American Management in Mexico: Maquiladora Challenges
This case study examines the opportunities and obstacles facing American managers who oversee operations in Mexican manufacturing plants, particularly within the maquiladora industry. Drawing on de Forest (1994), the paper identifies core impediments to effective management: language barriers, entrenched cultural hierarchies, inherited power structures, and a worker mentality shaped by economic protectionism and a directive educational tradition. The paper then evaluates alternate courses of action — from top-down Americanization to worker-driven communication — ultimately recommending a culturally adaptive strategy that works through existing authority structures. By engaging the patriarchal company leader as an ally, American managers can introduce incremental change while respecting the social fabric that defines Mexican workplace culture.
- Introduction and Case Overview: American management needs in Mexican manufacturing plants
- Major Issues in Cross-Cultural Management: Language, culture, and worker mentality as impediments
- Cultural Hierarchy and Self-Perpetuating Norms: Rigid hierarchy and inherited power in Mexican firms
- Alternate Courses of Action: Brute-force versus communicative change strategies
- Best Course of Action and Implementation: Engaging the company leader to drive incremental change
- Conclusion: Mexico's potential balanced against structural reform needs
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper moves logically from problem identification to cultural analysis to actionable recommendations, giving each section a clear purpose within the overall argument.
- It grounds cultural observations in a specific, cited academic source (de Forest, 1994), lending credibility to claims about Mexican workplace norms that could otherwise seem impressionistic.
- The recommendation section is practical and culturally sensitive — rather than imposing a single solution, it acknowledges that sustainable change must work through existing authority structures.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates applied case study analysis: the writer identifies a real-world management problem, situates it within a theoretical and cultural framework, and derives concrete recommendations from that framework. The use of direct quotation from a peer-reviewed management journal (Academy of Management Executive) to support cultural claims is a strong example of evidence-based argumentation in business case writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a standard business case format: an introduction summarizing the scenario, an analysis section divided into the major issue and its cultural roots, a recommendations section offering both alternate and preferred courses of action with an implementation note, and a brief conclusion. This structure — problem, analysis, recommendation, implementation — mirrors the frameworks taught in management courses and is appropriate for undergraduate business writing.
Introduction and Case Overview
This case study examines the need for American management in Mexico and the benefits and obstacles inherent in such a working relationship. More contemporary and dynamic management is needed throughout much of Mexico, and many firms desire it strongly. Many of the most successful companies recognize that the maquiladora industry must elevate its level of production in order to compete more versatilely within the world market and in relation to what can be produced within the United States. There needs to be a broader perspective of American managers acting as ambassadors of goodwill, along with a heightened sense of responsibility in that role.
Major Issues in Cross-Cultural Management
The major issue in this case is that there are very real and formidable challenges associated with American managers taking over a plant in Mexico. A primary obstacle is the absence of a shared language, compounded by differing cultural norms and standards. These differences make many of the elements necessary to run a successful company quite difficult to achieve. The overall mentality with which companies are viewed and treated also creates a significant stumbling block to managerial success.
Economic protectionism and a directive, French-influenced educational system have fostered a particular workplace mindset. As de Forest (1994) observes, "In comparison with U.S. workers, Mexican workers may not follow through on tasks, they tend to be activity oriented rather than problem solvers and appear to assume that companies exist to provide jobs rather than to make a profit." The central problem, therefore, is the mentality and learned behaviors surrounding work and employment at a major company — behaviors that act as substantial impediments to organizational success and to the achievement of meaningful goals.
References
De Forest, M. E. (1994). Thinking of a plant in Mexico? Academy of Management Executive.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.