Achilles vs. Hector: Who Is the True Hero of the Iliad?
This essay examines the concept of heroism in Homer's Iliad by comparing its two central warriors, Achilles and Hector. While Achilles is traditionally celebrated for his physical prowess, fearlessness, and divine connections, the essay argues that his motivations are fundamentally selfish — driven by a desire for personal glory and immortal fame rather than duty or love. Hector, by contrast, fights to protect his family and fellow Trojans, openly acknowledges his fears, and embodies compassion alongside courage. Through close reading of character and motivation, the essay concludes that Hector's humanity and selflessness make him the truer hero of the epic, despite his defeat on the battlefield.
- Introduction: Achilles and the Question of Heroism: Poses whether Achilles truly qualifies as a hero
- Achilles' Choice: Glory Over Altruism: Achilles chooses war for personal fame, not duty
- Hector as the Selfless Warrior: Hector fights from love of family and country
- Comparing the Two Warriors: Contrasting motivations, values, and battlefield conduct
- Conclusion: Legacy and True Heroism: Hector's legacy is more admirable and enduring
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay sets up a clear argumentative tension early — the traditional view of Achilles as hero versus a more critical reading — and sustains that tension throughout.
- Direct quotations from the text are used to anchor key claims, such as Achilles' own words about choosing between long life and eternal fame, lending credibility to the argument.
- The contrast structure is well-organized: rather than discussing characters in isolation, the essay consistently returns to the comparison, making the argument cumulative and coherent.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of comparative character analysis as an argumentative tool. By systematically identifying differences in motivation — personal glory versus duty to family and community — the writer builds a case that heroism is defined not by battlefield outcomes but by the values driving a character's actions. This technique shows students how internal motivation can be used as a critical lens in literary analysis.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a brief introduction establishing Achilles' fame and posing the central question of whether he qualifies as a true hero. It then examines Achilles' motivations through the dilemma presented by Thetis, before pivoting to Hector as an alternative model of heroism. A comparative section contrasts both warriors directly, and the conclusion synthesizes the argument by weighing legacy and admirable qualities against battlefield success.
Introduction: Achilles and the Question of Heroism
One of the central heroes of Homer's great epic, The Iliad, is Achilles. Known for his handsome appearance and physical invulnerability, Achilles is driven by a compelling need and desire to have his memory preserved in history. Although this desire is expressed as Achilles' personal compulsion, Homer clearly intended it to be reflective of humankind in general. This desire for everlasting immortality remains an important part of Western culture even today.
The real question is whether Achilles' actions in the Iliad qualify him as a true hero. Most readers of the epic view Achilles as a hero, but a more careful reading may raise doubts about his status as such. Part of Achilles' appeal is based on his described appearance and charm. He has the traditional hallmarks of a hero: a muscular build denoting extreme strength, handsome and masculine features, and an apparent close relationship with the various Greek gods. In battle, he is apparently fearless and stands out as the bravest member of the army. These are attributes that society would expect to find in its heroes, but there are other aspects of Achilles' character that are decidedly less than heroic.
Works Cited
The Iliad. Translated by Samuel Butler. CreateSpace, Charleston, SC, 2010.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.