Whether The H-1B Visa Rules Are Fair Including Cap Essay

Length: 2 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Teaching Type: Essay Paper: #39160624
Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … H-1B visa is issued to a limited number of applicants per year, and is restricted to persons with specialized education and training. Individuals cannot apply for the H-1B visa; rather, employers must sponsor an applicant they feel is worthy of the visa, which allows an individual to stay in the United States as a temporary foreign worker for up to six years. The H-1B visa class theoretically boosts the economy by allowing corporations access to the global labor market of highly skilled and specially trained personnel. However, the visa class has the potential to encroach on the domestic American labor market by allowing employers to hire foreign workers at a significantly lower salary than their counterparts (Tuttle, 2015). In spite of this potential drawback, the H-1B visa parameters are designed well if the stimulation of the American economy is its primary purpose. I would not change anything significant about the H-1B visa from an economic standpoint only. However, I would urge a reconsideration of the H-1B visa from the perspective of ethics and social justice.

One of the primary problems with the H-1B visa is the cap and cap-exempt status instances. Whereas...


Exempt from the cap are specific sectors, namely non-profit higher educational institutions and their affiliated research organizations (Washington Information Services, 2015). In fact, some for profit firms may be included in the cap-exempt sectors. The cap exemptions make it possible for manipulation of the H-1B principle of preserving American labor markets while continuing to welcome foreign workers who fill positions that might not be filled otherwise. If a position can be filled by an American graduate uniquely qualified for a specific role, then a foreign worker should not be sponsored even if it means saving thousands or tens of thousands in human resources funds (Tuttle, 2015). One of the most important methods of improving the ethical integrity of the H-1B visa would be to tighten the cap exemptions and require institutes of higher learning to prove why American-born workers are unavailable in the specific sector listed.

Another potential problem with the H-1B visa is the fact that some companies, like Disney for example, have been accused of laying off American workers and even requiring those workers to train their foreign replacements (Tuttle,…

Sources Used in Documents:


"H-1B Visa," (2015). Work Permit. Retrieved online: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/421934/h-1b-visa-program-hurts-american-workers

Tuttle, I. (2015). The H-1B visa program gives American workers a raw deal. National Review. Retrieved online: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/421934/h-1b-visa-program-hurts-american-workers

Washington Information Services (2015). H-1B quota for this filing season is gone as of April 2015. Now what? Retrieved online: http://www.h1visajobs.com/article_h1b_cap_exempt.htm

Cite this Document:

"Whether The H-1B Visa Rules Are Fair Including Cap" (2015, August 05) Retrieved December 4, 2022, from

"Whether The H-1B Visa Rules Are Fair Including Cap" 05 August 2015. Web.4 December. 2022. <

"Whether The H-1B Visa Rules Are Fair Including Cap", 05 August 2015, Accessed.4 December. 2022,

Related Documents
H-1B Shortage in Today's Society,
Words: 10207 Length: 35 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 8476703

To protect themselves, many Americans chose to avoid working with or becoming friends with those who immigrated. A lack of trust permeated everything that the Americans did in regards to the immigrants, at least with the men. This was not always true of the women, as they often got along together and shared the trials and difficulties of raising families. However, many men who owned shops and stores would not

Immigration Reform There Is a Broad Based
Words: 2649 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 93795452

Immigration Reform There is a broad based agreement of a need for immigration reform. In recent months and years, immigration reform has become an important political issue. However, there is some disagreement as to what precisely this reform will look like. On one hand, there is talk about amnesty for illegal immigrants who are currently in the country, an issue that has proved divisive (Grant, 2012). One the other hand, technology