of 2002 in Reducing Fraudulent Financial...
Words: 6052 Length: 15 Document Type: Literature Review

Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 in reducing fraudulent financial reporting Introduction to Fraudulent Financial Reporting Available research on financial statement fraud relies mostly on anecdotal evidence (for example, Wells, 2001, 2002, 2004a, and 2004b; Rezaee, 2003). This evidence offers advice on how mechanisms related to the fraud triangle can be curtailed. It leads to theoretical sense to reduce factors which lead to more instances of fraud. However, deterrence and established deterrence methods

Interdisciplinary Approaches to Learning How
Words: 7785 Length: 28 Document Type: Assessment

65). By controlling these two aspects of a scientific experiment, researchers are able to establish the specific causality of the phenomenon being studied. In this regard, Kahle and Riley note that, "Traditionally, causality is established through strict control and randomization over all other factors while experimentally manipulating the variable or variables in question" (2004, p. 165). Finally, Gliner and Morgan (2000) report that the internal validity (discussed further below)

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now