Enron Companies That Do Not Case Study

Length: 7 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Economics Type: Case Study Paper: #37875990 Related Topics: Bankruptcy, Executive Compensation, Deception, Gaap
Excerpt from Case Study :



Enron hid most of its debts by establishing several LLPs, with some of them being secretly ran by Andrew Fastow, CFO at Enron. By counting only the gains and losses of the companies, but not having to report the LLPs on its financial sheet, Enron's financial position seemed very good. Consolidating the statements would have defeated the purpose of Fastow because the goal was to dump debt, not to report it.

This would have made Enron look less profitable. There was no need to consolidate the two statements to count the LLP loses as well as the gains because Enron executives made sure that an outside company had a three percent control of the LLPs. This was the minimum investment required to stop the reporting on the financial sheets of Enron.

The company wanted to reduce its debt to keep its investor ratings. The company could have issued more stocks, but this would have diluted earnings per share and reduced the stock's value. As mentioned earlier, most of the executive compensation was tied to stock options, so issuing more stock would have taken money out of the CEO's and top executives' pockets.

To protect this money, unethical behavior spiraled out of control. The company bankrolled some of the companies with stocks, and engaged in ludicrous business activity such as ridicules guarantees to the LLPs acting at arm lengths. This and other information gave rise to suspicions of the dealings going on at Enron and started a federal investigation. Unfortunately, around this time all Enron pension plan members were prevented from moving any of their 401(k) assets between Oct. 29 and Nov. 13, supposedly to allow for a transition to a new outside plan administrator (Glassman, 2002). "Enron's great local Houston rival, the much smaller Dynergy Inc., announced a bid to acquire Enron but withdrew it on November 28, having done some due diligence. Moody's, the rating agency, downgraded Enron's debt to 'Junk' (Ca) on November 29, with the inevitable result of forcing Enron to seek protection from its creditors a few days later." (Hamilton, 2004) This is important because everything that the company did unethically to flourish and keep a good rating turned out to be for not. The company ended up with a useless junk yard rating. Again, this underscores the point that being unethical does not pay in the end.

D. The End

Essentially, Enron created more and more LLPs to cover the debt that was mounting (Wilson, 2003). When they could not hide the debt any further, Enron began resting Income and restructuring the LLPs. This cost the company stock to go down to almost nothing. The company eventually had to file for bankruptcy. Congress and the federal government began investigations, Arthur Anderson the auditor for Enron, who should of have accounted for the shaky practices of Enron, was also responsible because they either turn a blind eye or was in on the scandal. Arthur Anderson further complicated matters by shredding audited paper work of Enron's. Many questions still remain and the extent of Enron's deceit still has not been discovered.

One thing that the Enron case showed that Internal controls at the company was non-existence. The company was ripe for financial fraud. Therefore, I would implement the following controls in the company.

III. Procedures Needed in a Company to Protect Against Unethical Behavior

A. Internal Control Procedures

The goals of internal control are to safeguard the assets a business uses in operations, encourage adherence to company policy, promote operational efficiency, and ensure accurate and reliable...

...

With a good control system, the chances of apprehending deception in the company are much greater. Goals alone are insufficient; companies must also put in place internal and external controls. These controls are:

Competent, Reliable, and Ethical Personnel - Enron did not have ethical personnel. It had people who wanted to outsmart everyone and get rich quick.

Assignment of Responsibility - the major responsibilities at Enron were divided among a few people. This allowed the employees to cover their tracks while they were stealing money from stock holders

Proper Authorization - Enron had a board of directors and the main players in the company received authorization from the board. However, they deceived the board in many instances

Separations of Duties - Enron did not separate duties well. For example, Mr. Fastow ran the LLPs and worked for Enron. This was possible, because he was working for Enron and handling the LLPs by himself with little or no oversight.

B. Components of Internal Control

1. Organizational Environment - Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling set an environment for making money as fast as they could. The company was energetic, and it was accepted to cut corners, and to be innovative with the financial plan. This type of tone and mentality from the top lead to Enron's demise.

2. Risk Assessment - the Board of Directors of Enron failed miserably to properly monitor Enron's business practices. They did not do adequate risk assessment before they approved LLP deals.

3. Implementations of Procedures to Prevent Fraud - Fraud was rampant at Enron. In order to prevent it, there should have been more division of responsibility, and a second outside auditor to audit the books

4. Information and Communication - it is not clear if Enron had a strong it team, but a stronger it team would have allowed the Board of Directors to place more oversight on Enron.

5. Monitoring - a company the size of Enron requires multiple auditors. Its relationship with Anderson as exclusive auditor presented the opportunity for fraud.

