Blue Cross Blue Shield: Strategy, Medicare, and Fraud Issues
This paper examines Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS), a nationwide association of 42 independent health plans covering over 81.5 million Americans. It outlines the organization's origins, nonprofit structure, and dual role as both health insurance seller and healthcare services buyer. The paper analyzes BCBS's strategic and political positioning, including its administration of Medicare, and critically reviews a pattern of fraud and mismanagement that resulted in major financial settlements across multiple states. The paper concludes that, despite systemic failures, BCBS has little incentive to change its Medicare strategy, and that meaningful reform is more likely to originate from federal government intervention.
- Overview of Blue Cross Blue Shield: Structure, history, and national coverage of BCBS
- Market Position and Nonprofit Status: BCBS's dual market role and tax status
- Political Strategy and Medicare Administration: BCBS political interests and Medicare involvement
- Fraud and Mismanagement in Medicare Claims: Early fraud case examples and cost estimates
- Settlements Across State Plans: State-level settlement details and dollar amounts
- Conclusions on Strategy and Reform: Reform prospects and BCBS strategic incentives
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses specific dollar figures and named case examples to support claims about systemic Medicare fraud, lending the argument concrete credibility.
- Maintains a clear analytical lens throughout, framing BCBS not just as a healthcare organization but as a strategic and political actor.
- Connects structural features — such as the association's 42 independent plans and nonprofit status — to real-world outcomes like mismanagement and fraud settlements.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates cause-and-effect analysis rooted in organizational structure. It explains how BCBS's dual role as insurer and healthcare buyer, combined with its nonprofit status and large government contract responsibilities, creates systemic pressures that contribute to fraudulent practices. This technique links institutional design to behavioral outcomes effectively.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a factual overview of BCBS's structure and market reach, then moves into its strategic and political positioning. It introduces Medicare fraud as a central problem and supports the claim with multiple real settlement cases across state plans. The conclusion argues that reform incentives lie outside BCBS itself, leaving the strategic situation unchanged absent government action. The argument flows logically from description to analysis to prescriptive conclusion.
Overview of Blue Cross Blue Shield
Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) is an association of 42 independent, locally operated health plans. Each health plan within the organization is a private insurer that offers coverage primarily to corporate employees. Collectively, they cover 81.5 million people in the United States and Canada, representing 28.6% of the U.S. population. Through membership in the association, these independent insurers — each of which formulates its own strategies — are able to offer health plans that can be extended to other areas of the country by pooling the medical professionals they do business with.
In addition to serving private companies, Blue Cross Blue Shield has partnered with the U.S. government to offer Medicare services. In 1939, the Blue Cross symbol was officially adopted by a commission of the American Hospital Association (AHA) as the national emblem for plans that met certain guidelines. Blue Cross and Blue Shield insurance companies were established as community-sponsored, nonprofit service plans based on contracts with hospitals and subscribers. Most of these general voluntary plans accept subscribers both in groups and as individuals. As such, Blue Cross Blue Shield functions as the standard bearer for the medical insurance industry rather than as its strategist.
Market Position and Nonprofit Status
The Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans occupy a unique niche: they are both sellers of health insurance and buyers of health services. Because the companies party to these plans were early innovators, they were able to develop a dominant market share in most geographic areas. Many experts believe, as a result, that they receive favorable tax treatment, which includes nonprofit organization status and tax exemption.
Political Strategy and Medicare Administration
Blue Cross and Blue Shield's strategic plans are often political in nature, as the organization represents the interests of its 42 independent health plans. These independent plans share vested interests in the same political action, which shapes the policies they wish the government to implement. In the past, Blue Cross and Blue Shield has absorbed most of the operational aspects of Medicare. This strategy, however, has been plagued by mismanagement and fraud. It is estimated that $100 billion a year is lost to healthcare fraud and abuse. Malcolm Sparrow estimates the figure to be even higher — between $300 billion and $400 billion a year.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.