Legal Aspects And Considerations Term Paper

Length: 9 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Sports Type: Term Paper Paper: #80368633 Related Topics: Legal Issues, Boxing, Legal Ethics, Negligence
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Legal Aspects and Considerations

"Coaches should pursue opportunities for professional development to keep abreast of best practices, safety, and legal issues within their chosen sport(s)" (Schaefer, 2008, Risk Management Tips Section, ¶ 5).

Challenges for Coaches

During 2006, Bill Baker, a Sahuarita High School football coach in Chandler, Arizona resigned from his coaching position following a 2005 post-game incident which involved him and a player the previous fall. In the newspaper account, "Coach quits over legal dispute: Sahuarita's Baker facing charges involving player," Pedersen (2006) reports that Baker, 53, who cited a lack of support from the Sahuarita Unified School District, also resigned his position as golf coach; however, continued teaching character-education class at the school. The school's district reported that because its liability insurance applied only to civil claims, it could not legally represent employees in criminal cases. Baker denied charges against him that he threw punches at a student and was not found guilty.

The incident involving Baker, as with all legal issues, included two sides recounting "the story" of what happened. In the book, Coaching: A Realistic Perspective, Sabock and Sabock, (2008) assert that high school or college coaches do not need to be experts in every aspect of legal liability in their roles as coaches, they do need to understand the basic legal responsibilities they have to athletes they coach. This paper, which comprises one chapter of a professional portfolio, includes a number of contemporary legal considerations and aspects regarding issues and challenges facing athletic programs that a potential high school or college coach needs to know. Each year, approximately 3.7 million emergency room visits in the United States can be attributed to sports-related injuries. Nationwide, these injuries kill an average of 150 student-athletes. These injuries and deaths not only cost Americans a minimum of $680 million in medical expenses annually, they may also involve legal expenses. In the article, "The 'inherent risk' doctrine, amateur coaching negligence, and the goal of loss avoidance," Fitzgerald (2005) asserts that just as personal injuries constitute an unavoidable consequence of American sports -- so do numerous lawsuits that allege and attribute sports-related negligence to coaches.


The primary concern for coaches needs to be on the area of torts, according to Sabock and Sabock (2008). "A tort is a legal wrong that results in direct or indirect injury to an individual or an individual's property and for which payment for damages may be obtained by court action" (Sabock & Sabock, p. 283). Fitzgerald (2005) explains that general consensus exists that a fault-based tort system like the American negligence system holds some intrinsic deterring force.

The fundamental point of the deterrence claim regarding tort liability contends that the law can discourage parties from engaging in tortious conduct through the enforcement of the threat of liability on that conduct. "Thus, tort law can be viewed in economic terms as an incentive-based behavioral model, in which reasonably safe conduct is left alone while antisocial conduct is discouraged through the imposition of liability" (Fitzgerald, 2005, The Goal of Loss Avoidance Section, ¶ 3). A proper allocation of risk permits courts to impose liability to create incentives for both parties to demonstrate responsible conduct; consequently reducing the incidences of avoidable injury. Concerns routinely arise, nevertheless, regarding the proper allocation of risk regarding coaching decisions.

Avoiding Legal Ramifications

Heat stroke depicts one liability concern that has affected the behavior of coaches and their decisions in recent years. Since 1995, 21 student-athletes have died from heat stroke. During the summer of 2001, "three high profile athletes died of heat stroke during pre-season workouts (and their families subsequently filed lawsuits against the coaches)" (Fitzgerald, 2005, The Goal of Loss Avoidance Section, ¶ 11). During the next year, however, following the publicized report of these students' deaths, no reported deaths involving heat stroke occurred. Not insulating coaches from liability for acts of careless conduct, like exposing them to the potential to heat stroke, Fitzgerald contends, demonstrates a truism inherent in American tort law: Rules of liability may be utilized to minimize the incidence of unnecessary injury as well as deter needless injurious behavior.

Careless coaching decisions, a concern high school and college coaches need to recognize, do not constitute unavoidable risk. Fitzgerald (2005) reports that one study concludes:

Heat-related deaths are either entirely or almost entirely avoidable .... Fatalities like these often meant someone forgot to emphasize or practice what [doctors] have been reminding coaches and trainers about for years. Players should get all the water they want...


