Discrimination And Affirmative Action In Essay

The second is that non-minority companies far outweighed their minority counterparts in the level of service that would be provided. In the first case, the deontological viewpoint would not have been applicable, as there were no companies available to meet the minority standards. The ethical argument might then be that, all persons should have an equal right to receive the contract, and be chosen on merit. The second case could then have been decided on the grounds of a utilitarian approach. Quality of service takes precedence over human rights considerations.

The utilitarian viewpoint also considers the importance of quality of the specific service involved, as well as the setting and safety levels promoted by the service. In an airport setting, public and professional safety are of utmost concern. A company that provides shuttle services should therefore provide high value in terms of vehicle and logistical safety. When awarding a contract in an airport setting, utilitarian issues should take precedence over deontological ones. If no correlation can be found between deontological ethics and the utilitarian viewpoint, utility should overrule where public safety is a concern.

In investigating this case, it is therefore important to have an understanding of the details of the case. Only once the deontological and utilitarian issues are clear can a judgment be made of whether the case indeed has merit or not. It should also be considered that minority programs are often controversial and could be unfair in terms...

...

This is not desirable in terms of utility, where the greatest good is served, especially in matters that affect citizens that are not as concerned with the merits of the case as with their own safety and well-being.
The question of whether the contract should have been awarded to the specific company is therefore a somewhat difficult one to answer with absolute certainly. Many variables govern the decision. It can however be assumed that Maryland Airport is as concerned with the safety of their citizens as it is with equity in employment and business. Certainly the managers have carefully considered their options and the outcomes of each possible decision. Any accusations to the contrary should therefore be empirically substantiated by concrete evidence.

Sources

Smitherman, Laura. (2008, Aug 7).

Board OKs contract for company that failed to meet minority goals. Tribune Business News. Washington. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?index=0&did=1526873651&SrchMod e=1&sid=25&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1236295162&c lientId=29440

Teall, E. (2000). Ethics in the Workplace. Dept of Educational Technology, San Diego University. http://school.teall.net/ethman/info/util.htm

Sources Used in Documents:

Sources

Smitherman, Laura. (2008, Aug 7).

Board OKs contract for company that failed to meet minority goals. Tribune Business News. Washington. http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?index=0&did=1526873651&SrchMod e=1&sid=25&Fmt=3&VInst=PROD&VType=PQD&RQT=309&VName=PQD&TS=1236295162&c lientId=29440

Teall, E. (2000). Ethics in the Workplace. Dept of Educational Technology, San Diego University. http://school.teall.net/ethman/info/util.htm


Cite this Document:

"Discrimination And Affirmative Action In" (2009, September 18) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/discrimination-and-affirmative-action-in-19326

"Discrimination And Affirmative Action In" 18 September 2009. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/discrimination-and-affirmative-action-in-19326>

"Discrimination And Affirmative Action In", 18 September 2009, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/discrimination-and-affirmative-action-in-19326

Related Documents

Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity The policies of affirmative action aiming at assisting the black Americans are of recent origin. The policies have sought its origin to varied sources like legal structure, executive instructions, and court rulings. It was during the last three decades that these policies were being developed and they have become debatable as well. (Legal History) During the last three decades of the nineteenth century, a large number of African-Americans

Affirmative Action: Why We Need to Reform It It is widely believed that the American society is a "melting pot" where members of racial, ethnic, religious, and sexual minorities eventually mold into the mainstream, becoming full-fledged citizens of the country. The reality, however, is much more complicated. While it is true that America offers many opportunities to all its citizens, there is a history of discrimination against minority groups that affects

Affirmative Action At its most objective definition, affirmative action entails "positive steps taken to increase the representation of women and minorities in areas of employment, education, and business from which they have been historically excluded." Affirmative action acknowledges the presence of institutionalized and systematic forms of discrimination: which may not be apparent to members of the dominant or privileged culture. For example, white males will not even notice that no Blacks

Affirmative Action Ever since the upheavals of the 1960s precipitated a fundamental change in the way the United States regards civil rights, the notion of affirmative action has been regularly discussed and misunderstood throughout the national discourse. Requirements that certain employers enact affirmative action plans began with an executive order on the heels of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title VII of which specifies that employers may not discriminate on

Affirmative Action
PAGES 15 WORDS 4199

This is a particular problem at the nation's colleges and universities. This has become so much of an issue that law suits and verdicts have been handed down in some states. One of the most famous cases to date involved the University of Michigan's undergraduate and law school policies. These cases are Gratz v. Bollinger and Grutter v. Bollinger. In 1997, Jennifer Gratz, a white woman, sued the University of

Affirmative Action is the set of public policies and initiatives designed to help eliminate past and present discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Affirmative action was set into place during the 1960's. Focusing in particular on education and jobs, affirmative action policies required that active measures be taken to ensure that blacks and other minorities enjoyed the same opportunities for promotions, salary increases, career advancement, school