Affirmative Action: Arguments For and Against Race Policies
This paper examines whether affirmative action policies remain relevant in contemporary American society, with a focus on racial minorities including African-Americans and Latinos. It begins by defining affirmative action, tracing its historical roots from Reconstruction-era amendments through President Johnson's Executive Order 11246, and distinguishing between process-oriented and goal-oriented policy types. The paper then evaluates the major arguments made by supporters — including racial kinship, improved outcomes, and persistent racism — before critically assessing arguments against affirmative action, such as the arbitrariness of racial categories, moral objections rooted in colorblind ideals, and the psychological harm these policies may inflict on the minorities they intend to help. The paper concludes that goal-based affirmative action policies should be repealed while process-based approaches are preserved.
- Introduction and Overview: Paper's scope, structure, and central thesis
- Definition and History of Affirmative Action: Definitions, origins, and legislative history
- Goals and Types of Affirmative Action: Process-oriented vs. goal-oriented policy types
- Arguments in Support of Affirmative Action: Racial kinship, outcomes, diversity, and persistent racism
- Arguments Against Affirmative Action: Racial categories, moral objections, and psychological harm
- Conclusion: Case for repealing goal-based affirmative action
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear, neutral working definition of affirmative action before presenting competing viewpoints, preventing the argument from being skewed by loaded language.
- It organizes the debate symmetrically — dedicating roughly equal attention to pro and con arguments — and uses named scholars on both sides, lending credibility and balance.
- The conclusion draws a careful distinction between process-based and goal-based affirmative action, allowing the paper to reach a nuanced position rather than a blanket rejection or endorsement.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of concession and rebuttal. It presents the strongest arguments for affirmative action first, acknowledges their validity, and then systematically shows why they fail to address the policies' practical shortcomings. This structure strengthens the final argument by showing it was reached after genuinely engaging with the opposing view.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a classic analytical essay structure: a signposted introduction that previews each section, a background section defining terms and tracing history, two symmetrical body sections presenting opposing arguments with multiple sub-arguments each, and a conclusion that synthesizes a specific policy recommendation. The use of thematic sub-headings within body sections (e.g., "Arguments based on racial kinship," "Moral arguments against affirmative action") keeps complex multi-part arguments clearly organized.
Introduction and Overview
Affirmative action policies grew out of a need to address the historic discrimination against minorities and women. Since its inception, affirmative action has helped open the door for many minorities seeking gainful employment and higher education. However, the same policies have also spawned charges of reverse discrimination against others and, paradoxically, of harming the very people they were intended to help.
This paper examines whether affirmative action policies remain relevant today, with a particular focus on racial minorities such as African-Americans and Latinos. The first part defines affirmative action, traces the policies' history, and examines their goals. The second part critically examines the arguments of affirmative action supporters. The third part studies the arguments against affirmative action by evaluating both the policies' effectiveness and their harmful consequences for African-Americans and other racial minorities.
This paper concludes that, though they were instituted with the best of intentions, current affirmative action policies are ineffective at addressing racial discrimination and have even had harmful effects on the people they were intended to help. Therefore, affirmative action policies should no longer be used as a major determinant in either employment decisions or acceptance into higher education institutions.
Definition and History of Affirmative Action
Definition
The term "affirmative action" has multiple but complementary meanings. Harvard law professor Randall Kennedy defines affirmative action as "policies that provide preferences based explicitly on membership in a designated group" (cited in Guernsey, 8–9). Affirmative action supporter Richard Wasserstrom sees it as a "program of preferential treatment…which set aside a certain number of places as to which members of minority groups who possess certain minimum qualifications may be preferred for admission to those places over some members of the majority group who possess higher qualifications" (198).
This classical definition of affirmative action as preferential treatment has since spawned more contentious characterizations. Opponents of affirmative action, such as law professor Lino Graglia, characterize it as "a euphemism for discrimination: the granting of preference to some individuals and therefore disfavoring of others on the basis of their race" (47).
For the purposes of this paper, affirmative action is defined neutrally as any policy or effort to facilitate racial integration in society by developing more opportunities in education and employment for people who have traditionally been marginalized in social, economic, and political life due to their gender, race, ethnicity, national origin, or disabilities.
History of Affirmative Action
Affirmative action grew out of efforts to rectify past injustices committed against racial minorities and, later, women. The term "minority" is relevant here, since recent Census Bureau reports indicate that African-Americans and people of Hispanic origin now outnumber white residents in some areas. However, for the purposes of this paper, "minorities" refers to people of Hispanic or non-Caucasian origin.
Though the policies were rooted in the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments, the Enforcement Acts of 1870 and 1871, and the Civil Rights Acts of 1866 and 1875, these laws served as the basis for many of the civil rights laws enacted in the 1950s and 1960s, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. All of these policies paved the way for the eventual institution of affirmative action (Jenkins 1999).
The policies formally labeled "affirmative action" were first instituted by President Lyndon B. Johnson. In a historic 1965 commencement speech at Howard University, President Johnson acknowledged that the unemployment rates, income levels, poverty rates, and infant mortality rates of Black Americans were all far greater than those of white Americans.
Though he recognized the gains in civil rights represented by earlier legislation such as the Voting Rights Bill, Johnson pointed to how much remained to be done, saying: "Freedom is not enough…You do not take a person who, for years, has been hobbled by chains and liberate him, bring him up to the starting line of a race and then say, 'You are free to compete with all the others,' and still justly believe you are competing fair" (17).
In the interests of ensuring such fair competition, President Johnson enacted Executive Order 11246 in 1965. EO 11246 mandated policies of "affirmative action," requiring federal contractors to "take affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed, and that employees are treated during employment, without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin." Two years later, President Johnson expanded the scope of affirmative action policies to benefit women as well.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.