IV. Conclusion

After reading all of the factors and importance of ethics, let's place one thing in cement. All the actions taken at Enron were to keep the stock price strong. In order to manipulate the stock prices, this company's leaders uprooted and disregarded the foundation of GAAP. This means that the top executives of the company were not acting in an ethical manner. and, as the executives would later learn, they were acting in a criminal manner.

The tragedy of this story is the investors and employees who were left virtually penniless.

Bibliography

Akhigbe, a, Madura, J., and Martin, a.D.(2005, July 1). Accounting contagion: the case of Enron. Journal of Economics and Finance 29.2: 187-202. http://www.allbusiness.com/finance/3502611-1.html

Glassman, J.K. (2002, January 18) Diversify, diversify, diversify. Wall Street Journal [New York, N.Y.] Eastern edition: A10. http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=95001750

Hamilton, S. (2004, June 4). Enron unravelled. European Business Forum. 66-71. http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-3847472_ITM

Supanvanij, J. (2005). Does the composition of CEO compensation influence the firm's advertising budgeting? Journal of American Academy of Business, Cambridge 117-123.

Wilson, a. And Campbell, W. (2003, January-March) Enron exposed: Why it took so long. Business and Economic Review. 6-10. http://mooreschool.sc.edu/moore/research/Publications/BandE/bande49/49n2/enron.html

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

Akhigbe, a, Madura, J., and Martin, a.D.(2005, July 1). Accounting contagion: the case of Enron. Journal of Economics and Finance 29.2: 187-202. http://www.allbusiness.com/finance/3502611-1.html

Glassman, J.K. (2002, January 18) Diversify, diversify, diversify. Wall Street Journal [New York, N.Y.] Eastern edition: A10. http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=95001750

Hamilton, S. (2004, June 4). Enron unravelled. European Business Forum. 66-71. http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-3847472_ITM

Supanvanij, J. (2005). Does the composition of CEO compensation influence the firm's advertising budgeting? Journal of American Academy of Business, Cambridge 117-123.


Cite this Document:

"Enron Companies That Do Not" (2008, May 31) Retrieved August 4, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/enron-companies-that-do-not-29541

"Enron Companies That Do Not" 31 May 2008. Web.4 August. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/enron-companies-that-do-not-29541>

"Enron Companies That Do Not", 31 May 2008, Accessed.4 August. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/enron-companies-that-do-not-29541

Related Documents
Enron Was the Seventh Largest
Words: 27112 Length: 98 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 47234018

Enron could engage in their derivative trading strategy with no fear of government intervention because derivative trading was specifically exempted from government regulation. Due in part to a ruling by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) chairwoman, Wendy Graham, derivatives remained free of regulatory oversight. Ms. Graham, wife of Texas senator Phil Graham, made this ruling 5 weeks before resigning as chairwoman of the CFTC and joining the Enron Board

Enron Was a Texas Based, Low Profile,
Words: 3997 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Accounting Paper #: 8530368

Enron was a Texas based, low profile, gas pipeline Company that progressed from delivering energy to brokering energy futures. Exploiting de-regulation, it pioneered an innovative mark- to- market pricing strategy and started selling electricity in 1995, entering the European energy market in 1995. Enron broke new ground by buying, selling and hedging electricity against market risk just like shares and bonds. In 1999 Enron entered the hi-tech, Internet bandwidth market buying

Enron: The Smartest Guys in
Words: 1034 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 68960826

These acts of corporate rapaciousness make it clear how easily ordinary citizens can be hurt when executives try to make money 'creatively' by moving money rather than producing a product or fulfilling a real service. Enron is often mistakenly called an energy company, but it was really more of a speculative entity. This is another illuminating aspect of the documentary for those viewers who may only know about the

Enron's Organizational Behavior
Words: 3711 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 79670046

Enron Leadership Enron collapsed very quickly in November 2001, and its failure should have been a warning to serious dysfunctions in the entire corporate and financial system, but this did not happen. Its executives admitted that they had falsified its records going back for at least five years, although in reality they had been doing so since the 1980s. When the company filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy it laid off over 20,000

Enron Movie Analysis the Smartest Guys in
Words: 1461 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 48295261

Enron (Movie) analysis The Smartest Guys in the Room-Enron The film is pitched around the America's seventh largest corporation that was in charge of distributing electricity and natural gas. The company was worth over 70 billion dollars in assets built over years with over 22,000 employees, it became bankrupt within 24 days. The employees lost their jobs and medical insurance, 1.2 billion in retirement benefits while the retirees lost 2 billion dollars

Enron With What Is Going
Words: 633 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 39304243

If I was a legislator, I will be doing this act and I will not be swayed or affected by friends and lobbyists alike. Response to Ji Woo Chai: Indeed, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was able to put in place controls and measures to prevent the reoccurrence of the Enron scandal. However, there has to be more done because of what occurred before and during the financial crisis. Thus, there may