Comparing Website Agendas on Aristotle: A Source Analysis
This paper analyzes four online sources about Aristotle — the World Book Online, St. Andrews College's mathematics database, UC Berkeley's Evolution Homepage, and Philosophy Pages — evaluating how each site's institutional affiliation, intended audience, and underlying agenda shape its presentation of the philosopher. The paper argues that each source selectively emphasizes different aspects of Aristotle's legacy: general biography, mathematical reasoning, proto-scientific empiricism, or accessible philosophy overview. By comparing vocabulary level, use of direct quotation, credentialing, and editorial tone, the paper demonstrates that no single online source offers a fully comprehensive or neutral treatment of Aristotle.
- Introduction: Searching for Aristotle Online: Aristotle's broad significance and the range of online sources
- World Book Online: Biography for the General Reader: World Book presents Aristotle accessibly, encouraging deeper reading
- St. Andrews College: Aristotle as Mathematical Pioneer: St. Andrews claims Aristotle for rigorous mathematical philosophy
- UC Berkeley Evolution Homepage: Aristotle and the Scientific Method: Berkeley frames Aristotle as a precursor to modern science
- Philosophy Pages: Surface-Level Overview or Advertising Portal?: Philosophy Pages offers superficial content with weak credentials
- Conclusion: Agenda, Audience, and Credibility: Each source reflects its own institutional bias and agenda
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper applies a consistent evaluative framework — agenda, intended audience, vocabulary level, and credentialing — to each source in turn, making comparison easy to follow.
- It moves from the most credible sources (institutional encyclopedias and university departments) toward the least, building a clear hierarchy of reliability.
- The critical treatment of Philosophy Pages, including the observation that the author lists no credentials and the site functions partly as an advertising portal, shows genuine analytical skepticism rather than simple summary.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates comparative source evaluation — assessing multiple information sources against shared criteria rather than treating each in isolation. By holding agenda, audience, and institutional authority constant across all four sources, the writer produces a genuinely comparative argument rather than four separate summaries.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing of Aristotle's significance before moving through each source in its own paragraph. Each paragraph follows a consistent internal pattern: describe the site's content, identify its intended audience, state its agenda, and evaluate its reliability. A short Works Cited section closes the paper. The structure is source-by-source rather than thematic, which suits the comparative nature of the assignment.
Introduction: Searching for Aristotle Online
Aristotle was one of the great founders of Greek ethical, scientific, mathematical, and human philosophy, and perhaps the greatest founder of modern critical scientific empiricism. Typing his name into a Google search engine therefore returns a wealth of results. The four sources examined here — the World Book Online, St. Andrews College's mathematics database, the UC Berkeley Evolution Homepage, and Philosophy Pages — each approach the philosopher with a distinct agenda shaped by institutional purpose and intended audience.
World Book Online: Biography for the General Reader
The first result worth examining, from the World Book Online reference center, contains an introduction to Aristotle's life, teachings, and historical significance. Its main concern is to convey the complex and often intimidating subject of Greek philosophy to a general reader in clear, factual terms. Its agenda — if that word can be applied without sounding overly suspicious — is to encourage students to seek out the philosopher's writings with greater interest and depth. To that end, the site provides many helpful links to pages hosting the complete texts of Aristotle's actual works.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.