Earned Value Analysis as a project control mechanism: critical evaluation
This paper is about an article that was written on the use of earned value analysis (EVA) as a control technique in project management. The paper critiques one article on the subject and then compares that with another article on the subject that is considerably more involved. The findings are presented.
✍️ How to write this paper — tools & examples ▾
EVA
Earned value analysis (EVA) is "a quantitative project management technique for evaluating project performance and predicting final project results, based on comparing the progress and budget of work packages to planned work and actual costs" (Lukas, 2008). Vargas (2003) also wrote about the technique, and discussed specifically its use as a control mechanism for projects. Vargas divides his work into two parts, the first being about "the different features of each business and its contribution for the success or failure in the implementation of EVA," and the second is "about the characteristics of similarity found in all businesses that together favor or not the use of (EVA)."
Vargas presents a case study in the use of EVA as a control mechanism. The author recounts interviewing different levels of management at three construction projects, one of which that successfully implemented EVA and two of which that did not. The study attempted to seek out conclusions about the factors that contribute to the successful adoption of EVA and those that are important to explaining why the adoption of EVA was a failure in the other two projects.
There are a number of critiques that can be made about the Vargas article. Briefly, the author's lack of familiarity with the English language leads to clumsy, sometimes incoherent writing that either distorts or obfuscates the message, for example the vague, nonsensical clause "superior of the management potential of a construction site." One sincerely hopes something was merely lost in translation here. Writing skill aside, the author makes a bold, unsubstantiated reach when he attempts to "get evidence that could link the success or failure of the business to maturity in the use of Earned Value." The author clearly betrays his bias towards EVA as a control technique with such a statement.
Create your account
- Lukas, J. (2008). Earned value analysis – Why it doesn't work. 2008 AACE International Transactions. Retrieved April 7, 2013 from http://www.icoste.org/LukasPaper.pdf ↗
- Vargas, R. (2003). Earned value analysis in the control of projects: Success or failure? 2003 AACE International Projects. In possession of the author.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.