This paper examines a pivotal conversation between Odysseus and Achilles in Homer's Odyssey, Book XI, analyzing Achilles' surprising rejection of his underworld status despite his legendary glory. Through close reading of the passage, the essay explores how Achilles' despair at his early death contrasts sharply with Odysseus's initial praise, and how news of his son Neoptolemus's heroic accomplishments in the Trojan War ultimately provides Achilles with comfort and purpose. The analysis demonstrates that the passage reveals competing values in Greek heroic culture: the pursuit of eternal glory versus the human desire for life itself, and the consolation found in passing one's legacy to the next generation.
After reading The Odyssey, Book XI, "Odysseus Among the Ghosts," this analysis focuses on a pivotal passage in which Achilles and Odysseus meet in the underworld. The passage begins: "So I spoke, but at once he answered: Odysseus do not gloss over death to me. . . though that is the common way of war, since it is at random that Ares rages" (Book XI, lines 543–600). This conversation reveals a profound conflict between Achilles' legendary status and his deepest desires.
Before this passage, Odysseus has been praising Achilles for his heroic accomplishments. Odysseus applauds Achilles for earning honor and glory throughout his life. As stated on page 139: "...no man has been more blest than you in days past, or will be in days to come; for before you died we Acheans honoured you like a god, and now in this place you lord it among the dead." Despite being a king in the underworld and surrounded by the glory of his earthly achievements, Achilles harbors a secret wish: he would rather be an ordinary slave alive on earth than rule over the dead. This ironic tension—where Achilles, the greatest Greek warrior, rejects his own legendary status—sets the stage for understanding the passage's deeper meaning.
The passage opens with Achilles' forceful rejection of Odysseus's flattery: "So I spoke, but at once he answered: Odysseus do not gloss over death to me. I would rather be above ground still and laboring for some poor portionless man, than be lord over all the lifeless dead" (139). In this moment, Achilles reveals that he has fundamentally revalued what matters to him. Glory and honor, once the driving forces of his life, now seem hollow compared to the simple fact of existence. He would trade his entire legacy to be alive again, even in the lowest circumstances.
This statement is striking because it contradicts the traditional heroic code that prizes eternal fame above all else. Achilles' despair stems from the recognition that he died young—before his time—and that no amount of posthumous honor can compensate for the years of life he lost. The Odyssey presents this moment as a fundamental critique of the warrior's pursuit of glory: what good is immortal fame if one is dead and cannot enjoy it?
"Achilles learns of his son's heroic deeds and feels pride and redemption"
"Themes of honor and legacy connect individual characters to larger narrative"
You’re 50% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.