Achilles' Speech in Iliad Book 9: Honor, Pride, and Glory
This essay analyzes Achilles' speech to Agamemnon's embassy in Book 9 of Homer's Iliad, arguing that Achilles has effectively renounced the heroic pursuit of glory because Agamemnon's insult — most visibly his seizure of Briseis — has stripped Achilles of the honor necessary to attain it. Drawing directly from the text, the essay examines how shame, wounded pride, and the perceived futility of martial effort shape Achilles' bitter refusal of Agamemnon's gifts. It also considers how Achilles' perspective stands in sharp contrast to the values held by other heroes such as Odysseus and Hector, and how his humiliation ultimately illuminates the role of hubris in driving the conflict as a whole.
- Introduction: The Heroic Quest for Glory: Achilles' original drive for glory and his disillusionment
- Agamemnon's Insult and the Loss of Honor: How Agamemnon's seizure of Briseis destroys Achilles' honor
- Why Agamemnon's Gifts Are Worthless: Gifts cannot repair the shame of public dishonor
- Bravery Without Reward: Achilles' Disillusionment: Equal treatment of brave and cowardly soldiers undermines heroism
- Hubris, Pride, and the True Cause of the War: Pride as the animating force behind the entire conflict
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds every analytical claim in direct textual evidence, quoting Achilles' own words to support each interpretive point rather than making unsupported assertions.
- It maintains a clear, consistent thesis — that Achilles' rejection of glory stems from wounded honor rather than a fundamental change in values — and returns to it after each piece of evidence.
- It situates Achilles' perspective within the broader heroic world of the Iliad, using contrast with other heroes to show why his speech is so striking and unusual.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective close reading of primary source material. Rather than summarizing plot, the writer selects specific passages and unpacks their emotional and thematic significance — for example, analyzing the word "sting" and the phrase "shame that stings my heart" to illuminate Achilles' psychological state and connect it to the concept of hubris.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with context about the Trojan War and Achilles' original motivation, then introduces the thesis about the embassy scene. It proceeds in a logical arc: first establishing what Agamemnon took from Achilles (honor), then showing why gifts cannot repair that loss, then examining Achilles' broader disillusionment with martial effort, and finally widening the lens to argue that Achilles' fall from grace exposes the role of pride in the entire conflict. The conclusion ties Achilles' wounded pride back to Agamemnon's own arrogance, creating a satisfying symmetry.
Introduction: The Heroic Quest for Glory
The Trojan War was fought for a variety of reasons, the most fundamental of which was Helen's abduction from Sparta and her delivery to Paris of Troy. Yet for many of the individual combatants — and particularly for those regarded as heroes — the war was fought for far more personal and lasting reasons. As many of the heroes within Homer's Iliad indicate through their speech and actions, the Trojan War was ultimately a chance for everlasting glory: an opportunity to claim a renown and fame for deeds done and opponents conquered that would not present itself again for quite some time, if ever. Achilles, the hero of the epic and one of its most unequivocal champions, personified this desire for glory that drove most of the heroes in the conflict for the vast duration of the poem.
Yet Book 9 finds him sullen, bitter, and ambivalent about the fate of his fellow Greeks, due to Agamemnon's insult, which irreparably crushed his pride — a pride intrinsically related to the glory he once desired. An analysis of the speech Achilles gives to Agamemnon's embassy in this book demonstrates that Achilles has now disavowed the heroic need for glory, because he believes that glory is no longer attainable as a result of Agamemnon's actions.
Agamemnon's Insult and the Loss of Honor
There are many facets of Achilles' speech that run contrary to the codes of glory and fame that motivate other heroes such as Odysseus and Hector. The key to interpreting these statements correctly, however, lies in understanding that they are all principally fueled by the shame and disrespect Achilles still feels from Agamemnon's insult — which included, among other things, Agamemnon's dispossession of Briseis, a woman Achilles greatly desired, if not loved. The following quotation, in which Achilles has refused Agamemnon's lavish offer of gifts and is explaining why, illustrates how deeply that insult has shaped his speech and his refusal:
"…I will take back…all that was mine by lot, all except my prize that Agamemnon, son of Atreus, stole in his arrogance. Tell him openly all that I say…shameless as he is. Yet not shameless enough to look me in the face! I shall neither help by my advice or effort, so utterly has he cheated me and wronged me" (Homer).
Ultimately, what Agamemnon has cheated Achilles of is far more than a mere woman. By issuing an insult of this severity, Agamemnon has despoiled Achilles of his right to honor — and of any prospect of attaining the glory that Achilles originally sought and that many of the other heroes still pursue. What Agamemnon took from Achilles was his ability to achieve what he originally embarked on this mission to achieve: glory itself.
Why Agamemnon's Gifts Are Worthless
Once the reader understands that Achilles feels Agamemnon has robbed him of the right to call himself a hero — of the honor and good standing required to actually be a hero — the rest of his speech to Agamemnon's contingent becomes clear. The gifts Agamemnon has offered are meaningless to Achilles for a simple reason: they will not repair the insult he feels at the dishonor incurred from Agamemnon's stripping him of his valor. This is demonstrated in the following quotation, in which Achilles emphasizes to the embassy how useless their leader's gifts are to him:
"As for his gifts, they are hateful in my eyes, and not worth a hair…not if he gave me as many gifts as the grains of sand or motes of dust, could he persuade. First he must pay me fully in kind for this shame that stings my heart" (Homer).
This quotation reveals just how deeply the effects of Agamemnon's insult reverberate within Achilles, whose "heart" aches from the "sting" of "shame." It also underscores the degree of hubris Achilles possesses, and alludes to that which Agamemnon himself possesses. The conventional heroic desire to amass material rewards, glory, and lasting renown is rooted in pride. Agamemnon has stripped Achilles of his ability to achieve such glory and has ultimately wounded that pride. With a wounded pride, Achilles cannot verifiably earn the glory he initially set out for.
Works Cited
Homer. The Iliad. Translated and published at poetryintranslation.com. Web.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.