Verified Document

The Great Compromise The Virginia And New Jersey Plans Essay

¶ … Virginia Plan, the New Jersey Plan, the Great Compromise, and the Three-Fifths Compromise lead our current form of Congress? 300 words The Virginia Plan, the New Jersey and Plan and the Great Compromise all essentially contributed to the way in which Congress is today by setting the parameters of representation. The Virginia Plan was put forward by John Adams and basically urged that Congress should consists of representatives that were based on the population of each state. Thus, if a state had more people, it would have more representatives in Congress; if it had fewer, its number of representatives would be fewer. It was feared, of course, by smaller states that because of their smaller population size, they would have less voice in the course of governmental affairs. Thus, the New Jersey Plan was developed as an alternative. This plan suggested that every state should same the same number of representatives to Congress, no matter what its population size was.

The Great Compromise was, in effect, a compromise between the two views: Congress became bi-cameral -- that is, it had two houses -- one to accommodate the Virginia Plan (this was the House of Representatives) and one to accommodate the New Jersey...

Both would consist of legislators who would be indispensible in the crafting of new laws that would impact the country as a whole. Today, Congress is still made up of this same Compromise.
The Three-Fifths Compromise was related to the Virginia Plan portion of Congress in that it ironically allowed the South to count every slave as up to three-fifths of a person, thus ensuring that the slaves were "represented" in Congress, too -- even though they really were not. This was just enacted so that Southerners could feel as though they were not being short-changed in the government on account of Northerners have more representative power in Congress than they.

2. Explain the reasons behind the failure of the Articles of Confederation. Describe the part Shay's Rebellion played in the decision to revise the Articles. 300 words

The Articles of Confederation were weak and intentionally so -- the states did not want a strong central government that could tyrannize them individually or collectively. The states wanted to be autonomous, have their own legislature and be only loosely united to one another in their overall, common aim. The Articles were not designed to do any more…

Sources used in this document:
References

Patterson, T. (2012). The American Democracy, 11th Edition. NY: McGraw-Hill.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Articles of Confederation With the New Constitution
Words: 1097 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Articles of Confederation with the new Constitution of 1787. We will see what were the strengths and weaknesses of the Articles vis-a-vis the Constitution and give specific instances that demonstrate the weakness of the Articles, in particular its financial issues. Default and debt is an American tradition and it was initiated with gusto in the days following the Revolution when Dutch and French holders of American bonds found it impossible

Federalist Vs Anti-federalist Papers
Words: 710 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Introduction The penning of the American Constitution during the 1787 Philadelphia convention was followed by its ratification. This formal process delineated within Article 7 necessitated at least 9 states’ agreement to implement the Constitution, prior to actually enacting it (Pole, 1987). Whilst the Federalists supported ratification, Anti-Federalists were against it. Those opposed to the constitution’s ratification claimed that it accorded disproportionate power to federal authorities, whilst robbing local and state bodies of their power, excessively. According to

United States Constitution, the Articles of Confederation,
Words: 1261 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

United States Constitution, the Articles of Confederation, the Declaration of Independence, and the Great Compromise The Articles of Confederation was the first document attempting to govern how the newly independent states were to act together in their union. However, the Articles of Confederation had significant flaws that rendered them an unrealistic tool for the government of the new states. While not all inclusive, the following are some of the weaknesses

American Government the Five Main
Words: 1237 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

It separates the various forms of government and does not allow one to become more powerful than another, and it ensures that laws are created fairly, that justice is fair, and that the President does not gain too much power. Essentially, it is the backbone of our Democracy, and that assures our freedom and the public good. Critics of the Constitution and its support of the public good believe that

On Liberty and the US Constitution
Words: 2791 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Mill and U.S. Constitution None of the issues being raised today by the Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement are new, but rather they date back to the very beginning of the United States. At the time the Constitution was written in 1787, human rights and civil liberties were far more constrained than they are in the 21st Century. Only white men with property had voting rights for example, while most states

Constitutional Compromises: Reforming the Articles
Words: 949 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Northern states hoped that slavery would eventually prove unprofitable and wanted the Constitution to ban the (external) slave trade. This would not have banned slavery outright, merely banned the import of new slaves. The Constitution gave congress the power to ban the slave trade only 1808, presumably to give the southern economy time to 'adjust' or to determine how necessary the trade was to the economy in the future. Also,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now