Alberta Tar Sands: Environmental Impacts and Energy Debate
This paper examines the Alberta tar sands, home to the world's second-largest proven petroleum reserve, exploring the science of bitumen extraction, the evolution of production methods, and the significant environmental consequences associated with oil sands development. The paper reviews arguments from both industry proponents and environmental critics, covering topics such as carbon emissions, tailings pond contamination, avian mortality, and water quality along the Athabasca River. Drawing on peer-reviewed sources and government reports, it evaluates whether tar sands oil constitutes a viable long-term energy source and weighs the ecological costs against Canada's growing role as a global petroleum supplier.
- Introduction: Overview of Alberta's massive tar sands reserve
- The Science of Tar Sands Oil Production: Bitumen defined and its historical uses
- The Extraction Process at the Tar Sands Mines: Mining methods from draglines to SAGD and solvents
- The Case for Alberta Tar Sands Development: Government and industry arguments for oil sands
- Environmental Concerns and Ecological Impacts: Tailings ponds, water contamination, and bird deaths
- Is Tar Sands Oil a Viable Energy Source?: Weighing energy value against environmental costs
- Conclusion: Ongoing tension between energy demand and ecology
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper presents a genuinely balanced structure, dedicating roughly equal space to industry and government arguments in favor of development and to peer-reviewed scientific evidence of environmental harm, allowing readers to assess both sides.
- Specific quantitative data — barrel counts, contamination levels measured in parts per trillion, bird mortality estimates, and PAH concentrations — ground abstract claims in concrete evidence and strengthen credibility.
- The paper integrates a range of source types (peer-reviewed journals, government publications, news reporting, and advocacy research), demonstrating source diversity appropriate for an undergraduate research paper.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies the use of direct quotation paired with attribution to manage competing claims. Rather than simply asserting that environmental damage is significant or that the industry is responsible, the author quotes specific named researchers, officials, and publications, then juxtaposes their positions — for example, placing the Alberta government's self-reported tailings data directly against Timoney et al.'s scientific estimates. This technique lets evidence speak while maintaining an analytical frame.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a factual introduction establishing the scale of the reserve, then moves through technical sections on extraction science and process evolution. A central "pros" section presents the government and industry perspective, followed by an environmental-impacts section covering water contamination, PAH compounds, and bird mortality. A dedicated viability section synthesizes the competing claims, and a conclusion summarizes the ongoing tension between energy demand and ecological protection.
Introduction
The tar sands oil reserves in Alberta, Canada, represent the second-largest proven petroleum reserve in the world — right behind the reserves in Saudi Arabia. The Alberta tar sands are located in the vast boreal forest of Canada, just north of Montana. It is estimated that nearly 179 billion barrels of oil are contained in the tar sands, according to Bridget Mintz Testa, writing in the peer-reviewed journal Mechanical Engineering (Testa, 2008). The great volume of crude oil is seen as a positive, reliable source of energy for Canada and other countries that will be importing this oil. However, the extraction, production, and transportation of tar sands oil also represent a number of serious environmental impacts, which are reviewed in this paper.
The Science of Tar Sands Oil Production
Notwithstanding the fact that tar sands oil is in plentiful supply, one of the downsides of the equation is that it is not easily extracted, which poses stiff challenges for oil companies unlike those confronted when extracting oil from traditional wells in Texas, Saudi Arabia, or other parts of the world. The crude extracted from the tar sands is a low-grade kind of crude called bitumen, a "black, oily, viscous" substance that naturally occurs as an organic byproduct of "decomposed organic materials" (Hirst, 2013).
Bitumen has been utilized in myriad ways throughout world history. In ancient Egypt, bitumen was used in the mummification process. In prehistory, it was used as "a sealant, as adhesive, as building mortar, as incense," and even for decorative designs on pots and buildings (Hirst, p. 1). Neanderthals used bitumen to fasten ivory shafts to sharp-edged tools at the Hummal archaeological site in ancient Syria, and Native Peoples in the Middle East used bitumen to waterproof their reed canoes (Hirst, p. 1).
Works Cited
American Petroleum Institute. "Keystone XL Pipeline." Retrieved February 26, 2013, from http://www.api.org.
Austen, Ian. "Oil Sands Industry in Canada Tied to Higher Carcinogen Level." The New York Times. Retrieved February 26, 2013, from http://www.nytimes.com.
Chemical Engineering. "Solvent extraction method shows promise for recovering bitumen from tar sands." 118.9 (2011): p. 12.
Hall, William. "Canadian official brings 'facts' about tar sands to Portland." The Forecaster. Retrieved February 26, 2013, from http://www.theforecaster.net. 2013.
Heger, Monica. "The End of Easy Oil." Discover, 31.7 (2010): 1–4.
Hirst, K. Kris. "Bitumen." About.com. Retrieved February 26, 2013, from 2013.
Podlubny, Joey. "Alberta's Oil Sands: Opportunity. Balance." Government of Alberta. Retrieved February 26, 2013, from
Testa, Bridget Mintz. "Power & Energy / Tar on Tap." Mechanical Engineering. 2008.
Timoney, Kevin P., and Ronconi, Robert A. "Annual Bird Mortality in the Bitumen Tailings Ponds in Northeastern Alberta, Canada." The Wilson Journal of Ornithology, 122.3 (2010): 569–576.
Appendices
Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. "Chart 2: Comparison of Oil Sands versus Conventional Oil Production." Retrieved February 26, 2013, from
Schindler, David. "Tar sands need solid science." Nature. 468.7323 (2010): 499–501.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.