This paper analyzes Anne Moody's memoir Coming of Age in Mississippi as a form of primary source historiography, contrasting it with secondary historical analyses by scholars such as Harvard Sitkoff and David Garrow. The paper explores how Moody's firsthand experience of poverty, domestic servitude, and racial hierarchy informs her understanding of institutionalized racism and structural inequality. It argues that Moody's narrative critiques the idealism of mainstream civil rights organizations, pointing toward the need for deeper systemic transformation. The paper also considers how Moody's perspective aligns more closely with the Black Nationalism of Malcolm X and W.E.B. Du Bois than with the integrationist dream articulated by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
Coming of Age in Mississippi is Anne Moody's memoir of the civil rights movement in the United States. It therefore serves a different purpose than analytical secondary source historiography — the kind produced by academic historians and institutions — functioning instead as primary source historiography. Moody grew up on a plantation in conditions that were simply extensions of slavery. Her firsthand awareness of what racism is, and what it does not just to individuals but to whole communities, offers a chilling contrast to the colder and more distant historical analyses produced by scholars.
The "Childhood" section of Coming of Age in Mississippi details the harrowing conditions under which Moody was raised. Poverty and the grinding effects of racism have beaten down her family, and they take out their anger and frustration on their children. Anne's father leaves the family for another woman, forcing Anne to work as a domestic servant at only nine years old because her family could not survive otherwise. Moody's experiences with severe poverty are what shape Anne's character and her response to racism.
Sitkoff likewise draws economic issues into the race equation, arguing that the two are technically inseparable. Racism and poverty coexist. In "The Preconditions for Racial Change," Sitkoff notes that race relations noticeably and measurably changed in the years following the Great Depression. After World War Two, increasing numbers of African Americans had access to factory jobs and related training programs. Yet Sitkoff also acknowledges that factory jobs and vocational training are not sufficient to overcome poverty and are not enough for anyone to achieve upward social mobility. Black "buying power" may have improved as a result of economic growth, but black social status remained largely unchanged. Sitkoff admits this fact as he traces the roots of the Civil Rights movement. Issues like pan-Africanism brought to light the unique and precarious status of African Americans.
As she matures and develops her political philosophy, Moody quickly understands that poverty and race are linked. She also understands that structural inequities will not be overcome so long as class conflict issues remain brushed under the rug. Because of her acute understanding of both class consciousness and race consciousness, Anne Moody cannot join in the celebrations on the bus to Washington when she concludes her narrative. Her growing cynicism is not the result of disillusionment with the core spirit of the movement, but rather with the seemingly insurmountable odds stacked against non-white people in America. What Anne Moody is ultimately addressing is institutionalized racism.
Anne remains committed to the fundamental goals of the civil rights movement, but she recognizes that on some level the movement has failed to tackle the deeper issues that plague black communities. She does not use the phrase "institutionalized racism," but her worldview is predicated on the understanding that racism is institutionalized through the restriction of access to wealth and cultural capital.
Anne first begins to grasp the value of cultural as well as financial capital when she moves in with her father and his new wife Emma. Emma has light skin, which raises the issue of her potential to achieve a higher social status — if not to actually "pass." With Emma, Anne becomes increasingly aware of the social hierarchies that permeate American society, hierarchies based on membership in the dominant European-white caste versus the disenfranchised and subordinate classes. As she considers matters related to skin color, Anne is aware that her own mother is dark-skinned. Her mother's role as a domestic cleaner corresponds with being of the lowest social class, reflecting the color hierarchy embedded in American racial structure.
Moreover, Anne notices that racism has become so entrenched in American society that black people are racist against other black people. This level of deep social analysis is not something that Sitkoff or Garrow address in their less detailed historical accounts of race relations. If black people can be racist toward other black people, then overcoming racism requires more than legal reform. A deeper form of collective action — not just street protest — has become necessary. A wholesale shift in consciousness is required.
"Movement's fragmented coalition and divergent goals"
"Moody's critique of King's visionary but abstract leadership"
"Malcolm X and DuBois as alternative frameworks"
Ideally, a synthesis between the idealism and realism of the Civil Rights movement will prevail. Experiences like those of Anne Moody show that the Civil Rights movement was not the end of struggle. The struggle for racial parity continues because structural inequities and institutionalized racism have created problems that continue to plague black communities.
You’re 49% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.