This paper analyzes and compares the capital structures of three companies — eBay, Clorox, and Darden Restaurants — across different industries. Using financial data drawn from Yahoo! Finance, the paper examines current assets, total assets, liabilities, revenue, profitability ratios, and beta values for each firm. It then explores the theoretical considerations behind debt versus equity financing, including cost, control, market availability, and industry type. Finally, it evaluates whether each company's current capital structure is appropriate given its business model, revenue stability, risk profile, and return on equity, concluding with targeted recommendations for each firm.
The three companies selected for this report are eBay, Clorox, and Darden Restaurants. eBay is an online auction website that acts as an intermediary between buyers and sellers. Clorox is a manufacturer and marketer of consumer and institutional cleaning and household products; its brands include the eponymous cleaners, Brita water filters, Burt's Bees, and a variety of others. Darden Restaurants operates casual dining chains such as Olive Garden, Red Lobster, and Longhorn Steakhouse, with approximately 1,900 restaurants across North America.
eBay's total current assets are $12.6 billion and its total assets are $27.3 billion. Clorox's current assets are $1.2 billion and its total assets are $4.1 billion. For Darden Restaurants, current assets are $663 million and total assets are $5.4 billion.
For eBay, current liabilities are $6.7 billion and total liabilities are $9.3 billion. At Clorox, current liabilities are $1.3 billion and total liabilities are $4.2 billion. For Darden Restaurants, current liabilities are $1.28 billion and total liabilities are $3.5 billion.
For the latest fiscal year, eBay's total revenue was $11.6 billion. Clorox reported total revenue of $5.2 billion in its latest fiscal year, while Darden Restaurants posted total revenue of $7.5 billion over the same period.
The "Key Statistics" page on Yahoo! Finance shows that the total debt/equity ratio for eBay is 11.66. For Clorox, the total debt/equity ratio is not available because the company carries a negative equity book value. For Darden Restaurants, the total debt/equity ratio is 136.91.
eBay's profit margin is 27.72%, its return on assets (ROA) is 6.01%, and its return on equity (ROE) is 19.43%. Clorox has a profit margin of 10.45% and a return on assets of 13.47%. It is impossible to calculate ROE for Clorox because the company's equity value is negative; without a denominator, the calculation cannot be performed. Darden Restaurants has a profit margin of 5.8%, a return on assets of 7.89%, and a return on equity of 25.08%.
The beta for eBay is 1.36, indicating that the company's stock is more volatile than the market as a whole. Clorox has a beta of 0.42, reflecting a low level of risk relative to the broader market. Darden's beta is 0.88, which is close to the market beta but indicates slightly lower risk than the market overall.
For financial managers, the choice between debt and equity financing involves a number of nuances. The first consideration is cost. Debt financing carries a lower cost than equity financing, primarily because creditors are senior to shareholders with respect to a firm's cash flows. This can be seen in the General Motors bankruptcy, where some creditors received at least a partial return on their investment while equity holders lost everything. Because debt holders face lower risk, they do not require as high a return as equity holders do, making debt the lower-cost form of capital financing.
A second consideration is control. Creditors protect their investments in various ways, most notably through restrictive covenants placed on loans. These covenants may limit the company's current ratio, debt/equity ratio, or other operating figures. Beyond such controls, debt represents a fixed cash flow obligation that must be met, leaving less money available to reinvest in the business or pay out as dividends. A company may be forced to forgo investment opportunities because cash is needed for debt service, reducing the degree of control managers have over the firm's strategic direction.
A third consideration is the availability of financing. Firms cannot always access equity markets; using available cash for an investment could therefore increase reliance on debt. Conversely, debt markets may at times be unreceptive to a given company, forcing it to seek equity capital instead. For most companies, however, the debt-versus-equity decision ultimately comes down to balancing risk and cost. Debt is the lower-cost form of capital, but it is also the riskier option for the firm because of its service obligations. Higher levels of debt will also increase returns to shareholders (ROE), precisely because the risk to those shareholders rises as debt increases.
Finally, industry type is a significant factor. Certain industries are inherently more oriented toward debt financing than others. Industries characterized by projects with defined lifespans and high fixed costs tend to carry substantial debt. Knowledge-based industries, by contrast, often show a strong preference for equity financing.
eBay has a debt/equity ratio of 11.66, meaning its capital structure is approximately 34.3% debt and 65.6% equity. As a primarily online business, eBay should not carry a high level of fixed assets. The nature of its operations is long-term rather than project-based, which would generally support equity-based financing. Moreover, eBay's relatively high beta implies that the company would benefit from reducing its debt load, since its business is not especially stable. An analysis of the income statement and cash flow statement confirms that there is a high degree of volatility in the company's operations.
It is reasonable to conclude, therefore, that eBay's current level of debt is probably higher than the company would prefer. It is worth noting that the company undertook a $1.5 billion debt issuance in fiscal year 2010, suggesting that this debt was taken on during an economic downturn rather than as a deliberate capital budgeting decision. This confirms that eBay likely carries more debt than is optimal for its capital structure, and the company should seek to reduce it over time.
"Negative equity and excessive debt burden at Clorox"
"Darden's high debt justified by revenue stability"
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.