(Fitzgerald, 2005, Avoidable Risk Section, ¶ 3)

Numerous other sports-related risks can implicate high school and/or college coaches. "Other examples include overmatching student-athletes, failure to provide proper instruction, failure to respond to injury in a timely manner, and allowing injured students to participate in competition" (Fitzgerald, 2005, Avoidable Risk Section, ¶ 8). Although sports participants assume all risks that arise out of "improper coaching," primarily when they participate in a "savage sport" like boxing, some such ensuing injuries may be eliminated or reduced relatively easy when coaches adopt preventative logistical measures and properly coach participants.

To help ensure high school and college coaches avoid challenges involving torts relating sports related deaths as well as other avoidable injuries, coaches need to invest concentrated, deliberate focus on preventive measures. The following list, related in the article, "Legal and Ethical responsibilities of a coach," represents a number of codes of conduct and behaviors Engelhorn (2011) recommends for coaches to help avoid potential negative legal ramification:

1. Facilitate practices and games in a safe and secure or physical environment.

2. Utilize contemporary knowledge of methods of instruction along with proper skills.

3. Ensure players have the access to and use appropriate as well as safe equipment.

4. Implement both proper short- and long-term planning.

5. Properly match athletes in practices and games by their ability, experience and size.

6. Supervise and/or provide adequate supervision of athletes at all times they participate in practices or games.

7. Supply warnings of risks inherent in sport participation to parents and athletes.

8. Be sensitive to the health and well-being of athletes.

9. When warranted, provide appropriate emergency care (Engelhorn, 2011, ¶ 7).

Lists regarding coaching responsibilities abound, with some primarily focusing on legal concerns and others encompassing ethical issues. "The legal and ethical issues are not mutually exclusive, as many of the legal responsibilities are based upon societal ethics, doing what is morally right" (Engelhorn, 2011, ¶ 6). Coaches are legally bound to ensure athletes remain free from discrimination and harassment as well as both physically and emotionally safe. In additions to the above list of considerations, the Iowa coaching authorization course on coaching ethics relates the additional, ultimately "legal" responsibilities for coaches:

Prevent harassment and discrimination by coaching staff and athletes;

report suspected child abuse to proper authorities;

respect and protect the confidentiality of student personal records;

report breaches of ethical behavior by colleagues (Engelhorn, 2011, ¶ 8).


Coaches routinely develop and implement numerous tactics to help ensure their teams win. The generalization that coaches have the mentality to "win-at-all cost," albeit, constitutes a negative generalization sometimes unfairly attributed to individuals who choose to coach high school and college youth. "Generalizations," Sabock and Sabock (2008) stress, "are usually dangerous and unfair simply because of what they are -- generalizations" (p. 286). In a similar sense, coaches cannot afford to generalize tactics regarding to or ignore their legal liabilities. Instead, coaches can opt to implement one specific defense against liabilities -- an "ounce of care" -- doing whatever needs to be done to prevent an accident from occurring.

The high school and college coach cannot eliminate the inherent risks of competition or always prevent an accident. Nevertheless, a comparative negligence standard would impose a proportionate share of liability on these coaches if/when they should fail to create and/or ensure a reasonably safe context for individuals in their care engaging in vigorous competition. To avoid this concern, coaches can adopt preventative logistical measures like scheduled water breaks, shorten practice sessions on extremely hot days, and ensure reasonable access to medical equipment and personnel. They can also warn students about complex dangers like heat stroke as well as risks relating to the student's use of performance enhancing and/or illicit drugs. (Fitzgerald, 2005).

Sabock and Sabock, (2008) relate the following general factors that can contribute to high school and college coaches facing negligence claims against them:

1. The absence of protective measures. As coaches should anticipate the potential hazards involved in sports-related activities, they should invest necessary precautions to protect the safety of the athlete.

1. Poor selection of activities. When a coach fails to appropriately match activities to the athlete's age, size, and skill, serious injury an occur; consequently constituting an act of negligence.

