This paper examines alternative growth strategies available to Aetna Inc., one of the United States' oldest and most established insurance companies. Operating in a highly competitive industry that includes healthcare, group insurance, life insurance, dental, and pharmaceutical coverage, Aetna must pursue deliberate expansion strategies to sustain its market leadership. The paper evaluates four strategic options—entering new markets, developing new products and services, deepening market penetration, and diversification—and concludes with a value discipline recommendation centered on customer intimacy. Drawing on Treacy and Wiersema's framework, the paper ultimately recommends that Aetna prioritize new product development and untapped market segments as the most promising path to continued growth.
The paper demonstrates applied strategic analysis: it introduces a theoretical concept (growth strategy), surveys multiple strategic alternatives, evaluates each in the context of a real company, and then synthesizes the analysis into a prioritized recommendation. This "evaluate then recommend" structure is a foundational technique in business case writing and management coursework.
The paper opens with a general introduction to growth strategy and Aetna's competitive context. It then moves through four discrete strategic options—new markets, new products and services, market penetration, and diversification—dedicating a short section to each. A separate section introduces the value discipline framework and applies it to Aetna's customer relationship challenges. The paper closes with a brief but direct strategy recommendation that ties all sections together.
Growth strategy is one of the primary concerns of any organization seeking to expand. It refers to an overall course of action that allows a firm to reach new markets, introduce new products or services, or create a market penetration plan. A firm like Aetna Inc., which is primarily an insurance company, faces a particularly challenging task in this regard due to intense competition in the insurance industry. However, this very characteristic of the firm also opens new avenues for growth by allowing it to take advantage of areas where competition has not yet entered.
The best approach for Aetna Inc. is to develop a range of alternative growth strategies and then implement those that appear to offer the greatest benefits against the competition. Some of the main reasons why a firm would pursue such a strategy include survival, higher profits, changes in market trends, market expansion, and new technologies. In Aetna's case, it is a combination of several of these factors.
Being one of the oldest and most prestigious insurance companies in the United States, Aetna cannot afford to become complacent — a danger that is ever-present for companies with a large market presence and a long history. Aetna currently offers insurance plans across a variety of fields, including healthcare, group insurance, life insurance, dental, and pharmaceutical coverage. Competition exists in all of these fields, and the only viable path to successful expansion is through the introduction of new services and products and by reaching new markets.
New markets refer to new segments within the current market that Aetna can reach in order to expand successfully. In this regard, one of the largest untapped segments consists of patients who have historically been ignored by insurance companies. One example worth exploring is emergency pregnancy insurance. A significant number of women in America face a lack of financial coverage when dealing with accidental or unplanned pregnancies. Even with planned pregnancies, many women still lack adequate coverage or have no coverage at all, leaving them in a difficult financial position. If a firm were to offer an emergency insurance plan specifically for pregnant women, it could be enormously successful, and Aetna has the means and resources to explore this idea further.
By reaching into new markets, Aetna can position itself as a pioneer in a new field and thereby confront and outpace the competition. This requires a careful exploration of possible new segments within an already saturated market. According to Treacy and Wiersema's framework on value disciplines, understanding what customers truly need is central to any successful market development effort. That kind of customer-focused analysis is the only way Aetna can expand in a market that might otherwise offer limited opportunities for growth.
Developing new products and services would also enable Aetna to remain competitive within the current market while still finding sufficient opportunities for growth and expansion. Offering new products and services to existing market segments requires thinking creatively about how to serve those segments in ways that have not been tried before. For example, Aetna could develop a new product line targeting teenage drivers. Every parent wants their teenager to be comprehensively insured, and Aetna could develop products and services to serve this market more effectively. Such products could be designed to meet the specific needs of young drivers and made more affordable so that teenagers themselves can participate in payment plans rather than relying entirely on their parents.
This kind of product innovation within existing markets is consistent with the Ansoff Matrix approach to strategic growth, which identifies product development as a key lever for companies looking to grow without abandoning their established customer base.
You’re 59% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.