Descartes' Famous Maxim "I; I " Why Essay

¶ … Descartes' famous maxim "I; I "? Why statement fundamental method? (3-4 Paragraphs) Describe Newton's method. How arrive conclusions? (3-4Paragraphs) Describe views John Locke: state nature, social contract, revolution, govern, property rights. Q1.Descartes

Descartes began his famous series of Meditations with a resolution to doubt everything: this kind of hyperbolic skepticism was used to advance his use of the deductive approach to philosophy. Descartes was fundamentally a rationalist, and believed that truth could be obtained only through mental reasoning, not through observation. Observation was rooted 'in the body' and potentially faulty, human observation. At the beginning of his philosophical tract, "his basic strategy was to consider false any belief that falls prey to even the slightest doubt" including his own existence (Skirry 2008). Sensations can deceive us, but logic cannot, since even if we are dreaming, 2+2=4. Eventually, after engaging in radical questioning of his belief structures, Descartes decided that because some entity is thinking and doing the doubting than 'I' (Descartes) exist.

"Descartes distinguishes intellectual perception and volition as what properly belongs to the nature of the mind alone while imagination and sensation are, in some sense, faculties of the mind insofar as it is united with a body" (Skirry 2008). The body, because of the subjective nature of sensation, can deceive us, but the mind cannot -- therefore 'I think; therefore I am.' Through rationalism and reason, Descartes makes 'I think, therefore I am' the core of his philosophy. "For if I convinced myself that my beliefs are false, then surely there must be an 'I' that was convinced. Moreover, even if I am being deceived by an evil demon, I must exist in order to be deceived at all" (Skirry 2008)....

...

So "I must finally conclude that the proposition, 'I am,' 'I exist,' is necessarily true whenever it is put forward by me or conceived in my mind" (Skirry 2008).
The mind cannot be doubted and although it may be deluded, it still is a 'thing' that is being deluded, and thus it exists. The certainty that he exists enables Descartes, over the course of the Meditations, to prove that other minds exist and God exists. God exists because God exists as an idea in the mind and there is no way that a perfect being could be conceived of in the (imperfect) human mind. The existence of the idea of God in the mind means that God exists, hence the importance that Descartes has a (thinking) mind to have an idea of God.

Q2. Newton

Newton's method was fundamentally scientific and analytic in nature. While it was created to explain and justify Newton's own theories, it was also "truly universal in its scope" (Wesstein 2012). Newton's four rules are as follows "(1) we are to admit no more causes of natural things such as are both true and sufficient to explain their appearances, (2) the same natural effects must be assigned to the same causes, (3) qualities of bodies are to be esteemed as universal, and (4) propositions deduced from observation of phenomena should be viewed as accurate until other phenomena contradict them" (Wesstein 2012).

This method, in contrast to pure rationalism, was founded upon empirical observation of natural phenomena. Newton believed that rationalistic analysis alone could not be used to justify what was not immediately apparent. In contrast to Descartes, Newton was not concerned with doubting the existence of external reality. He was also comfortable in drawing common lines of causality between different observed phenomena, and did not doubt the senses to the point that the…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Skirry, Justin. "Descartes, Rene: Overview." The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2008.

[12 Jul 2012] http://www.iep.utm.edu/descarte/

Kemerling, Garth. "John Locke." Philosophy Pages. [12 Jul 2012]

Last modified 12 November 2011. http://www.philosophypages.com/hy/4n.htm
2007. [12 Jul 2012] http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/biography/Newton.html
http://www.lps.uci.edu/node/12243


Cite this Document:

"Descartes' Famous Maxim I I Why" (2012, July 13) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/descartes-famous-maxim-i-i-why-81112

"Descartes' Famous Maxim I I Why" 13 July 2012. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/descartes-famous-maxim-i-i-why-81112>

"Descartes' Famous Maxim I I Why", 13 July 2012, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/descartes-famous-maxim-i-i-why-81112

Related Documents

Improvement" is not necessarily implied, because humans do not currently possess an understanding of the environment sufficient to ensure that "improvements" do not become counterproductive; however, attempts to correct human damage is at times appropriate, when the scenario is simple enough. The necessity of accepting this precedent transcends the mere logical. In truth, it is the only precedent that can be accepted, because for all that humans revel in their marvelous

Descartes' Major Tenets Descartes Major Tenets Descartes was one of the most well-respected thinkers of his time, and he applied his special brand of logic to a wide-variety of disciplines, most notably mathematics and philosophy. The Cartesian approach to philosophy, like many approaches to philosophy, looked at the interaction of the mind and the brain. Were the mind and the brain one united organism, did they interact with one another, was one

The previous sorts of error apply to particular classes of object or condition: refraction (so far as common errors of perception are concerned) affects the appearance of sticks in water and a few other things; jaundice, so it is said, affects apparent color. But anything I can perceive, I can dream that I perceive. Confronted with an apparently bent stick, experience of refraction-illusions can put me on my guard

Sensory experiences are nor reliable for making any statements, since people often mistake one thing for another. (Descartes talks about mirages). Knowledge based on reasoning is not always trustworthy, because people often make mistakes. (adding numbers is a classical example). Finally, knowledge is deemed by Descartes to be illusory, since it may come from dreams or insanity or from demons able to deceive men by making them believe that

The fifth chapter turns from metaphysics to physics and applies his universal laws to scientific pursuits. The fifth chapter offers the reader one of the most challenging of applications, the superiority of man over beast, as the beast contains no soul, no reason and no thinking mind, and according to Descarts this is easily assumed because animals do not talk, therefore they do not reason and have no mind separate

Free Will" Exist and if so, to What Extent does it Exist? The concept of "Free Will" has been debated by many philosophers over a period of centuries, not only regarding its very existence but also regarding its elements, the extent to which it may or may not exist and its moral implications. Our assigned readings have merely touched on debates that have raged and will probably continue to rage