1. Unsafe conditions of equipment and facilities. Coaches should not permit student athletes to use any piece of equipment until they examine it and ensure it to be free from defects and that it…

Sources Used in Documents:


Engelhorn, R. (2011). Legal and Ethical Responsibilities of a Coach Iowa State University. Retrieved March 24, 2011 from

Fitzgerald, T.B. (2005). The "inherent Risk" Doctrine, Amateur Coaching Negligence and the Goal of Loss Avoidance. Northwestern University Law Review, 99(2), 889+. Retrieved March 24, 2011, from Questia database:

Football Coaches Push N.J. School Prayer Case at U.S. Supreme Court. (2008, December). Church & State, 61, 16+. Retrieved March 24, 2011, from Questia database:

Pedersen, B.J. (2006). Coach quits over legal dispute: Sahuarita's Baker facing charges involving player. AZ Daily Star. Landmark Media Enterprises, LLC. Retrieved March 23, 2011 from HighBeam Research:
Rothe, J.P. (2009). The voluntary use of physical education safety guidelines in schools: Safety guidelines can reduce injuries and the risk of legal action. So why are they often unused?.JOPERD - The Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance. American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation & Dance. Retrieved March 23, 2011 from HighBeam Research:
Schaefer, G.R. (2008). Mismatch, Sovereign Immunity and Negligence. JOPERD -- The Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 79(2), 11+. Retrieved March 24, 2011, from Questia database:

Cite this Document:

"Legal Aspects And Considerations" (2011, March 24) Retrieved July 4, 2022, from

"Legal Aspects And Considerations" 24 March 2011. Web.4 July. 2022. <>

"Legal Aspects And Considerations", 24 March 2011, Accessed.4 July. 2022,

Related Documents
Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology
Words: 1541 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 50460802

Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology All psychologists are required to follow the ethical guidelines found in the 2002 Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct of the American Psychological Association (APA), commonly known as the Ethics Code. Other important ethical guidelines are found in the 2007 Competing Development Achievement Levels (DALs) of the National Council of Schools and Programs in Professional Psychology (NCSPP) and the Assessment of Competing Benchmarks Work

Legal Aspects of Opening a
Words: 3863 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 67676155

Partnerships demand that all partners (both general and limited partners) be on the same page financially and within the scope of the business operations. They require shared a goal and vision for the entity, and a mutual understanding of each owner's role and the parameters for exerting control. Perpetual lines of communication must be available for all parties in response to changing dynamics and the occurrence of unforeseen events. This

Legal Aspects of Job-Related Stress in Great
Words: 620 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 44359292

legal aspects of job-related stress in Great Britain, with the view to helping businesses in Great Britain avoid stress claims. While the article addresses issues in Great Britain, it also illuminates another way of looking at stress. The first article looked at it from a personal level; the second from a group level; and this one purely from the company's point-of-view. In considering this article, readers might note its

Abortion Debate While Legal Aspect
Words: 1160 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 59405250

Even the laws on statute books charge the parents with crimes punishments varying from a few years to death (Need for repealing Hudood Ord stressed, 2003). In such societies abortion is the only solution of protecting the woman and 'the family name'. Unfortunately, abortion is also illegal in most of these societies. The result is that people have to find sympathetic (and money demanding) private clinics, resort to unsanitary back

Legal Responsibilities and Rights of a Forensic Psychologist
Words: 3466 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 29060543

The participants aren't given the right to access the records of forensic scientists. The consent of the concerned party is needed first. A fee is charged for recording keeping purposes. Accessing the third party evidence requires approval of the attorney and concerned party. The forensic professionals should be able to protect the identity of the confidential individuals and present the information in a balanced manner. The information concerned is of importance

Legal Aspects of Marketing Via Social Media
Words: 1053 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 59890760

Social Media in Marketing The four components of a legally astute social media-marketing manager In this paper, I will look at Facebook as the leading social networking site. The four components of a legally astute manager include the knowledge, judgment, proactive and the attitudinal component (Bagley, 2006). A legally perceptive manager must acknowledge the importance of law to company success and accept responsibility for being in charge of legal factors of the