Chance, Fate, and Identity in Great Expectations and Villette
This paper examines the interplay of chance and fate in Charles Dickens's Great Expectations and Charlotte Brontë's Villette, focusing on how each novel uses these forces to drive character development and plot. Through Pip's shattered illusions and gradual moral growth, Dickens explores how false expectations undermine identity and social aspiration. Brontë, by contrast, uses coincidence and narrative ambiguity to portray Lucy Snowe's persistent estrangement, oscillating between hope and despair in an uncertain social world. Together, the novels reveal how Victorian protagonists negotiate the tension between external circumstance and inner selfhood, arriving at provisional, sobering forms of maturity.
- Introduction: Two Victorian Novels and the Chance–Fate Dichotomy: Introduces Pip, Lucy, and the shared thesis
- Pip's Shattered Expectations and Moral Growth: Pip's idealism, conscience, and moral arc
- Character Expectations and Disappointment in Great Expectations: Network of disappointed hopes among supporting characters
- Lucy Snowe's Estrangement and Narrative Ambiguity in Villette: Lucy's lovelessness, isolation, and narrative uncertainty
- Coincidence, Non-Recognition, and Plot in Villette: Brontë's use of coincidence and non-recognition scenes
- Conclusion: Fate, Hope, and the Victorian Self: Identity as estrangement and variable potential
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It establishes a clear comparative thesis early, framing both novels around the dichotomy of chance and fate and tracking how each author handles this tension differently.
- It uses well-chosen direct quotations from both novels to ground analytical claims in textual evidence, allowing the characters' own language to support the argument.
- It moves fluently between close reading and broader thematic observation, linking specific plot events (Miss Havisham's wedding, Lucy's reunion with the Brettons) to overarching structural arguments.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates sustained comparative analysis: rather than treating each novel in isolation, it consistently returns to the shared thematic lens of chance versus fate, showing how Dickens and Brontë each approach the same opposition through distinct narrative strategies — Dickens through a structured, episodic bildungsroman and Brontë through deliberate narrative ambiguity and orchestrated coincidence.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief introduction to each novel and a joint thesis. It then devotes two sections to Great Expectations — one examining Pip's character and moral arc, one cataloguing the network of disappointed expectations among supporting characters. Two subsequent sections turn to Villette, analyzing Brontë's use of estrangement and narrative uncertainty before examining the role of coincidence in plot construction. A brief conclusion synthesizes both works around the fate-and-hope dynamic.
Introduction: Two Victorian Novels and the Chance–Fate Dichotomy
Great Expectations is a coming-of-age novel — a story of Pip and his initial dreams and resulting disappointments that eventually lead him to becoming a genuinely good man. During his journey into adulthood, Pip comes to realize two diverse concepts of what it means to be a gentleman, and he discovers that the real gentlemen in his life are not the people he had assumed. Dickens structures the novel as a life's journey laid out in three chronological episodes of almost precisely equal length. The first takes us through Pip's childhood and early youth to the moment when he leaves to discover where his newly announced "expectations" will bring him. The second shows the working out of these "expectations" to the moment of their shattering by the arrival of Magwitch. The last leads Pip and Magwitch through struggle and catastrophe — death in Magwitch's case, near-death in Pip's. Expectations are demolished, and past and future are at last annealed in a sober, responsible present.
Charlotte Brontë's Villette depicts Lucy Snowe, the novel's narrator, who flees from an unhappy past in England to begin a new life as a teacher at a French boarding school in the cosmopolitan capital of Villette. Soon Lucy's struggle for independence is overshadowed by both her friendship with a worldly English doctor and her feelings for an autocratic schoolmaster. Brontë's strikingly modern heroine must decide whether any man in her society will allow her to live and still be free.
Both novels tackle the dichotomy between chance and fate, and how the protagonists — namely Pip and Lucy — build their lives around these two themes. In Dickens's novel, this opposition is manifested through most of the characters and is inextricably linked to the idea of success and what it entails for Pip. Brontë's perspective is rather different. Throughout Villette, coincidence drives much of the plot — such as the serendipitous and unforeseen reunion of Lucy, Dr. John, and Mrs. Bretton in Villette at the same moment — but Brontë handles coincidence skillfully, so that the reader has little difficulty believing it.
References
Brontë, Charlotte. Villette. London: Penguin, 1985.
Dickens, Charles. Great Expectations. Penguin Classics, 2002.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.