Berniece as Protagonist in August Wilson's The Piano Lesson
This essay analyzes Berniece as the protagonist and heroine of August Wilson's play The Piano Lesson, arguing that her conflict with her brother Willie drives the entire drama. Tracing her arc across all three acts, the paper examines how Berniece's ambivalence toward the piano reflects a deeper struggle between preserving African American heritage and assimilating into capitalist America. The essay concludes that Berniece's climactic invocation of ancestral spirits to save Willie's life marks her as a feminist, matriarchal, and spiritual figure whose choices ultimately determine whether the family's history — stretching back through slavery to Africa — will survive into the next generation.
- Introduction: Berniece as Protagonist and Heroine: Berniece as matriarchal heroine and Willie as antagonist
- Act I: Establishing the Central Conflict: Berniece resists Willie and reveals family history
- Act II: Ambivalence, Loss, and the Weight of the Past: Berniece fears the past but cannot escape it
- Act III: Accepting Ancestral Power: Berniece invokes ancestors to save Willie's life
- Conclusion: Matriarchal Heroism and the Survival of Tradition: Berniece chooses heritage over capitalist assimilation
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Follows a clear act-by-act structure that mirrors the play's own dramatic arc, making the argument easy to track.
- Supports its central claim with direct textual quotations from the play, grounding interpretation in evidence.
- Maintains a focused thesis throughout: Berniece's choices, not Willie's actions, determine the play's outcome.
- Connects symbolic elements — the piano, the ghost, the ancestors — to broader themes of cultural memory and Black identity.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses character-centered literary analysis, identifying Berniece as the protagonist by examining how agency, conflict resolution, and thematic significance all converge in her decisions. Rather than treating the play as an ensemble piece, the essay consistently tests each scene against the thesis that Berniece controls the drama's outcome.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis-rich introduction that frames both characters and the central conflict. It then moves chronologically through the play's acts — Act I establishes Berniece's resistance and backstory, Act II explores her ambivalence and personal relationships, and Act III covers the climactic exorcism scene. The conclusion broadens the reading to feminist and Afrocentric themes, synthesizing the earlier analysis into a final interpretive claim.
Introduction: Berniece as Protagonist and Heroine
In August Wilson's play The Piano Lesson, Berniece is the protagonist and heroine — the main character who represents the traditions and heritage of her family, reaching back to the era of slavery and even to Africa itself. Willie, by contrast, is the antagonist: a violent, angry man, a thief and a murderer who takes revenge on the Sutter family but now intends to use the proceeds from selling the piano to buy their land. In short, he is a young capitalist who means to move up in America and claim the place once held by the Sutters — a plan Berniece refuses to support.
From the outset, Berniece refuses to cooperate with Willie. For most of the play she remains deeply reluctant to engage with the piano at all, yet in the climactic scene at the end she uses its power to save her brother's life from the ghost of James Sutter. She also teaches her daughter Maretha the instrument's history and meaning, ensuring that the family legacy will pass to the next generation. Berniece is the protagonist because her conflict with Willie drives the entire play, and the choices about whether to sell the piano — and how to use it — are always in her hands. She is the key matriarchal and spiritual figure in the story, and she ultimately invokes the spirits of their ancestors to save their traditions for the future.
Works Cited
Wilson, August. The Piano Lesson. Penguin, 1990.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.