Mrs. Dalloway And A Streetcar Named Desire Term Paper

Septimus and Blanche: Victims of Patriarchal Culture Septimus in Mrs. Dalloway and Blanche in A Streetcar Named Desire are interesting fictional characters who suffer from mental illness in the 1920s. Septimus' illness stems from his wartime experiences while Blanche's illness stems from her position as an oppressed woman under patriarchy. In a sense, patriarchal society has produced both illnesses because exploitation of others, war, and oppression of women are characteristic of the patriarchal system. Both Septimus and Blanche have separated themselves from painful reality and have created a new, less painful unreality for themselves. In this essay we will compare Septimus' illness to Blanche's by investigating their symptoms, the influence of patriarchal culture on their concepts of manhood and womanhood, and the situations leading to exacerbation of their symptoms.

At the end of World War I, Septimus has all the symptoms of shell shock, later called battle fatigue, and currently called post-traumatic stress disorder. "He went to France to save an England which consisted almost entirely of Shakespeare's plays and Miss Isabel Pole in a green dress walking in a square." In other words Septimus went to war for personal reasons rather than political. He seemed to be fine, a good soldier and a hero, until the war was over; then, he discovered he had lost all feeling. Today we know that loss of feeling allows people to survive in violent situations that would otherwise be too terrible to endure, such as prolonged child abuse, cruelty in a concentration camp, or several stints in active combat. Numbness allowed Septimus to see his friends, including Evans, die without losing his own ability to function. Afterwards, however, he can't turn it off. He wants to feel again, but doesn't know how.

In the patriarchal view of what a "real man" is, shell shock is unmanly; there is a stigma attached; thus, he has to hide his trouble. He cannot discuss his difficulty or shame with anyone. Untreated, his symptoms get worse. He passes judgment on himself, blames himself, and begins to see evil everywhere. All the weakness, frailty, and ugliness of the human condition begins to take on huge...


Eventually, he listens for voices outside of himself to guide him because he has lost all trust in himself. He thinks, for example, that skywriting is directed in a secret code to him personally. He believes he hears his dead friend Evans speaking to him, but it is from within himself that the messages emanate.
Blanche, on the other hand, has been raised to believe that women are objects to be owned and admired, cared for and supported by men. Without a man, a woman is worthless. Women are only beautiful when they are young. Once their breasts sag, their faces wrinkle, and weight accumulates, they are no longer desirable or marriageable, no matter how talented or amusing. This cultural belief leads to Blanche's obsession with her appearance. She is past youth, a "fading beauty," and in her panic is "searching for a protector." Like Septimus, Blanche functions well until a crisis occurs. She loses the house and her job in Mississippi just before the story opens. Now she has no means of support. She must make herself beautiful in order to attract a man to take care of her. Like Septimus, she has to hide her difficulty and pretend it doesn't exist. This requires deception -- keeping the lights low, for example, to hide her age. She lies to make things seem the way she thinks they ought to be. Everything takes a turn for the worse when she starts to lie even to herself.

Both Septimus and Blanche are doing their best to adapt to the requirements of their gender roles. Although Septimus is in England and Blanche in the American South, they both feel societal pressure to conform to patriarchal standards. One of the characteristics of a patriarchal society is that masculine and feminine roles are strictly defined. Men are supposed to be independent, unemotional, courageous, and strong. Women are supposed to be helpless, emotional, frail, and pure. Septimus starts out as a sensitive, emotional poet who depends on his beloved Miss Isabel Pole to teach him Shakespeare, lead him through literature, encourage him, and guide him. This is not society's picture of an independent, unemotional, masculine man so perhaps Septimus has doubts about his manhood…

Cite this Document:

"Mrs Dalloway And A Streetcar Named Desire" (2005, November 10) Retrieved April 23, 2024, from

"Mrs Dalloway And A Streetcar Named Desire" 10 November 2005. Web.23 April. 2024. <>

"Mrs Dalloway And A Streetcar Named Desire", 10 November 2005, Accessed.23 April. 2024,

Related Documents

Streetcar Named Desire: The symbolic dichotomy and opposition between Blanche DuBois and Stanley Kowalski Tennessee William's Blanche Dubois from an "A Streetcar Named Desire" is one of the most complex characters in dramatic literature. On one hand, Blanche represents fine, southern gentility. When she speaks of losing the family estate Belle Reve, in contrast to the practical Stanley Kowalski, she is vague about the legal and financial complications which led her

Deferred Dreams The two plays A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams and A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry are two classical plays that are based on the daily struggles by families trying to live life as best as they know how. There in are several setbacks and obstructions that come their way and work against them in achieving their dreams. Some of the hindrances are from without yet

Streetcar Named Desire is a 1947 play by Tennessee Williams that explores the relationships between Stella (DuBois) and Stanley Kowalski and Blanche DuBois, Stella's sister. In the play, Williams analyzes how social constructs and expectations influenced Blanche's behavior and the factors that contributed to her mental breakdown. Blanche's mental breakdown piques towards the end of the play, however, it can be argued that Blanche was psychologically damaged before she arrived

But on the other hand, men lose interest quickly" (Williams 81). She believes the way to catch a man (which she believes she must do to stay alive), is to act innocent and girlish, and she is not innocent and girlish at all. This shows how tragic her character is, and how self-defeating her dreams and hopes are, because she is setting herself up for failure, and she will

Streetcar Named Desire Blanche is a person of imaginative and false illusions, whereas Stanley is a creature of bestial reality. Although the binary holds firm throughout A Streetcar Named Desire, Blanche and Stanley are multifaceted and complex characters that preclude oversimplification. For example, Blanche's imaginative and false illusions are exacerbated and enhanced by her devotion to the drink. Her compulsive and excessive drinking prove to be expressions or symptoms of her

Streetcar Named Desire and the Snows of Kilimanjaro The epigraph of Tennessee Williams' classic play A Streetcar Named Desire contains a quote from Hart Crane's poem The Broken Tower: "And so it was I entered the broken world / To trace the visionary company of love, its voice/An instant in the wind (I know not whither hurled)/But not for long to hold each desperate choice" (1947). Ernest Hemingway also elected