Competition Orthodox Economic Thought Holds Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Competition in these markets, therefore, is unlikely to be on the basis of product innovation. Service innovation is possible to some degree with the Internet, but there are only so many ways to deliver insurance -- it is a product centuries old and not subject to much innovation. In a market like this, service and price are two methods of gaining competitive advantage. Private insurance firms use proprietary actuarial tables to set rates, and this might be the only way that an insurance firm can gain advantage, since it is nearly impossible to derive sustainable competitive advantage from service. Thus, profit margins are slim and a firm can improve the spread between the table and the consumer price only by increasing volume. This leads to a price war as firms fight for market share. Knowing that price wars are devastating to businesses on already thin margins, the companies in the industry instead begin to spend on marketing. In addition to insurance in Europe we see this in a number of telecommunications markets, and frequently in the global beer market, among other industries. Products and services are not differentiated because the firms in the industry cannot conceive of how to do so, so they spend extravagantly to outmarket each other. Since they all do it, they all pass the same costs onto customers.

What this shows is that for some industries -- and it depends on the specific industry characteristics -- the nature of competition may lead to higher prices rather than lower, particularly if extensive marketing is considered by the industry players to be the main way to improve market share. Government monopolies, of course, have little need for marketing since their audience is already captive. Thus, they can be profitable at lower price levels…and they are not always trying to do anything more than break even.

Impact on Consumers

Orthodox economic theory holds that consumers will see a range of benefits from competition, not just lower prices. This assumption, however, derives from the assumption that firms within an industry will compete on a number of different levels. However, in some industries we know that not to be the case. The result is that competition does not have any marked benefit to consumers. The reason that governments become involved in some industries is because they consider the product or service to be a public good. Generally, public goods are characterized as having benefits beyond simple economic outcomes. Insurance, for example, standardizes the terms of insurance and can improve the quality of coverage because the government is motivated to deliver a high level of coverage, not just a low cost of coverage. Backed by the government's resources, this is entirely possible for a government-run insurance company.

Conclusions

That competition does not always deliver superior outcomes to consumers than monopolies is easy to understand when one understands the differences between a government-run monopoly situation and a corporate monopoly. The latter, arguably, are always worse for the consumer than competition. The former, however, need not be. Without the need to spend on market, the state-run monopoly can keep prices lower and/or plow earnings back into delivering higher service levels or a better product. The goods and services subject to government monopolies are typically ones where consumers are motivated by benefits beyond price -- the state run monopoly can focus specifically on those benefits without doing a cost-benefit analysis on them. This is not to say that a state-run monopoly is always going to outperform a competitive market. Certainly the market conditions will have an impact on whether the industry is suitable for government monopoly. Additionally, a poorly-run or greedy government monopoly that behaves like a corporation will deliver worse results than a competitive market. But that rule is not as universal as economic orthodoxy would have us believe.

Works Cited:

Baily, M.; Gordon, R.; Bresnahan, T. (1993). Competition, regulation and efficiency in service industries. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Microeconomics. Vol. 1993 (2) 71-159.

Epple, K. & Schafer, R. (1996). The transition from monopoly to competition: The case of housing insurance in Baden-Wurttemberg. European Economic Review. Vol. 40 (1996) 1123-1131.

Felder, S. (1996). Fire insurance in Germany: A comparison of price-performance between state monopolies and competitive regions. European Economic Review. Vol. 40 (1996) 1133-1141.

Ungern, T. (1996). The limits…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Competition Orthodox Economic Thought Holds" (2011, November 30) Retrieved December 10, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/competition-orthodox-economic-thought-holds-48062

"Competition Orthodox Economic Thought Holds" 30 November 2011. Web.10 December. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/competition-orthodox-economic-thought-holds-48062>

"Competition Orthodox Economic Thought Holds", 30 November 2011, Accessed.10 December. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/competition-orthodox-economic-thought-holds-48062

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Keynes and the Liquidity Trap

    Critically for the long-term economic situation, it meant many Japanese firms were lumbered with massive debts, affecting their ability for capital investment. It also meant credit became very difficult to obtain, due to the beleaguered situation of the banks; even now the official interest rate is at 0% and have been for several years, and despite this credit is still difficult to obtain Overall, this has led to the phenomenon

  • International Marketing

    International Marketing Comparison of Spain and Czech Republic This paper is written out in the form of a comparison between the two countries of Spain and Czech Republic. In all the sub-heads, the situation in Spain is first discussed and that is followed by the relevant description about the Czech Republic. In all reasonableness, Spain has been a poor country with low employment, and this is being solved with temporary employment

  • Religion Entered the 18th Century and With

    religion entered the 18th Century and with it a revival. The growth of the revival was overwhelming.More people attended church than in previous centuries. Churches from all denominations popped up throughout established colonies and cities within the United States. Religious growth also spread throughout England, Wales and Scotland. This was a time referred to as "The Great Awakening" where people like Jarena Lee got her start preaching. Evangelism, the epicenter

  • Socialist Zionist Beliefs Colin Shindler

    There is much to the assertion by Nachman Syrkin that the Jews have persisted in history because the performed a socio-economic function that other peoples did not want to do or could not do. In his 1898 "The Jewish Problem and the Socialist Jewish State, " Syrkin lays out these ideas. Regarding this, Syrkin argued that a classless society and national sovereignty were the only means of solving the Jewish

  • Slavophilic Russian Ideas vs The

    This similarly encourages modest investment in Russia, a market of 150 million, even in the face of continuing economic difficulties and political uncertainty (Saunders, 105). According to Sunders, the strategy developed to "globalize" Russia was known as "shock therapy." And its implementation began with the January 1, 1992 elimination of price controls on most goods. The objective of "shock therapy" was, in essence, to create a market economy in Russia

  • Applying Servant Leadership Within a

    Initially, I had to point out when people were saying things that would indicate a connection between group members. However, once those connections were established, the group members moved rather rapidly towards directly relating with one another. Another result of the group meetings is that the group members initially appeared very focused on the past. Small groups tend to do postmortems of old failures, archaeologizing (digging in the past for

  • Clinical Psychology

    Dream Content as a Therapeutic Approach: Ego Gratification vs. Repressed Feelings An Abstract of a Dissertation This study sets out to determine how dreams can be used in a therapeutic environment to discuss feelings from a dream, and how the therapist should engage the patient to discuss them to reveal the relevance of those feelings, in their present, waking life. It also discusses the meaning of repetitious dreams, how medication affects the


Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved