Patient Satisfaction in Quality of Managed Care Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

Patient Satisfaction in Quality of Managed Care

Aspect to be compared

Gender and Patient

Satisfaction in Managed Care, etc.

Stakeholder Perceptions of Quality in Managed Care Plans

Two Steps to Enhance Managed Care Quality


Emily Weisman, MS

Martha Romans

Jacobs Institute of Women's Health

Washington, DC

Carolyn M. Clancy, MD

Paul L. Grimaldi, Ph.D.

To determine what the differences are and what variables might affect women patients' perceptions of the quality of managed care

To find out what attributes three different health care stakeholders, physicians, employers and consumers, value most in determining their assessments of the quality of managed care health plans

To explain the ramifications of two developments in managed care: the new application form for MCOs to become Medicare risk contractors, and the National Committee for Quality Assurance plan to begin performance-based accreditation.


Determining what the differences between men's and women's perceptions of the quality of health care may mean to the outcome of care; hypothesis was that the differences were minor despite women's different patterns of visiting doctors.

The three stakeholder groups view quality differently; consumers want good care and good customer service; physicians want autonomy; employers want value at low cost and good work ethics and so on. Knowing the nature and extent of these differences would help managed care organizations better serve each group.

That the two steps enumerated will cause an increase in health care costs.


The subjects were survey respondents of NCQA and contains 97,873 men and women aged 18 and over) who were enrolled in 206 commercial managed care health plans and completed the HEDIS/CAHPS survey administered between February and May 1999.

Focus groups of employees, physicians and consumers were used to develop information, which was followed up by a questionnaire.

None for this article per se; however, he identifies subject groups MCOs might survey vis-a-vis the two factors of managed care he is explaining


Harrisonburg, Va. area


As aggregate data was used from other studies, only computers and other data handling equipment would be needed.

Audiotape machines for the focus groups, as well as some means of transcription, and means of sending out questionnaires.

Virtually none.


Feb.-May 1999

Several phases, although specific length of time not given.


Acquire data set from NQHA; decide which respondents' answers not to use; decide which variables to assess.

Conduct literature review; use information to structure questions for focus groups; include key attributes from focus groups in mail survey; assess survey response; write article.

Determine what information about each of the two programs will be included; gather information; write article.

Data Analysis


Paired t-tests: Multiple linear regression analyses:

Gender-stratified multiple linear regression analyses.

Ratings by attribute; ratings by importance.


Of nine measures of satisfaction, five show small but statistically significant gender differences.

The strongly significant gender differences attributable to small numerical differences in means reflect the aggregate nature of the data as well as the highly concentrated distribution of mean scores within genders.) On the rating of all experience in the health plan, women report higher satisfaction than men."

Results of the responses of each of the three groups indicated that each group ranked the important MCO attributes in a different order.

There were results in terms of a HEDIS measure of various medical procedures by three groups, commercial populations, Medicare beneficiaries and Medicaid recipients.

Conclusions (the authors')

First, although the mean gender

Differences in satisfaction are small, identifying the top and bottom performing plans for women could be useful information for consumers, purchasers, and health plans.... "Second, gender-stratified analyses of the predictors of satisfaction levels are useful for identifying mutable health plan characteristics that are associated with women's satisfaction and can be the focus of quality improvement efforts within health plans.

Third, the study suggests ways in which consumer satisfaction tools may be modified to improve sensitivity to women's health care."

Stakeholders of different groups perceive the attributes of MCO plans differently; the implications of this are that it is incumbent on designers of health plans to be careful to design them with those features most important to the consumers to gain greater acceptance.

The new MCO application form and the performance-based accreditation plan will cause health care costs to rise dramatically.

Authors' suggestions for…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Patient Satisfaction In Quality Of Managed Care" (2004, June 09) Retrieved November 28, 2016, from

"Patient Satisfaction In Quality Of Managed Care" 09 June 2004. Web.28 November. 2016. <>

"Patient Satisfaction In Quality Of Managed Care", 09 June 2004, Accessed.28 November. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Integrated Patient Managed Care Information System

    Integrated Patient Managed-Care Information System Identifying a Cost-Effective Integrated Patient Managed-Care System for Concord Hospital: A Managed-Care White Paper This white paper is provided in response to a request review integrated patient managed-care systems for possible implementation at Concord. Because there are a number of sophisticated applications specifically designed for such purposes today, each with its own attributes, it is important to select the software package that best suits Concord's needs and

  • Quality Safety Current Issues in Quality and

    Quality Safety Current Issues in Quality and Safety Patient safety is considered a priority in the health, increasingly complex activity that involves risk and in which there is no system capable of guaranteeing the absence of adverse events, as it is an activity in factors inherent in the system combined with human activities. According to the statistics, each year in the United States, Medical errors can kill up to 98,000 patients figure

  • Managed Care Situation Such as

    These skills are vital for them to make an impact, considering the powerful relationship between leadership strength and influence. (...) In Australia the following study has noted a change in skill mix may be necessary: Rising demand for health services, cost containment and shortages of nurses, midwives and other health workers were cited as the major catalyst for skill mix changes by ICN (2005d in ICN 2006). ICN (2004 in ICN

  • Managed Health Care and Evaluates

    " The bulk of quality improvement measures are working for managed care by providing insight as to what can be done to improve care therefore reduce mortality rates, and maintain a high level of customer satisfaction which in turn helps to build the managed care health business. Population Health Focus Population health refers to the physical, social, cultural, and economic environment in which we work and live (Radzyminski, 2006)." This has become a focus

  • Future of Managed Care

    Future of Managed Care Medical facilities have become much more important today than they were ever before. The complex diseases are treated by treatment methodologies and the equipment that were nonexistent a few decades ago. But these facilities have also increased in the cost of treatment. The medical facilities thus need to find ways in which a patient can be offered services without over-burdening him. The financial and economic situation of

  • Health Care Quality Management as it Applies to Managed Care

    Health Care Quality Management as it Applies to Managed Care In the current age of improved answerability for quality of care, every healthcare expert should be conversant in the theory and paraphernalia of quality management) Quality Management-QM is an all-embracing attitude that pervades the management infrastructure, rules and customs of an establishment. It characteristically comprises of five fundamental doctrines -- undivided attention on the customer/supplier relationships; a stress on functional and

  • Patient Centered Medical Home

    Patient-Centered Medical Home Medical Home How the Patient-Centered Medical-Home reducing cost and improving quality and safety for patients. The patient centered medical home is a platform that fills a need in the current healthcare system. The U.S. healthcare system has been plagued for quite some time with a trend of substantially rising healthcare costs as well as another trend of slipping quality standards. These two trends are argued to be a phenomenon that

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved