Verified Document

Comparing And Contrasting Different Models Of Marriage Essay

Part One: Single female ISO single male. Creative, ambitious, fearless, and passionate professional female seeks a partner with similar values. Ethnicity/race/socioeconomic class is irrelevant. What matters is a dedication to making the world a better place. I do prefer no baggage and no children from a previous relationship. Although we both may have parents with traditional values, they understand that our lives may look different from theirs and they will not pressure us to get married or have children before we are ready. You are not constrained by religion but neither are you cynical. You are as independent and free-spirited as I am, yet interested in a monogamous relationship. Together we can do more than we ever could on our own, and we thrive in each other’s company. We travel together, but we also maintain a home base near to our friends and family. I do not own property but intend to one day after saving enough money of my own and establishing my career.

Part Two: Mosuo female ISO walking marriage

As our culture is threatened by the hegemony of the nuclear family model, we need to maintain our traditions. I am a Mosuo woman with two children who is currently seeking partnership in the form of a traditional walking marriage. I own a sizeable piece of property including fertile farmlands across many acres, as well as livestock. My maternal family has remained entrenched in our community. I take regular trips to Lijang, have several thriving businesses, and have no interest in a marriage relationship. You are a strong, physically fit, energetic, sexually active man of any age who is simply interested in enjoying our time together with no strings attached.

Part Three: Compare/Contrast

The Mosuo model of “walking marriage” is unlike any other, different not only from other Himalayan or Chinese societies but also other societies across the globe and throughout time. Yet the Mosuo “walking marriage” bears striking resemblance to the modern and sexually liberated concept of sexual relationships that do not take place within the confines of the established patriarchal norms. As Coontz (2005) points out, “as both a social institution and a personal experience, marriage has changed more in the past 30 years than the preceding 3,000 years,” (Coontz, 2005, p. 1). These changes have taken place predominantly in Western/technologically advanced societies. Many of these changes are starting to resemble the Mosuo model, which...

For the Mosuo and other traditional societies that are only now beginning to change, models of marriage have remained largely intact because their economic and political systems have also changed very little.
Marriage is a social, economic, and political institution. This is true both for me and for the Mosuo, even though in our ads it seems we are looking mainly for a love marriage. Increasingly, though, marriage is becoming viewed less and less as a social and political institution and more and more as a personal choice. Marriage is often still an economic institution even when we are unwilling to admit it. I expect that my partner and I will share our household chores, just as the Mosuo woman expects that her male companion will share in their chores.

For the Mosuo wanted ad, as well as for my own, the primary objective is companionship. Partnership does entail mutual respect and responsibility, but does not necessarily mean a gendered division of labor. The Mosuo do often exhibit gendered division of labor, mainly with regards to childrearing duties but also due to the need of hard labor in the village. Yetif women can do the same work, they will. Likewise, I do not perceive a gendered division of labor as something that is strict but something that happens naturally as each person does what they can to contribute to the household or to their community.

The importance of childrearing may be the most significant difference between my ad and that of the Mosuo woman. A Mosuo woman does not necessarily have as much leeway or choice regarding her role as a mother. In my society, a woman does feel pressured to have children but can make the choice to not be a mother. As I indicated in the personal ad, I do not want to feel pressured by my partner, his family, or my own. I would like the choice to not have children, and to not feel constrained by an obligation to do so. At the same time, I would like to have children on my own terms and to raise children in a partnership situation similar to that exhibited in the walking marriage model.

Mosuo men will often serve as temporary or even permanent caregivers of children, even children that are not their own. Men are simply part of the community. Actually, the same is true for men in my own society. Many men become step fathers, rearing children that are not their own in exchange for the companionship and love they share…

Sources used in this document:

References



Coontz, S. (2005). The evolution of matrimony.

Kingdom of Women: The Matriarchal Mosuo of China

Stockard, J. E. Marriage in Culture

 


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Marriage Happiness Is Marriage Beneficial
Words: 909 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

On one hand, there does seem to be advantages that can be gained through marriage; especially for females. However, on the other hand, these indicators are compiled through aggregates of large samples. Therefore these findings do not suggest that any individuals should use these findings to try to plan their lives. Correlation does not equal causation and individuals should attempt to make good decisions that are not necessarily based

Marriage and Family Types
Words: 1907 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Monogamous Nuclear Families, Polygamous and Communal Families Family has different connotations for different persons and cultures. In American society, the word is usually meant to denote a nuclear family consisting of a father, mother and their children. However the meaning of family in Asia is different because the family includes the grandparents, relatives and siblings of the elders. Family thus would also denote an entire clan. In African communities the Mormon

Family Systems and Marriage Psychology
Words: 3816 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Psychology of Marriage and Family Systems The literal meaning of the word "psychopathology" is a mind disorder or disease. Psychological diagnosticians, while assuming that the illness is located inside a person, always use the medical model in treating or studying patients with 'mental illnesses'. In comparison with the approach they take, I present two converging and related psychopathology perspectives. The two perspectives give an analysis based on context from the family's

Stacey, Judith. Unhitched: Love, Marriage,
Words: 1993 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Stacey describes the Mosuo as matrilineal -- all family ties pass down through the mother's line, even though it is not a culture where women rule over males. The Mosuo's social structures question the presumed naturalness of patriarchy and that of the nuclear family unit. In Mosuo society, girls are given their own rooms at night from a young age and it is accepted that men will have sexual

21st Century, the Term Marriage
Words: 3923 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Further, "Just as the models of family therapy are, unsurprisingly, isomorphically represented in their corresponding training models and methods, so the development of the clinical reality of family therapy can serve as a methaphor for the training and supervision area." However, in 1988 MFT was truly in its earliest states and not much time had gone by since supervision and training was mostly something that was done and not giving

Sociology Comparison of the Canadian
Words: 3036 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

"In the Nordic countries multitasked family policy system helps families to reconcile family life and employment" (Forssen, 2000, p.16). The stresses and strains of the Canadian system are; therefore, largely absent from the Nordic system. Canada's system of social welfare, being largely after the fact, does not possess the same prescriptive effect as Scandinavia's program's of paid family leave, paid childcare, income redistribution, and so forth. The Nordic nations

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now