Decision-Making In Uncertainty

¶ … Director's Daughter The issue is that the purchasing manager is uncertain about what to do. There is an intimation that the purchasing manager should purchase from Tabitha's, regardless of whether the bid is competitive, but that has not been made clear.

There are two reasons why this is an issue. The first is that the CEO has not been 100% clear on this issue. If he is ordering the purchasing manager to do a deal with Tabitha's, then he has not stated that explicitly. As a result, there is ambiguity here. The second reason this is an issue is because there is uncertainty as to whether Tabitha's can handle the order. If that was not in doubt, then there would be little reason to worry -- the purchasing manager is free to switch suppliers for any reason at the end of a contract. Only the ambiguity with respect to the instructions and the lack of clarity with respect to whether or not Tabitha's can handle the order has made this an issue.

There are definitely some value assumptions here. The underlying assumption, because the CEO brought Tabitha's business card to the purchasing manager, is that Mr. Foster would like MMI to help his daughter get a leg up. For some, this would be seen as nepotism; for others, the world is all about who you know, and Tabitha happens to be well-connected. The conflict arises because the purchasing manager does not know if she is supposed to give Tabitha a chance in the bidding, or if Tabitha is to be...

...

So it is hard to read the assumptions here -- it is never a good idea to make decisions based assumptions anyway.
4. There is definitely information omitted. First, what are the consequences of not doing business with Tabitha? If the purchasing manager is employed at will, this is rather important. Second, can Tabitha's handle the company's four restaurants. There is some doubt about that -- a conversation with Tabitha needs to happen here, to gather than information. Are there any consequences to dropping the current suppliers -- that is another issue that would need to be clarified before a decision can be made.

The information that has been omitted is precisely the information that would need to be in place in order to make the decision. Business decisions are made on the basis of weighing costs and benefits and in this case there are still too many unknowns with regards to both of these things for a good decision to be made.

5. There are a number of conclusions possible. First, the company should entertain a number of bids. The possibilities with respect to those include going with Loretta's again, going with Tabitha's, splitting the next contract, and using some third party. The splitting option itself can be done different ways, where maybe the contact is split evenly, or maybe Tabitha's is given a contract that aligns with its current capabilities, with the remaining restaurants going to Loretta's or a third…

Cite this Document:

"Decision-Making In Uncertainty" (2015, April 24) Retrieved April 26, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/decision-making-in-uncertainty-2150165

"Decision-Making In Uncertainty" 24 April 2015. Web.26 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/decision-making-in-uncertainty-2150165>

"Decision-Making In Uncertainty", 24 April 2015, Accessed.26 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/decision-making-in-uncertainty-2150165

Related Documents

A combination of techniques was used to evaluate, the most important being Bayes Theorem. Bayes Theorem "In its simplest algebraic form, Bayes' theorem is concerned with determining the conditional probability of event A given that event B. has occurred." (Kazmier, Staton & Fulks, 2003; p. 43). In this case, the event A is the increase in sales through the e-commerce site while event B. is the implementing of the decision to create

Decision Making As the owner of a small grocery store, it has come to my attention that current business has been slow, and therefore, requires me to let go two employees of my total staff of four. By cutting my staff by half, this means that I would take on extra hours, as would another employee that I feel can handle the work-load, and can be trusted in taking on the

Decision Making Decision-making Scenario Anderson Children's Hospital (ACH) is an internationally known and recognized pediatric hospital that provides the full range of services from primary to critical care units, located in San Francisco, CA with affiliated care centers throughout the Bay Area. The board of directors at ACH would like to create a mobile-crisis program to be piloted in the City of San Francisco and eventually grow to service the entire Bay Area.

In other words, throughout the transition period, Onetech would create efficiencies and would consolidate its position. In the future however, it is recommended that the company moved towards a strategy of diversification, as this would better satisfy customers' needs, attract them and as such create market power for the firm (Markides, 2007). The decision making process at Onetech The decision making process at Onetech is quite intricate, revealing both strengths, as well

Decision-Making Process in Business Environment The activity of decision-making may be defined as mental processes leading to the choosing of one alternative out of many. All decision-making processes generate an ultimate choice. Decision-making output may be a chosen view or action. Broadly, decision-making represents a process of choosing between numerous alternatives and making a commitment to adopting some particular option for the future (Masood). The Nature of Decision-Making Successful decision-making, realizing where one has made the

The most general critical thinking strategy involves the following steps, outlined by Cohen et al. (2000). First, we propose certain statements or hypotheses. For example, I have written down my thoughts at this stage in the decision-making process if I have too many ideas. Second, we need to think of or actively solicit counter-arguments. We need alternative explanations for our observations. So in my situation, I need to brainstorm