Verified Document

Presidentialism And The Alternatives Article Critique

Related Topics:

Presidentialism Lijphart, a. (1991). Constitutional choices for new democracies. Journal of Democracy 2(1): 72-84.

In "Constitutional Choices for New Democracies," Lijphart argues that the parliamentary/proportional representational model offers clear advantages over the alternatives available to architects of a democratic system of government. The "architects of new democratic constitutions" should take into consideration variables like ethnic minority representation and the need for reductions in unemployment when crafting their political policies (Lijphart, 1991, p. 72). With regards to most of the meaningful variables impacting developing nations or those in need of dramatic political restructuring, the author argues that "the combination of parliamentarism with proportional representation should be an especially attractive one," (Lijphart, 1991, p. 72).

To prove the point, the author provides a great degree of theoretical background and uses ample examples. The author points out the importance of electoral procedures and how they affect proportional representation in government. Moreover, the author points out key biases that stem from rigid frames of reference. For example, the author speaks...

77). The only glaring weaknesses with the Lijphardt (1991) study are its lack of experimental data collection or research methodologies. The author relies heavily on conjecture and example. Moreover, Lijphardt (1991) makes generalizations about nations that either are or will be anachronistic.
In spite of these weaknesses, the Lijphardt (1991) study is valuable in pointing out the general reasons why a parliamentary system may be superior for many situations. Especially situations in which a nation-state comprises multiple ethnic groups, and needs to ensure income equity, a proportional representation and parliamentary system would work well. A government characterized by a proportional representation of the populace in government will facilitate minority representation, allow for greater participation of women, and also foster greater overall voter participation. After all, Lijphardt (1991) points out that parliamentary systems with proportional representation also boast the highest voter turnouts.

Gerring, J., Thacker, S.C., & Morena, C.…

Sources used in this document:
To evaluate the practical effects of presidential vs. parliamentary rule, Gerring, et al. (2008) use a complex global data set. The hypothesis of the research is that the type of executive governance used does have concrete and measurable effects on policy and policy outcomes. The researchers use 14 indicators to measure the dependent variables including those within the categories of political development, economic development, and human development. An analysis of the data reveals favoritism for parliamentary systems because of their association with general "good governance," (Gerring, et al., 2008, p. 328). The authors conclude that parliamentary systems are "a more reliable vehicle for good public policy," (p. 353).

The study has several methodological weaknesses that prevent it from being an authoritative source of data on the subject. Most of the findings reveal correlative, rather than causal, connections between the dependent variables and the type of executive structure in government. Moreover, the potential of intervening and extraneous variables has an adverse effect on internal and external validity. The authors go to great lengths, however, explaining each data set and set of correlative relationships. Assumptions are rooted in prior research or theory. A few more examples of exceptions to rules, and explanations of those exceptions would help bolster the overall impact of the Gerring et al. (2008) study.

Still, the research is ambitious and as thorough as possible under the circumstances. The dependent variables are meaningful, especially because the authors state the purpose and application of their research as being how to properly consult budding democracies on their constitutional development. Called "constitutional engineering," the process of determining whether a presidential or a parliamentary system is a critical issue. It would best benefit the budding nation to access hard, empirical evidence that points to the issues that are most pressing: whether those issues be humanitarian/social; economic; or political. Although the authors come to a definitive conclusion that parliamentary systems offer a superior means of creating good, flexible governance, the question of local or regional diversity remains salient.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Constitutional Originalism
Words: 1059 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Constitutional Originalism A living constitution is a concept that is found in the United States, it is also referred to as loose constitution. This is because it is a constitutional interpretation that the constitution is dynamic in meaning. It claims that the constitution has human properties since it constantly changes .I hold a strong opinion for the constitution to be interpreted as a living constitution due to several reasons. The idea

Constitutional Rights of Prisoners the Hands Off
Words: 984 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Constitutional Rights of Prisoners The hands off doctrine that existed throughout the United States through the 1960s was the notion that the law did not apply to prisoners. It Convicted offenders, who were incarcerated, were not eligible for the same rights that applied to liberated U.S. citizens. The doctrine mandated that prisoners had forfeited those rights when they were convicted of whatever crime they committed. This doctrine made it impossible for

Constitutional Law Debate: The Legislative Branch the
Words: 933 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Constitutional Law Debate: The Legislative Branch The Legislative Branch of government is the most powerful for many reasons. Of course, there would be people who would argue against that and state that other branches are more powerful because of specific powers that those branches possess. Despite that argument, the Legislative Branch of the U.S. Government clearly has more power because of the types of decisions that have been entrusted to them.

Constitutional Law Facts of the
Words: 389 Length: 1 Document Type: Research Proposal

Kennedy referred to international as well as domestic standards in defense of the court's majority opinion. He wrote: "Our determination that the death penalty is disproportionate punishment for offenders under eighteen finds confirmation in the stark reality that the United States is the only country in the world that continues to give official sanction to the juvenile death penalty. This reality does not become controlling, for the task of

Constitutional Rules
Words: 1214 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Constitutional Rules IS OUR CONSTITUTION A "LIVING" DOCUMENT? Americans are hugely proud of and greatly revere their Constitution, and so does the rest of the world stand in awe at the economic and political might of the United States in adherence to its Constitution. Founding Fathers poured out their highest and best during the Constitutional Convention held in 1787 in fashioning a most precious document (Patton 2000) that would define and establish

Constitutional Law Case Study --
Words: 933 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

However, where a state statute exerts control over matters capable of being regulated by Congress under the Commerce Clause, those statutes are invalid because they conflict with a concept that is generally referred to as the "dormant Commerce Clause" (Dershowitz, 2002; Friedman, 2005). In modern application, federal courts apply a three-pronged test to determine whether or not a given state statute is invalid by virtue of a conflict with Congressional

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now