This paper compares two defining masters of Italian Baroque art — Gian Lorenzo Bernini and Francesco Borromini — through an analysis of three landmark works: Bernini's Fountain of the Four Rivers (Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi) in Piazza Navona, Borromini's Sant'Agnese in Agone church, and the Baldachin at St. Peter's Basilica, which involved both artists. The paper examines the symbolic, political, and religious dimensions embedded in each work, explores the personal and professional rivalry between the two artists, and evaluates their differing approaches to space, sculpture, architecture, and narrative expression within the Baroque tradition.
The paper uses sustained comparative analysis, structuring its argument around two artists and three works to build cumulative claims. Rather than treating each work in isolation, it traces thematic threads — papal patronage, symbolic iconography, the relationship between architecture and sculpture — across all three objects, creating a web of connections that supports a nuanced concluding judgment about the artists' relative strengths and circumstances.
The paper opens with brief biographical and stylistic context for Bernini, then dedicates its longest section to the Fountain of the Four Rivers, unpacking its iconographic program in depth. It then introduces Borromini and Sant'Agnese in Agone before moving into a direct comparative section. The Baldachin discussion serves as a capstone, uniting both artists in a single work. The conclusion reflects on rivalry, patronage, and legacy, avoiding a reductive ranking in favor of contextual evaluation.
This paper analyzes two grand masters of Italian Baroque art: Bernini and Borromini. The central argument is that their distinct styles and techniques are best observed through two landmark works — Bernini's Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi (Fountain of the Four Rivers) and Borromini's Sant'Agnese in Agone — and that comparing these works is, in effect, comparing the two defining representatives of the Baroque movement. The Baldachin at St. Peter's Basilica, a work that involved both artists, is also examined.
Bernini created his works during a period characterized by strong creative energy, shaped by the revolutionary visions of Caravaggio and Rubens. Scholars note that he was influenced by Greek sculpture as well as by Michelangelo's late period. His classical sculptural training is evident throughout his output. Beyond sculpture, he was also an accomplished architect, painter, and playwright — a breadth of vision that gave his art a distinctly complex, multidisciplinary character.
His works possess a strong narrative dimension. His capacity to capture essential moments and communicate them to the viewer in a highly expressive manner is widely regarded as one of the foundations of his genius. The striking realism of his work draws on his fluency in both architectural and painterly principles, which he combined to achieve results of remarkable unity. He demonstrated these skills across religious art, civic monuments, secular buildings, palaces, and urban installations alike.
Among Bernini's most celebrated public works is the Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi, situated in the Piazza Navona in Rome. The fountain was commissioned by Pope Innocent X in 1651. It served a practical purpose — providing water to the surrounding area — but, having been ordered directly by the pope, it also functioned as a papal monument with an explicit religious dimension.
Beyond its utility, the fountain's majesty and beauty were intended to remind onlookers of the pope's power, generosity, and greatness, as well as of the authority of the Church within the state. In other words, alongside its aesthetic function, the fountain carried a strong political message.
Every element of the fountain carries symbolic weight. The four rivers represented are the Ganges, the Nile, the Danube, and the Río de la Plata. Each is personified in human form as the god of the respective river, and these figures were executed by Bernini's collaborators: Raggi, Poussin, Baratta, and Fancelli. The river gods stand as symbols of the continents in which their rivers are found, and their various poses and attributes carry specific connotations about their power and their relationship to Rome.
At the summit of the fountain stands a bronze dove. On one level, the dove symbolizes peace and the divine — it is a traditional emblem of the Holy Spirit. In the context of the Church's power at that time, it also represented the direct connection between the Church and world peace. On another level, the dove was the heraldic symbol of the Pamphilj family, who had commissioned the monument.
Water emerges from a rock placed at the center of the fountain. At the base are a horse, a lion, and a palm tree. Above everything rises an Egyptian obelisk. The Ganges, representing Asia, is personified as a strong, bearded adult man of remarkable beauty. The Nile is represented as a powerful figure whose head is covered with a cloth, obscuring his face from view — a metaphor for the fact that, at the time, the river's source was still unknown to Europeans. This gesture can also be read more broadly as a symbol of human ignorance in general.
The Río de la Plata is represented as a dark-skinned man with coins on a ledge beside him, symbolizing the Americas as a source of great wealth. The Nile figure is believed to have been inspired by a sketch of Moses attributed to Michelangelo.
Taken together, the four river gods — reuniting all the continents of the known world — render the fountain a symbolic representation of the entire earth. The fact that it is crowned by papal insignia communicates a clear message: the Church holds dominion over the world. This is simultaneously a religious and a political statement about the triumph of the papacy.
The Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi also demonstrates Bernini's considerable engineering abilities. For a time, observers feared that the foundations would collapse under the weight of the obelisk, but they did not, vindicating the artist's technical mastery. The obelisk itself had been brought from the Circus of Romulus and is believed to have been constructed to honor a triad of Roman emperors: Vespasian, Titus, and Domitian.
In addition to the papal dove and the four river gods, seven animals populate the fountain: the horse, the lion, the alligator, the dolphin, the snake, and the armadillo. Like the river gods, these animals are connected to specific continents and function as symbolic embodiments of those regions' characteristics.
One of the most celebrated qualities of the fountain is its experiential dimension: moving around it, the viewer continually discovers new details. The statues are partially concealed by the central rock, so that what comes into view changes with every step. This element of surprise was deliberate on Bernini's part, designed to create a rich and rewarding contemplative experience. It is among the reasons the Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi is often considered the most significant work of his career, further supported by its dense allegorical and metaphorical content.
The fountain's importance must also be considered in the context of its time. The Jubilee of 1650 brought vast numbers of pilgrims through the area, making the fountain an ideal medium of public communication. The obelisk is a symbol of the sun, associated with reason and truth. With the dove positioned at its apex, the two elements together suggest that the Church, through its divine nature, possesses absolute truth — and this is why it rightfully rules over the four continents.
The rocks and caves of the fountain are further metaphors. The caves represent darkness and, from a religious perspective, sin. The rocks above them symbolize the Church, and their position over the caves conveys the message that the Church has transcended sin and provides humanity with a path to redemption. Since the fountain is the origin point of all four rivers, it may be read as a kind of earthly paradise; the rivers, flowing outward from this center, symbolize the diffusion of faith across the world.
The rivalry between the two sculptors was only natural to occur. They were both very talented and they both wanted to develop themselves and have the opportunity to create works of art that clearly demonstrated their potential. It cannot fairly be said that one was better than the other, because they did not benefit from the same opportunities. Bernini's character and his social circumstances allowed him to become the protégé of wealthy and influential families who commissioned major artistic works, including the Fountain of the Four Rivers. His social standing, not only his artistry, contributed to his fame. Borromini, by contrast, had a complex and difficult character. He did not secure the patronage of a prominent family and frequently offered his work for little or no payment.
You’re 42% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.